11 ms·
Los Angeles is suing a landlord for evicting tenants to rent units on Airbnb
- a_small_island 10y agoThat title needs work, I had no idea what it meant until I clicked the article.
- zodiac 10y agoPrepositional phrase attachment ambiguity! http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=17711 http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=17711
- rewrew 10y agoYup -- it's missing the word "landlords" after the word suing
- dang 10y agoOk, we'll add that.
- prostoalex 10y agoSorry about that, with HN's 80-character restriction and QZ's affection for paragraph-long titles it had to be contracted somehow without being rewritten.
- jseliger 10y agoIf L.A. is worried about housing affordability, the real solution is to build more housing: http://la.curbed.com/2015/3/18/9979526/housing-crisis-los-angeles-construction http://la.curbed.com/2015/3/18/9979526/housing-crisis-los-an...: While Los Angeles County built the most out of any California county in the years between 1980 and 2010, it was waaaay less than it needed to keep housing prices from getting ridiculous. For comparison, in the same 30-year period, "the number of housing units in the typical U.S. metro grew by 54 percent, compared with 32 percent for the state's coastal metros. Home building was even slower in Los Angeles and San Francisco, where the housing stock grew by only around 20 percent." We have the technologies to increase housing supply, but we've collectively made deploying them illegal.
- danhak 10y ago> If L.A. is worried about housing affordability, the real solution is to build more housing And that's precisely what the city is doing. Housing permits are up around 40% YOY, about 70% of which are for multi-family units. But that's not directly related to the purpose of rent control, which is not to keep housing throughout the city affordable, but to keep longtime residents--especially older individuals--from swiftly getting priced out of their particular community. At any rate, I'm not sure how construction of new housing in Los Angeles has been "made illegal" as you suggest.
- fuzzywalrus 10y agoIn addition to the comment above, I'd view this as an update to zoning laws and renter's rights. As we become increasingly a nation of renters instead of owners, these sort of issues need to be addressed.
- bogomipz 10y agoGreat point. But not only are we becoming a nation of renters but we have also become a world of urban dwellers. Additionally as wealth becomes more concentrated more residential real estate purchases are not primary residences but income properties and in many cases a means of hiding money. The majority of new construction in many large cities appear to be "Luxury Condos", glass and steel structures designed to attract "hot money" inflows and not targeting the working or middle classes. I encourage you to read the following: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreign-wealth-flows-to-time-warner-condos.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/08/nyregion/stream-of-foreign... http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/07/nyregion/more-apartments-are-empty-yet-rented-or-owned-census-finds.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/07/nyregion/more-apartments-a... These are in now way restricted to New York either. This is happening in Shanghai, London, San Francisco etc.
- mturmon 10y agoThank you for making an accurate reply. It is worth noting that the situation in LA is very different than in SF -- people may be using the state of affairs in SF as a comparative, and it's just not the same: there is now and has been much more intensive housing development in LA. Certainly there are many NIMBYs in LA, but the regulations in LA are not tilted as strongly against development as they are in SF. In the past years, there has been a lot of infill development in Hollywood (especially), mid-Wilshire, and around downtown. It has been encouraged by changes in zoning regulations that lift some parking and density rules, especially along transit corridors. These changes have been supported by two mayors now, and by most of the City Council. (One of the sued parties in the OP had units in mid-Wilshire, and another in Hollywood; the other two were in Venice.) Here's a very selective overview of some new Hollywood projects: http://urbanize.la/post/hollywood-construction-binge-revisited http://urbanize.la/post/hollywood-construction-binge-revisit... -- but the story is similar in many other neighborhoods. The resulting density increases have caused considerable gnashing of teeth among older residents, who think of LA as a city of single family residences. There is going to be a proposition on the ballot soon, seeking restrictions on this development, and it's not clear where things will shake out (http://la.curbed.com/2016/1/21/10844688/los-angeles-anti-development-ballot-measure-neighborhood-integrity http://la.curbed.com/2016/1/21/10844688/los-angeles-anti-dev...). I don't see it passing, but it's too early to be sure. It's also worth saying that it's often poor renters who are forced out by these changes -- their little three-story apartment building is torn down and replaced by a 6-story mixed-use building. That's the message the City Attorney is trying to get across to landlords.
- univalent 10y agoWhat are they complaining about. Under the new 'sharing' economy, you don't need to rent one place anymore. You can simply hop week to week from one AirBnB rental to another without being tied down. And you can also hop between jobs as you like without being tied down. This is all in your benefit. Isn't the new 'sharing economy' great?
- Spooky23 10y agoWhy get a job? The world is moving to gigs man. Solve the oft-cited zoning crisis that is preventing tall building from low density places like Manhattan and build massive apartment blocks. Then you'll just need a few fiverr gigs a week and boom, you can rent a different, exciting new apartment every day!
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y ago> "[...] abuse platforms like ours in search of a quick buck,” Airbnb says in a statement. Ah, the verb conjugation game, always fun: - I dare. (or disrupt, usage varies.) - You transgress. - He abuses.
- eric_h 10y agoYou omitted the plural in your [...] - He abuses - They (real estate speculators) abuse.
- thedufer 10y agoI don't think parent was pointing out a conjugation mistake. Rather, the point is how we will use different words to describe the same event depending on perspective - in order from least to most harsh, first-, second-, and third-person.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoThe only noteworthy aspect of this story is that the city attorney is actually taking this particular rent-control law seriously enough to sue a landlord. A lot of other laws are violated and the city attorney (and law enforcement agencies in general) just ignore the violations. So this tells us a bit about prosecutorial discretion in LA at the current time.
- FussyZeus 10y agoSo a landlord pulled an illegal dick move and is being sued for it by the city in accordance with their laws. Why is this newsworthy? Oh right, because putting "sued" and "airbnb" in the title equals clicks, despite Airbnb having jack shit to do with this case beyond being the unfortunate 3rd party.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoI agree. And right in the article itself it says that even AirBnB stands opposed to the kind of illegal move these landlords made: >"... we strongly oppose real estate speculators who illegally evict tenants and abuse platforms like ours in search of a quick buck,” Airbnb says in a statement.
- thenewwazoo 10y agoYes, they oppose it so strongly they refuse to continue to do business wi- ... oh, they still cash the cheques? Well then. How much is that opposition worth?
- HillaryBriss 10y agoyes. good point.
- FussyZeus 10y agoSo Airbnb is now responsible for enforcing local laws for all it's applicants, even though a huge majority are up to no such shenans? This is such a non-problem it's ridiculous. The regulation to prevent this not only was proposed, not only was enacted, it's now being enforced by the city with damages likely to be awarded to the fouled renters. This is literally the best case scenario for one of these "grey area" startups causing some problems for regular people that has already been covered by proper regulation.
- st3v3r 10y agoHonestly, if they want their "We're opposed to this" statement to be anything but hollow rhetoric? Yes.
- hugh4 10y agoIf LA is worried about housing affordability, the best thing to do would be to work to get President Trump elected, so the city can get rid of all the people who have no legal right to be there in the first place. What would housing costs look like in an LA without illegals?
- mindslight 10y agoHousing costs would skyrocket - there would be nobody to build new housing, and the current housing would slowly become uninhabitable as it got dirty and light bulbs burnt out. The problem with cheap labor isn't the people looking for a better life. It's that the rest of society ends up thinking they're above needing to know how to use a screwdriver.
- hueving 10y agoDo you really depend on illegal labor to change a light bulb? Also, the construction workers that built my parents home up in northeast US were all locals (or managed to have impeccable English), so I find it hard to believe the rhetoric that there are no legally employed laborers.
- mindslight 10y agoMy statement was a bit hyperbolous, and I've no idea how much of that labor is actually under the table versus not. But coming from northeast values of basic self-reliance, you'd be amazed at the level of outsourcing relied upon by the middle class.
- xenadu02 10y agoThe US would have a falling population without immigration so we'd be facing the Japanese situation of deflation and an eventual population crash (presumably). A lot of systems (pensions, social security, 401k, the stock market, most city governments and state budgets, et al). There would also be the economic slump as you remove consumers from the spending pool and labor from the labor pool. The massive gestapo/SS-like state apparatus required to round up so many people and deport them would take billions upon billions of dollars. It would also require shredding (what is left of) various constitutional rights and turn the US into a "papers please!" dystopia. This massive deportation police force would need to setup checkpoints on all major roads, in various public places, etc to even make a dent. Probably need to force all employers, even individuals hiring a contractor, to verify legal status. Outlaw cash to prevent paying people under the table too. The impact to US citizen children would be devastating; millions who were born in the US and are US citizens would be forced to leave and go live in a foreign country they've never been to (and in some cases barely even speak the language of). It would permanently alter their economic and development potential as they wouldn't have access to US culture, education, etc. You may not think they are citizens but you're simply wrong. Since the founding of the USA (and via common law) citizenship has been jus soli, confirmed by SCOTUS precedents too. If you're thinking of stripping their citizenship... trying to ex-post-facto do that on the basis of actions not taken by them and before they were born would require a constitutional amendment (besides being an immoral and shitty thing to do... We don't punish children for the actions of their parents; it's even in the constitution: No attainder or corruption of blood!). Oh and the fact that unless you're Native American you're a descendant of immigrants so it makes you a massive hypocrite and an arsehole?
- pyrophane 10y agoIt seems like there has been a growing body of "bad news" for Airbnb lately. Several major European cities (Paris, Berlin) are tightening regulations and limiting short-term rentals. NY, one of Airbnb's largest single markets, if not the largest, stands ready to essentially ban "whole apartment" rentals entirely as other cities seem to be gearing up to consider their own measures. I'm not saying that any or all of this threatens what Airbnb is trying to do, and in fact I think such restrictions will make model better and more sustainable in the long run. Still, for a company that is, out of the necessity of their valuation, as bent on maintaining growth as Airbnb, the skies appear to be darkening.
- youngButEager 10y agoSupply and Demand. If demand rises -- and it does, the population of LA is increasing by roughly 20,000 annually (from http://www.clrsearch.com/Los-Angeles-Demographics/CA/Population-Growth-and-Population-Statistics http://www.clrsearch.com/Los-Angeles-Demographics/CA/Populat...) -- if 20,000 per year are added to LA's population, you need more rental units. Here's a potential SAT question in the 'Logical Reasoning' part: "A large city experiences 20,000 population growth per year. Because restaurants, doctors, barbers, dentists, and other service providers are not growing fast enough in the city to accommodate this large growth in citizens, should the city: [A] Provide incentives for new restaurants, doctors, barbers, dentists, etc. to move into the city and start operating to meet the need? [B] Or should the city impose caps/limits on the fees/charges of those restaurants, doctors, barbers, dentists, etc. who already operate in the city, which will create disincentives for new operators to move to the city to satisfy increasing demand? Supply and Demand. The demand for EVERYTHING is affected by 20,000 new citizens in LA each year. In 10 years there 100,000 to 200,000 more citizens in LA. With the disincentives for new landlords to enter the LA market, there will be an even more severe shortage of units. "Shortage of willing landlords." The old adage is this: "You cannot price-limit, and regulate, and tax your way to an over-supply of housing." It's really, REALLY awful that city leaders don't understand that. Guess which cities have the greatest shortage of landlords? Los Angeles San Francisco New York City San Jose (those are the U.S. cities with the longest period of landlord-reducing Rent control laws, by the way) Can we PLEASE INCREASE THE FREAKING SUPPLY of willing landlords. PLEASE. $3500+ for a 1 bedroom apartment is just pyscho.
- hueving 10y agoThe number of people even on HN that don't seem to grasp supply and demand is shocking. If HN is a relatively intelligent group, imagine how much of the general population will think just price limiting housing will work?
- st3v3r 10y agoWe grasp it just fine. We also take a dim view of asshole landlords that decide to skirt the law.
- randyrand 10y agoIt seems as though he did leave the rental market and went into the hotel market. so I think they have a good legal argument and IAML.
- beedogs 10y agoGood. The sooner Airbnb goes away forever, the better.
- chatman 10y agoWith so much regulations around what you can or cannot do with your own property, this sounds like a socialist state.
- IDanceOnAPole 10y agoUrban areas always have laws about what you can do with your property.
- chatman 10y agoThat is surprising. I live in India, and there's no regulation around renting it out or asking tenants to vacate. As long as both landlord and tenant adhere to the agreement document, all is good. No government interference. Government enforcing regulations asking a landlord that he can or cannot use his home for letting out to a person of his choice seems very regressive to me.