4 ms·
No, I wouldn't. I believe that peddling pornography is the same as peddling drugs -- both are addictive, dangerous substances that do great harm to families. No
by cookiecaper 17y ago
No, I wouldn't. I believe that peddling pornography is the same as peddling drugs -- both are addictive, dangerous substances that do great harm to families. No matter how much easy money is in it (and there's a lot), I would keep my name and any money I had as far away from it as possible.
- johnfn 17y ago> ..addictive, dangerous substances that do great harm to families. Wait, what? For one, I hardly think that porn the primary cause of any damage to a family; I would think that any family damage blamed on it probably has some deeper seated problems than porn. I further think that you would be hard pressed to prove that it is dangerous, especially when people are seeing actual naked people all the time without any damage. Addictive is arguable until the cows come home, mainly because addictive is a very subjective word.
- petercooper 17y agoStudies back up your hunches: And in every region investigated, researchers have found that as pornography has increased in availability, sex crimes have either decreased or not increased. And: Now let’s look at attitudes towards women. Studies of men who had seen X-rated movies found that they were significantly more tolerant and accepting of women than those men who didn’t see those movies, and studies by other investigators—female as well as male—essentially found similarly that there was no detectable relationship between the amount of exposure to pornography and any measure of misogynist attitudes. No researcher or critic has found the opposite, that exposure to pornography—by any definition—has had a cause-and-effect relationship towards ill feelings or actions against women. No correlation has even been found between exposure to porn and calloused attitudes toward women. Read more: Porn: Good for us? - The Scientist - http://www.the-scientist.com/2010/3/1/29/1/ http://www.the-scientist.com/2010/3/1/29/1/ The anti-porn brigade is just as bigoted as the anti video game brigade.
- jrockway 17y agoThe anti-porn brigade is just as bigoted as the anti video game brigade. Porn and video games are enjoyable. Enjoying your life is a sin! Don't you get it? Now get back down into that salt mine!
- cookiecaper 17y agoPlease. There was a long thread about that link here just the other day. Correlation is not causation; the decrease in sex crimes over the last thirty years cannot just be attributed to the increase in availability of pornography, as the authors of that paper seem to think. See http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1184510 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1184510 for discussion about your link and its dubious methods.
- mos1 17y agoPsst, your double-standard is showing.
- jrockway 17y agoBut think of all those sperm cells that did nothing more than moisten a kleenex. All of those are future babies that were basically murdered in cold blood!!!
- jrockway 17y agoWhat damage to families does porn cause? The same damage that condoms do? (If people can get off without making children, that's bad right?) Also, what if I don't have a family? Does that mean I can use porn and drugs with impunity, since there is no family to harm? Or does it magically harm other families, perhaps via some obscure quantum effect that the Large Hadron Collider is studying? I would keep my name and any money I had as far away from it as possible. So far away that you read articles about it and post your "opinion"? Anyway, this comment was amusing to read. Now to see if you are actually serious, which would, admittedly, make it a lot less funny.
- cookiecaper 17y agoThis wasn't an article, just a straightforward question posted on a forum I frequent. It damages families in a lot of ways. Porn users are almost universally addicts; you might say you're not, but if you're a regular consumer, try to go without it and see how long you last. I challenge all naysayers to do that. A few can do so without much effort, but the vast majority can't. This reality is opposite of the lie that most will claim. There are accounts all over of addiction to porn and the feelings that it causes. Companions feel inadequate compared to the airbrushed, artificial bodies their companions lust after. Porn users perceive the subjects of their pornography in an abnormally sexualized light and it diminishes their emotional and intellectual sensitivity. Pornography steals time, productivity, and money from its users; it is not a wholesome, upbuilding recreational activity as some here say, it is not comparable to video games. It is degrading to its subjects and its users. Pornography, like drugs, is a mechanism to enrich a few for the moral entrapment of its many users. Porn users become addicted and can't stop using it. They go back for more and more. They desire harder and harder material. They seek to mimic what they see in their preferred pornographic material. How is any of this desirable? Pornography has a large negative effect on its users. That's absolutely true and no amount of studies, hopes, oblations, snarky comments, or any other thing can change that.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- bhseo 17y ago
- jacquesm 17y agoWow, where to begin... I am not in the least interested in porn, I prefer my bed partners in the flesh, but I find it interesting that you say these things with such certainty. Families as such are not harmed by porn in any but the rarest cases, and then usually there are other factors besides. There are people that are harmed by porn, but rarely directly, more usually as a by-product of a society that tries to control the behaviour of it's citizens. The same arguments you make have been made countless times about prostitution, and are used to outlaw it in many countries. But the cold hard facts are that prostitution exists everywhere, even where it is outlawed. And yet, only there you will find excessive violence, disease and rampant drug use. The reason for that is that by making it illegal the 'sex workers' as they're called get pushed in to being criminals, and that means they lose the protection that every other person is normally given. They can not go to the police when a customer (or their pimp) beats them up. They tend to have unsafe sex, the tend to use drugs. Whereas in places where prostitution is legal prostitutes are treated no different from other professionals, they pay their taxes, they are protected by the law from their customers, instead of their pimps, they get regular medical checkups and so on. With porn, it is similar. There are lots of people that simply enjoy it. Just like lots of people simply enjoy sex. Looking at it doesn't make you go blind, it won't 'harm your family'. As long as all parties involved in the consumption and the production of it are adults and are doing it of their own free will I have absolutely no problem with it. As I wrote above, I have a website that has an 'adult part'. It was never my intention to be the webmaster of a site that is NSFW. But when it happened I learned something about my self. That I'm probably more of a prude than I ever thought I was, mostly because the fact that I thought that these people were using my software for a purpose that I could not even envision were somehow betraying me. But I learned over time that I was wrong. They simply have a different viewpoint than I do, and they are - to put it bluntly - right, and I was wrong. And they are completely in the right to use the software that I put in to the world to use for whatever purpose they feel like, as long as it is legal. They're in their own houses, they are safe from stalkers and other real life nuisances, and they enjoy what they do, be it that they're nudists or people that get it on in front of the cam, whatever works for them. So, I learned to control my 'kill' instincts, and let go of it. The practical upshot of that is that we have a website which is separated in to two portions, one that is non-adult, and one that is adult. The non-adult cams are about 85%, about 15% is adult. On the viewer side it is probably the reverse. People are asked to label their content using a switch in the software, and any abuse of that switch (there are always jerks) is punished by a very permanent ban. So, we all get to live in peace, those that care for porn, and those that don't. As for my reasons for wanting to get out of this, I've been doing it for more than a decade and it is really time for fresh blood, besides that as I said I never wanted to be the webmaster of a NSFW site. But that's my limitation, not one of the people on that site.
- javert 17y agoWoah, people! Down votes on HN comments are only supposed to be used for malicious or spammy comments. He's expressed a valid opinion. Don't downvote.
- mos1 17y agoHe implied that anybody who has pornography and a family is "doing great harm" to their family, and engaging in "dangerous" activity, and offered no reasonable basis for his widespread accusation. That's pretty clearly malicious, and it most definitely breaks the "would you say this at a dinner party if you wanted to be invited back?" rule.
- cookiecaper 17y agoI guess that depends on who's populating the dinner party. Usually the subject of pornography wouldn't come up at all, so it wouldn't be a concern.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sown 17y agoNot really. He made broad, sweeping and unreasonable assertions, incorrect assumptions and no one has any real reason to believe anything written up there. It was a personal opinion that many disagree with.
- cookiecaper 17y ago>Not really. He made broad, sweeping and unreasonable assertions, incorrect assumptions and no one has any real reason to believe anything written up there. I shouldn't have to convince you to be respected. I have other things to do with my life than gather together a compendium of research on porn. The truth is out there for all to see. You can find it yourself if you want to. The thing is not malicious, it's just an alternative opinion. I don't stand in your way, you are free to live your life as you like. If I condemn a thing you want to think is good, you don't need to take personal offense, just politely disagree and let's all be on our ways. EDIT: I'm truly curious to see this one get downvotes. Do you guys really want people to call you out on every opposing opinion and make you run to and fro gathering a corpus of data, anecdotes, and other evidence to support every claim you make? I just don't have the time for it, and I don't have the interest because I know that I won't be changing any minds here, it'll just get written off with, "Well that psychologist/victim/whatever is a religionist so obviously he's backward", etc. Be sensible here, please.
- mos1 17y agoYour comment says boatloads about you, but little about porn.