3 ms·
Apparently you missed the memo... nobody who is successful got there through hard work, sacrifice, initiative, or diligent application of their own will. It's
by mindcrime 10y ago
Apparently you missed the memo... nobody who is successful got there through hard work, sacrifice, initiative, or diligent application of their own will. It's all a result of luck and/or leaching off of the backs of the exploited masses.
- back_beyond 10y agoApparently I did miss the memo. All successful people are a result of luck and leaching. TIL. Actually that is, in my opinion, a perverted world view. Surely you don't believe it.
- pwnna 10y agoI think the parent is trying to say that successful people all have luck, while not all hard working people are successful. I feel this is a correct, one way relation, as being born in the right country is luck in itself.
- back_beyond 10y agoSure, this is something that I can support. The parent post seemed too simplistic a characterization.
- mindcrime 10y agoThat (my post above) was sarcasm, for anybody who missed it.
- cesarbs 10y ago> It's all a result of luck and/or leaching off of the backs of the exploited masses. I can't accept someone truly believes that. You are polarizing this discussion. While it is known that people born with an advantage have a higher chance of succeeding in life, those people have to do their part in order to succeed. That means seizing opportunities offered to them, studying hard, working hard. They might have had an easier time having access to things, but that doesn't mean they could just slack off and yet succeed.
- mindcrime 10y agoI can't accept someone truly believes that. Yeah, seems incredible to me as well. But reading some of the rhetoric flowing around here over the past couple of years, it seems to be an amazingly popular point of view.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoMy grandfather survived 5 beach landings in WWII and came home to open a restaurant. He worked every day (you have to or people in that industry will steal from you) to provide for his family. The only luck or exploitation he had was having the bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki so he didn't have to die on a Japanese beach (his medical records at that time listed him as suffering from typhoid and dysentery - but because the war effort was stretched so thin, he was also listed as "combat ready". He would have died)
- r00fus 10y agoYou forget - taxes pay for all sorts of infrastructure, the legal system, and the underlying mechanics that allow those successful people to find success. Tell me with a straight face that the next big startup is going to come from Somalia or hell, even Flint, Michigan.
- mindcrime 10y agoI'm not following how that has anything to do with the comment you replied to. I personally am actually very anti-tax, but that's an orthogonal issue as to whether or not individual effort counts for anything or not, and whether or not "it's all luck". Note too that "success" doesn't necessarily have to mean "building a startup and having a big exit." There are many levels of success.
- r00fus 10y agoLet me simplify: taxes are critical for basic infrastructure that makes you successful at all levels. If you want zero taxes, go build a business in a jurisdiction that doesn't have them and see how you fare.