3 ms·
What % of teachers are "good"? Again, we often need to optimize for the "mediocre teacher". At least in the US we pay our teachers less than we pay our garbage
by brianwawok 10y ago
What % of teachers are "good"? Again, we often need to optimize for the "mediocre teacher". At least in the US we pay our teachers less than we pay our garbage truck drivers, I am not sure we can count on "most" being "good". Which is not to diss teachers, but to be sad that we don't value them enough.
- Retric 10y agoGarbage truck drivers is a dangerous, low status, and unpleasant profession. Which forces you to pay well. Teaching on the other hand is a relatively high status, low risk profession.
- theorique 10y agolow risk profession It can be, for teachers in comfortable suburban schools where the students are generally well behaved. For teachers in dangerous, urban schools with severe disciplinary and even criminal issues (gangs, violence, drugs, etc), it is not so low-risk.
- Retric 10y agoI suspect there is a similar increase in risk for inner city garbage collection. No. 9: Police and sheriff's patrol officers Fatalities per 100k: 18.0 No. 7: Refuse and recyclable material collectors Fatalities per 100k: 22.8 Feel free to look for statistics though.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoIt's probably more representative of the fact that the vast majority of people actively avoid dealing with LEOs for a laundry list of legitimate (for the avoidee) reasons wheras trash men are "normal people." Trash men also spend their day around equipment that can easily kill you if mis-operated. Both spend a lot of time standing on the side of the road but far fewer people will perform absurd traffic maneuvers to pass a cop that's stopped in the right lane. IMO it's fair to infer that minute for minute standing on the side of the road behind a garbage truck with orange lights moving a trash bin is more dangerous than standing on the side of the road in front of a cruiser with blue lights harassing a motorist.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoWhen it's the middle of summer and 95 degrees out where is the teacher? What about the garbage man? If you start moving garbage cans around at age 20 in a brand new truck there's a pretty fair chance you'll be looking to switch careers at about the same time they retire that truck. If you manhandle garbage cans around every day from 5-2 your body isn't going to last. Teachers (along with police, fire and other municipal employees) are usually paid very well for the qualifications their work requires the time they put in and the wear on their bodies. Since most teaching positions are union jobs they're incredibly stable. Personal anecdote: the teachers I've known all seem to be on the same career path. The start working in less wealth areas and slowly move upward until they land a well paying job that they like and has a pension plan. On the way up to that job they build their resumes, libraries of lesson plans and gain experience. IMO this makes sense, the schools with the most money to throw at teachers can be picky in hiring teachers and more effective at retaining them.