3 ms·
"He should be in jail, there's nothing medieval about separating a rapist from the community." Has he been convicted of rape, or is an article on the internet
by collyw 10y ago
"He should be in jail, there's nothing medieval about separating a rapist from the community."
Has he been convicted of rape, or is an article on the internet good enough evidence for you? There is a good reason we have courts a justice system.
- gnaritas 10y agoThere's more than enough evidence for him to have been fired "in that article alone"; of course a rape charge would have to be prosecuted, my saying he should be in jail doesn't mean "without due process". Firing someone however requires no due process, several women complaining about harassment is more than enough.
- collyw 10y agoI hope you never have to server jury duty if that is enough evidence for you.
- gnaritas 10y agoThe bar for firing is much lower than the bar for imprisonment, you obviously can't see that, but it's true none the less. That article contains first hand testimony of multiple incidence of abuse and names numerous witnesses so it's all easily verifiable; if that's not enough evidence for you to fire someone, you need to reevaluate your standards. If you wouldn't fire him for those complaints, you're complicit in his abusive behavior.
- collyw 10y agoYou seem to have changed your argument from the original post, where there was no talk of firing. Anyway, go on and argue your strawman.
- gnaritas 10y agoThat would be true if you were replying to the original post, but you weren't, I clarified the jobs thing and then you replied to it so no, it isn't a moved goal post or a straw man, so go on and try another line of reason or move along.
- mfringel 10y agoSo, let's say that you loan someone $2000, and they promise to pay you back, but they don't. Now, let's say that person comes to me and asks for $2000. I know you loaned them money, so I ask you, and you say 'Well, he didn't pay me back, and I don't think he's a good risk.'" Given that, I can react in two ways. A) "Huh. Good to know. Thanks for the heads-up." B) "You never took him to court, and he was never found guilty. Stop accusing him." It appears that you're requiring the evidentiary standards of a court of law that can imprison someone, when the actual punishment here is removal from a specific social and professional sphere. Two different standards of evidence for two different spheres of influence.