12 ms·
Power plants that convert all of their CO2 emissions into carbon nanotubes
- gus_massa 10y agoThe idea of using this in power plans with natural gas may work. The global reaction is CH4 + O2 --> C + 2 H2O + energy I have to check the calculation, but the research paper looks legit. I'm worried because they use a very indirect process so it's not clear for me that the loss in the intermediate steps are small. Also, I'd assume that if many power plants start to do this, then the nanotubes price will drop almost to the level of soot. (Would it be much cheaper to just make soot instead of nanotubes?) But they say that the energy production will drop only 10%, so this may make sense with some carbon taxes. But I really don't like that in the research article they propose to use this in coal plants. They use a complex scheme, (with additional solar panels?), but the global chemical reaction doesn't make sense. They start with coal that is essentially C and the final product is nanotubes that are essentially C, so there is very little room to extract energy.
- dnautics 10y agomy thoughts exactly
- sandworm101 10y agoHas any thought been put into the dangers of literally millions of pounds of carbon nanotubes floating around with nothing to do? CO2 is evil, but some people suspect carbon nanotubes could be the next asbestos if they become widespread. Wouldn't a substantial pile of such tubes be a serious fire hazard? Aren't they essentially the carbon version of steel wool, ie much more flammable than solid carbon?
- ams6110 10y agoTANSTAAFL
- rdoherty 10y agoI'm guessing that if they are generating nanotubes for sale, their is a collection process that keeps the nanotubes in some sort of container. Since this would take place in a location that also has coal or natural gas, I think they will have the procedures and technology to prevent fires and explosions.
- sandworm101 10y agoFor sale is one thing, but I get the sense that they might do this as a means of reducing CO2 emissions. That would generate truly epic piles of nanotubes, far beyond any concept of containers. For perspective, look at the amount of coal going into a plant. Roughly that much, by volume, would come out again as nanotubes. If they are flammable, even explosive, nobody has any protocol that could make storage of such volumes safe.
- lawpoop 10y ago> If they are flammable, even explosive, nobody has any protocol that could make storage of such volumes safe. Dumb question for a non-engineer: couldn't they feed them back through the power plant again?
- jerf 10y agoIf they were going to do that, they just wouldn't create them in the first place and keep the higher efficiency numbers. No point capturing the nanotubes out of your exhaust only to burn them.
- rosser 10y agoFrom TFA: "They found that the concept is economically feasible and even improves the power plants' energy efficiency." If that's true, and assuming the CNTs can be sold, sequestered, re-burned, or otherwise disposed of in a way that doesn't ... "exploit" their über-asbestos aspect, I'd think it worth doing on that basis alone.
- Raticide 10y agoSome nanotubes have a similar affect to asbestos when inhaled, so I sure hope they're not just leaving piles of it lying around. Source: http://www.nanotechproject.org/news/archive/mwcnt/ http://www.nanotechproject.org/news/archive/mwcnt/
- DigitalJack 10y agoCO2 is not evil and by mass most of life on earth needs it to breathe.
- sandworm101 10y agoElevated CO2 from fossil carbon stores (coal/oil etc) is evil. That isn't the same as C02 already in the biosphere.
- reitanqild 10y agoLets be precise here: The CO2 from fossil carbon stores is chemically speaking exactly like other C02. That said, increasing the concentration might not be smart anyways, -I don't know, at this point I'm not really sure. (I used to be very skeptic, now I'm starting to think it might be correct and the proponents just don't get PR.)
- sandworm101 10y ago>> Lets be precise here: Do you or do you not believe in the link between the burning of fossil fuels and climate change? If you do not, I am not going to get into a theological debate with a believer.
- reitanqild 10y ago> Do you or do you not believe in the link between the burning of fossil fuels and climate change? ? It matters nothing for the chemical properties of CO2. > If you do not, I am not going to get into a theological debate with a believer. I am very much a believer, and for technical stuff I believe in experiments, measurements etc : )
- cossatot 10y agoFrom the journal article, re: energy extraction from coal: "The thermodynamic enthalpy available per CO2 emitted from carbon combustion (−394 kJ/mole) is less than that from methane (−890 kJ/mole) combustion. Coal, compared to natural gas, combustion will generate less excess heat per transformable CO2 to drive CNF [carbon nanofiber] and CNT [copper nanotube] production product is retained within the system at (the electrolysis chamber temperature of) 750 °C, and hence under normal circumstances while a CC [combined-cycle natural gas] CNF plant can co-produce electricity and CNFs, a coal CNF plant will produce only value-added carbon nanotubes, and not surplus electricity." Annotations in brackets are mine.
- nneonneo 10y agoThis is a cool idea, but it comes with a weird perverse incentive problem. The authors estimate that a "CC CNF" power plant would produce $835 of electricity and over $225,000 of nanotubes from a single metric ton of methane. At this point, economically, this is no longer a power plant: it is a carbon nanotube factory that has the side-effect of producing power. And if nanotubes are so valuable, the power generation part starts to look like a distraction: why not just pull the electricity off the grid and convert methane/CO2/coal/oil straight into nanotubes for less cost and complexity? So really, this doesn't seem to be about power plants, so much as a (maybe) cheap way to make nanotubes from carbon. If we can incentivize people to make useful products out of all that CO2 just floating in the atmosphere, then maybe, just _maybe_, we can start fixing the mess we made.
- duaneb 10y ago> If we can incentivize people to make useful products out of all that CO2 just floating in the atmosphere, then maybe, just _maybe_, we can start fixing the mess we made. Is this really a shorter path than just planting more trees, which is both cheap and extremely low maintenance?
- vkou 10y agoTrees can sequester a bounded amount of carbon from the air. Burning fossil fuels can release an almost unbounded amount of carbon into the air.
- duaneb 10y ago> Trees can sequester a bounded amount of carbon from the air. So plant more trees? It's a continual process. It's not like you can plant a tree and say "Ok, I'm carbon neutral now!"
- vkou 10y agoWe only have so much land to plant trees on. (Which is very quickly shrinking due to urban and agricultural pressure.) The current amount of carbon sequestered in all of the world's forests is ~600 giga-tonnes. If we stopped all of our carbon emissions today, and tried to roll back to pre-industrial CO2 levels, we'd need to sequester ~270 giga-tonnes of carbon. Losing that much agricultural land is unrealistic - expensive as they are, it would be much less painful to switch our entire energy economy to renewables.
- enimodas 10y agoWeren't these nanotubes the new asbestos?
- pasquinelli 10y agoyeah, that was my thought too. now we have an interesting new pollutant.
- beatpanda 10y agoAside from the other objections raised here, this also doesn't do anything about environmental and social impacts at the site of fossil fuel extraction, which are significant. One of the benefits of transitioning away from fossil fuels is not having to pull them out of the ground anymore.
- narrator 10y agoOnly problem with carbon nanotubes is they are kind of toxic -- like maybe asbestos level toxicity. So you just made your CO2 emissions problem into an asbestos problem. Congratulations! Dose-dependent mesothelioma induction by intraperitoneal administration of multi-wall carbon nanotubes in p53 heterozygous mice " Here, we report a dose-response study; three groups of p53 heterozygous mice (n = 20) were given a single intraperitoneal injection of 300 μg/mouse of μm-MWCNT (corresponding to 1 × 108 fibers), 30 μg/mouse (1 × 107) or 3 μg/mouse (1 × 106), respectively, and observed for up to 1 year. The cumulative incidence of mesotheliomas was 19/20, 17/20 and 5/20, respectively." [1] [1]http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1349-7006.2012.02318.x/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1349-7006.2012....
- rosser 10y agoIt's not like they're just venting CNTs out the top of the smoke stack, instead of CO₂.
- andrewflnr 10y agoIsn't there a problem of quality, here? Not all nanotubes are equal, I'm guessing especially for applications like construction. Will it be difficult to make sure the nanotubes this process creates are actually usable?
- teraformer 10y agoGrey goo, here we come!
- teslaberry 10y agocarbon capture is billions of waste JUST LIKE the synfuels fiasco of the carter administration. There is NO scarcity of carbon as an input in industrial processes. so producing it through the MOST inefficient means , just like making FUEL OUT OF ETHANOL , is not just unprofitable and dumb, but environmentally destructive and stupid. capturing carbon is just making it more expensive to burn more carbon based fuel. capturing carbon means you are getting a lower EROI on the input energy. so you are actually winding up getting a more carbon intensive energy production as a result Albeit ----some of that carbon is going to be 'captured'. BUT this means the more carbon capture you achieve, the more carbon intensive your energy source!!!!! moral hazard anyone? the support for carbon capture amongst the greenies is one of the best examples of internal inconsistency and thoughtlessness amongst the greens. the total rejection of nuclear power on any and all terms, is the another. but let's get on with it. consider that all this 'captured carbon' will just be magically stored underground or somewhere else it won't escape for a 100 million years. MASSIVE VOLUMES in the atmosphere, cheaply and easily 'CAPTURED' and now of course, we assume it can all be stored perfectly. just like nuclear waste right!? no. that was sarcasm. c02 sequestration is the biggest joke of all. despite the nonexistence of effective sequestration methods ( which all COST ENERGY, and are thus more carbon intensive ) ------why not assume it already exist. ok what then, consider that within 100 years, any given earthquake let alone the basic erosion of nature will eventually lead to this carbon somehow coming back to the atmosphere one way or another. so now , the final piece of stupidity is introduced, let's take the carbon and use it for industrial production instead of sequestering it. yes , PERFECT!!!!! LET'S INVENT NEW THINGS THAT DON'T EXIST AND ARE UNPROFITEABLE EVEN IF THEY DID AND USE THE MOST EXPENSIVE THEORETICAL SOURCE OF INPUTS OF CARBON TO MAKE THEM. this is how sovietized economies reason, based on a goal centric output, rejecting ALL COMMON SENSE about investment to achieve the perfect recipe for optimal levels of destructive malinvestment. ----------------------- let me break it down for you liberals. the only effective way to sequester carbon is to plant trees, or otherwise encourage nature to run her own course (perhaps by stopping clearcutting trees to begin with) , because natures' course naturally consumes oxygen and sequesters carbon by way of...THE CARBON CYCLE!. seeding the ocean with iron for algea has not worked because our science is lacking in the area. we know SO LITTLE about the ocean, including to what extent it controls our atmosphere. YES, every year a whole new ton of research comes out about the oceans previously unknown influences on the atmosphere. why is this? because it is deep and huge. and so much of the ocean has not been subject to study without physical penetration in many different simultaneous locations ( like the worlds biggest scientific gang bang ) . Only now are we even beginning to understand ocean currents below the surface of the ocean ( where 99.999 percent of the ocean's water exists ) as for carbon, capturing it from smokestacks is just stupid. It is uneconomical let alone more carbon intensive. please by all means continue to pursue your interests in renewable energies. but stop being dumb. carbon capture for the sake of smoke stack 'cleansing' is a cruel joke.
- m_mueller 10y ago> he system applies a voltage to split CO2 into oxygen gas and solid carbon nanofibers Wait what? Where is the electrical energy coming from if not from bringing solid carbon into a lower energy state by oxidising it and releasing the energy difference as heat? If you want to reverse that process you will with certainty have to invest more energy to account for all the losses. At which point this isn't a power plant anymore. Am I missing something here?
- warrenpj 10y agoThe fuel which is being burned has a higher specific energy than pure carbon, (compare the specific energy of natural gas with coal [1]). The chemical process is methane -> pure carbon with CO2 as an intermediate state. Of course you're not generating as much power as just burning the methane completely. [1] http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085.html http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085....
- m_mueller 10y agoThanks. So disregarding any heat losses, you get (12-7.5)/12 = 37.5% of the stored energy. Gas power plants appear to have an efficiency of 54% [1]. I honestly can't imagine how you could reasonably get electrical energy out of that system. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle#Efficiency_of_CCGT_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle#Efficiency_of_C...