6 ms·
I think it's fair, but how much OVH charges for each VM? $5 per month? I think that's a bit too much (or they'll just slap the $1 as a "Canonical Fee" and be do
by raverbashing 10y ago
I think it's fair, but how much OVH charges for each VM? $5 per month? I think that's a bit too much (or they'll just slap the $1 as a "Canonical Fee" and be done with it)
- fermigier 10y agoIMHO the problem is not if it's fair or not, but if Canonical's demand is grounded on juridically or not. OVH is a huge user of open source, and, as far as I been told by several sources, gives very little back (for instance, they have a no open source contribution policy internally). But I'd like to see the juridical arguments forbidding any hosting provider to propose a given trademarked distribution on their system.
- icebraining 10y agoIANAL, but as it has been pointed out, OVH distributes a modified version of Ubuntu, not (only?) a pristine copy. As such, that may be considered a material difference, which gives Canonical a claim against OVH. Quoting a ruling, [T]he unauthorized (...) sale of materially different merchandise violates the Lanham Act because a difference in products bearing the same name confuses consumers and impinges on the local trademark holder’s goodwill.
- PedroBatista 10y agoBut Canonical doesn't seem to have a problem with that... as long as they get paid. The truth (IMHO): OVH changes the ISOs but wants to call it Ubuntu because it's a huge brand. Canonical smells blood in the water and wants money. Nobody is an angel here.
- icebraining 10y agoCanonical does have a problem with that, which is why they require OVH and other re-distributors of modified versions to submit them for approval, for which they charge. This is all in their IP policies: http://www.ubuntu.com/legal/terms-and-policies/intellectual-property-policy http://www.ubuntu.com/legal/terms-and-policies/intellectual-...
- jamespo 10y agoCanonical also provide a product for free that powers an enormous swathe of the internet
- toyg 10y ago> they have a no open source contribution policy internally Man, that's just evil. <adds company name to list of businesses never to patronise>
- icebraining 10y agoWell, if I run a SaaS business on VPSs but it's only profitable if those cost $1 a pop, would OVH lower its prices just for me?
- seszett 10y ago> or they'll just slap the $1 as a "Canonical Fee" and be done with it I could see them offering the following options: * Ubuntu without OVH panel monitoring * Ubuntu with monitoring (+1€/mo) * Custom OVH Ubuntu-based distribution with monitoring (same as above but we can't call it "Ubuntu" without charging 1€ per month) Not sure it would be fair, but that's the kind of thing they could do.
- gnoway 10y agoWhy can't they offer stock Ubuntu + the monitoring stuff as a .deb? They can put up lots of instructions about how to enable panel integration. They could run their own apt repository too, which should satisfy anyone who wants to spin up instances via API and configure via some CM tool. Seems like this would satisfy all needs.
- Tepix 10y agoI second this. Also it means you don't have to examine the distribution after setting up a new box to find all the little things they have modified.
- wtbob 10y agoThere's always Debian! I honestly don't know why someone would run Ubuntu on the server rather than Debian. I did kinda like Ubuntu once upon a time for end-user computing (e.g. laptops & desktops), although eventually I gave up on it because it was too painful to customise. But why use it on a server? There's no need for the proprietary blobs it supports, and it's really not targeted at servers like Debian is.
- icebraining 10y agoUbuntu Server is definitively targeted at servers. I use Debian on my servers, but one reason I know some companies used Ubuntu was because it had a five year LTS program. Debian only started theirs in 2014, and it's not handled by the main Security Team, which might make some people feel queasy.
- Karunamon 10y ago>I honestly don't know why someone would run Ubuntu on the server rather than Debian. Having just had this discussion at work, I can give you a few reasons: * Canonical's ecosystem, including direct support for OpenStack and some homegrown tooling around it like Juju. Also Landscape and MAAS. * 5 years of support on LTS images * Ubiquity, specifically the fact that Ubuntu has enough popularity (well beyond Debian's) that most of its issues are well known, and it has broad 3rd party support * Paid support on the base image (it's not like CentOS/RHEL where you need an entirely different OS to get paid support, you can just buy Ubuntu support) * PPAs (which is really just some tooling on top of a DEB repo, but it's still useful) I'm not sure what you mean by "targeted at servers" when http://www.ubuntu.com/download/server http://www.ubuntu.com/download/server exists.