3 ms·
> More specifically if I want to run a big web app in production there are no suitable microkernels or exokernels to do so now. Windows NT is a hybrid kernel[1
by kbenson 10y ago
> More specifically if I want to run a big web app in production there are no suitable microkernels or exokernels to do so now.
Windows NT is a hybrid kernel[1], so there's somewhat conflicting evidence.
Really, I think I could make an argument that the reason a microkernel hasn't gained popularity is because there's far too much focus on performance to the detriment of security and stability in much of the last few decades program development, much less OS development. People aren't good at correctly estimating risk and reward for future events that are more than a few years out, and worse when the risk is abstract in nature.
Would everything be running slower if we used microkernels for the majority of systems? Probably (but who knows by how much? If there was a lot more work focused on that problem, we might have ways to alleviate much of it by now). Would our systems be more secure and less prone to software errors? I think so. Do I think it's possible we as a culture (species?) could choose stability and security over performance? Not without enforcement negative consequences when developers supply buggy and/or exploitable code, and consequences for those companies that choose to run that code even if they are carefully advised on the possible consequences. So, not likely, and that's a huge discussion in itself.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_kernel#NT_kernel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_kernel#NT_kernel