3 ms·
>>Government aid programs have failed to generate startup scene basically everywhere they were used. >Didn't Silicon Valley grow out of a collection of compani
by SilasX 10y ago
>>Government aid programs have failed to generate startup scene basically everywhere they were used.
>Didn't Silicon Valley grow out of a collection of companies doing defense contracts and research grants?
I think you're talking past each other. The parent was referring (AIUI) to government programs specifically intended to promote a "startup scene".
So you may be right that government spending was responsible for making SV what it is now; however, that spending was not in the form of "hey, we want to jumpstart a specific kind of business environment by filtering for companies that meet that mold and heavily subsidizing them in their early stages", which is the kind of aid program the parent meant.
The SV funding you're referring to, by contrast, was contracts for stuff the government had wanted for (and was optimizing for) completely unrelated reasons, and which (over a long time) created a startup scene as a side-effect.
- vram22 10y agoRight (as I've read). E.g. The Secret History of Silicon Valley - a video and blog post series by Steve Blank - gives good though long info on how SV evolved over decades.