4 ms·
Why don't we start teaching the basics of set theory and algebra during elementary school? I know I'd have dealt with that far better than the "Do this page of
by zdw 10y ago
Why don't we start teaching the basics of set theory and algebra during elementary school?
I know I'd have dealt with that far better than the "Do this page of 100 addition/subtraction problems as fast as you can" human calculator stupidity thrust upon us as math education. At least it sounds like common core is getting away from that sort of stuff.
- jerf 10y ago"Why don't we start teaching the basics of set theory and algebra during elementary school?" Based on what I'm saw coming home from my first grader, they are. The common core stuff at least comes from people who understood that having the student do a couple thousand "1 + 2 = ____" problems tends to promote the incorrect idea that the = symbol means "do the thing on the left and write it down", and I noticed a mix of "1 + __ = 3" and "___ = 1 + 2" in the problem sets. I noticed enough other places where the good ideas had been visibly chewed on by "the process" that I'm still not ecstatic about "common core", but at least the bits I've seen (up to first grade now) I do concede that there were good ideas at the beginning of the process. I'm not entirely convinced they made it through correctly, but they were there at the start. (Still a bit pissed that they took my kid who was adding single-digit numbers in his head and forced him to count on his fingers because That's What The Curriculum Says, though. Seems to have gotten over it by the end of the year, though, so no permanent damage. Still.)
- vonmoltke 10y ago> I noticed enough other places where the good ideas had been visibly chewed on by "the process" that I'm still not ecstatic about "common core", but at least the bits I've seen (up to first grade now) I do concede that there were good ideas at the beginning of the process. I'm not entirely convinced they made it through correctly, but they were there at the start. (Still a bit pissed that they took my kid who was adding single-digit numbers in his head and forced him to count on his fingers because That's What The Curriculum Says, though. Seems to have gotten over it by the end of the year, though, so no permanent damage. Still.) The standards are being ruined by terrible curricula providers, to the point where people conflate the standards and the curricula.
- torgoguys 10y agoI went to public schools and was in the "advanced" class for most things. We began algebra in the last quarter of 6th grade. Very basic stuff. What's a variable and how do they work. Simple equations. That kind of thing. 7th grade was nothing but algebra. The normal progression around here had (and I'm guessing still has) algebra starting in 8th. Kids handled it fine...I think. (Yes, some better than others of course.) So it surprises me that in SF, 8th grade was the year when the advanced class is just starting algebra and most not beginning until 9th. Is that the norm around the country?
- wrp 10y ago> Why don't we start teaching the basics of set theory and algebra during elementary school? Read about the history (and failure) of the New Math movement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math