6 ms·
Of course, the terrorists will switch Not only terrorists will switch. Everyone who has the option will switch. This is just another nail in the coffin for US
by tremon 10y ago
Of course, the terrorists will switch
Not only terrorists will switch. Everyone who has the option will switch. This is just another nail in the coffin for US technology companies.
I'm pretty sure that when this gets through, the non-US companies will be bought en-masse by US companies, like Microsoft did with Skype.
- chopin 10y agoEveryone who has the option will switch This might be difficult. With iOS, Android or Windows you have to trust the OS Vendor. I assume especially on iOS it might be difficult to supply any meaningful encryption at all if Apple decides to not supporting it.
- zaphar 10y agoAndroid is open source so if an OS vendor outside of the United States decides to use it and provide strong encryption there is very little stopping them from doing so. A lot of the hardest work has been done already. There is a small but growing market for strong encryption. US companies will find themselves losing some amount of market share due to encryption restrictions. We already saw this once with the previous crypto wars. The U.S. thought that they could corner the market on good crypto and instead ended up losing a good portion of the market. The U.S. lost that war and they can totally lose this one for the same reason. We don't have a monopoly on good crypto in the U.S. and if they have their way we'll end up with only bad crypto.
- Hermel 10y ago> This is just another nail in the coffin for US technology companies. What are the other nails in your opinion? To me it seems that the Silicon Valley is doing quite well.
- tremon 10y agoThe other big nail is surveillance itself, especially when coupled with the fact that foreigner's data in US' corporations hands is a free-for-all for everyone.
- jdimov10 10y agoHardly a nail. More like a crooked little staple. In the large scheme of things, nobody cares - and this is unlikely to change.
- jacquesm 10y agoYes, but they could be doing a lot better. There is a whole raft of companies out there that would have been happy customers of Google, MS and Amazon cloud services that is now doing business elsewhere.
- Arnt 10y agoI'm sure they could be doing better, but I notice that Amazon has a region in Frankfurt specifically to address German data protection concerns. There are Amazon employees who could be ordered by the US of A to break German law and extract data from customers at the Frankfurt site. In my judgment, the chance of their being prosecuted in Germany would be indistinguishable from 100%, so the real question is, has Amazon set up its organization such that people who are safely in the US can access such data.
- jacquesm 10y agoDitto for Amazon Ireland.
- Johnny555 10y agoThey'd immediately lose a large chunk of the EU customers that stored data in Frankfurt just because of EU data protection concerns. So I don't think AWS would take the risk of the USA being able to force an employee to disclose data. I wonder if they already separate privileges between regions so one rogue employee can't take down all of their regions.
- Arnt 10y agoAn Amazon employee told me that people outside govcloud (Amazon's special region for the US government) are/were technically prevented from accessing it, so the technical ability appears to be there.
- paganel 10y ago> the non-US companies will be bought en-masse by US companies, like Microsoft did with Skype. I'm glad I'm not the only one having that opinion about MS's acquisition of Skype. There's this article from July 2012, after the MS acquisition and before the Snowden leaks: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/skype-makes-chats-and-user-data-more-available-to-police/2012/07/25/gJQAobI39W_story.html?hpid=z1 https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/skype-makes-... > The FBI, whose officials have complained to Congress about the “going dark” problem, issued a statement Wednesday night saying it couldn’t comment on a particular company or service but that surveillance of conversations “requires review and approval by a court. It is used only in national security matters and to combat the most serious crimes.” and most importantly > But changes allowing police surveillance of online chats had been made since late last year, a knowledgeable industry official said Wednesday. As an anecdote, just wanted to add that I live in an Eastern European country which has started to at least try to put up a fight against endemic corruption, with the help of some Western countries (i.e. the American and the UK ambassadors issuing worrying statements from time to time saying "corruption is bad" and meeting the head of the Anti-Corruption body). Anyway, in a couple of anti-corruption cases investigated by our local anti-corruption prosecutors there were mentions of the authorities having access to the corrupt people's Skype conversations. Now, our NSA-like structure is no way as powerful as the real NSA, computationally speaking, so I don't see them breaking Skype's built-in encoding all by themselves, unless given that information on a silver plate by our friends from across the Atlantic Ocean. In exchange, we might help them with keeping nasty terrorists locked in an improptu prison, because that's how friends help each other out. (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/inside-romanias-secret-cia-prison-6273973.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/inside-romani...)
- nxzero 10y ago>> "non-US companies will be bought en-masse by US companies" Sounds like an "exit strategy" - TrueCrypt might even be an example of this.
- ikeboy 10y agoOpen source encryption has been available for decades. Yet, whatsapp got a billion users before they enabled end-to-end encryption. The data shows you're wrong: lack of encryption does not prevent a significant number of people from using a product. I'm mostly repeating what I said in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10580829 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10580829. Further down I had several links supporting the claim that even people who have a lot to gain from encryption will often not use it if it's not enabled by default.
- Bartweiss 10y agoWhich returns to the top commenter's point: Brennan is well aware that this won't end usage of newly-unencrypted US products. It will drive away foreign companies, and those with something to hide, but it will still expand CIA access to the bulk of everyday, non-criminal users.
- ikeboy 10y agoMy point is that "the terrorists/people with something to hide will switch" is incorrect, and so the claim that this isn't about catching them is unsupported. Data shows that even terrorists or other people committing high profile crimes won't always make sure to use encryption. It's very possible preventing encryption by default will help catch a couple of those.
- chopin 10y agoIt's very possible preventing encryption by default will help catch a couple of those. I doubt that. I agree with you that many use unencrypted products though, so you have a point. However in almost all events I can remember the people committing terrorist acts where already known to at least some agencies. The agencies already drown in false positives. There is no indication that this will change. This strengthens my point: it is not about terrorists.
- Bartweiss 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]