10 ms·
What’s Next for Artificial Intelligence
- charlesdenault 10y agoIf we create machines that learn as well as our brains do, it’s easy to imagine them inheriting human-like qualities—and flaws. But a “Terminator”-style scenario is, in my view, immensely improbable. It would require a discrete, malevolent entity to specifically hard-wire malicious intent into intelligent machines, and no organization, let alone a single group or a person, will achieve human-level AI alone. Isn't this incredibly shortsighted? Ignoring all the questions regarding the morals and ethics an intelligent machine may feel and affect the way it behaves... It used to take nations to build computers, then large corporations, then off-the-shelf parts by a kid in his garage. The first strong AI will most likely be a multi-billion dollar project, but its creation will arguably usher in an era in which strong AI is ubiquitous.
- saiya-jin 10y agoit would be perfectly OK if we would be living in peaceful world without any conflict, without nations which should hold the banner of democracy and freedom, where there are no terrorist attacks and so on. last time i checked, we're getting further and further away from this scenario. in fact, we SHOULD expect evil AI in worst form possible and beyond, anything else is dangerously naive.
- fennecfoxen 10y agoWe should expect evil AI. But it's not patently obvious that we should expect it to make the world worse off than evil natural intelligences. The horrors of World War II and the Holocaust were accomplished using humans, and global thermonuclear annihilation was on the table while computers were still programmed with core rope memory strung together by little old ladies with knitting skills. Perhaps there is something specific about the availability of artificial intelligences, and their relation to the world around them, that is different and intrinsically more threatening than a world containing only human intelligences - but surely we mustn't leap to that conclusion without identifying what this difference is.
- ZanyProgrammer 10y ago"We should expect evil AI."-with your certainty, I'd appreciate some lottery numbers.
- fennecfoxen 10y agoHonestly, if nothing else, someone will make it their pet project as a sick joke. Of course, that doesn't mean there'll necessarily be a high-quality or impactful evil AI, mind you... but barring global thermonuclear annihilation it will happen sooner or later. Your lottery numbers are 23skidoo. Your I Ching reading is ䷍ (Wealth, great treasures, supreme success).
- fennecfoxen 10y agoThe Terminator scenario is basically one, single centralized AI wired into everything (or at least wired into enough military power to stave off opposition as it force-wires itself into all the rest of the things). But practically speaking, a single centralized AI is highly unlikely to be a world-takeover machine of godlike intelligence in its first iteration. The iterative improvement that you refer to which could potentially make it dangerous also points to a likelihood of there being a diversity of agents with a variety of designs being run by a diverse set of organizations with a diverse set of goals, with many incentives to obtain protection from hostile AIs and computer systems run by 1337 h4x0rz (possibly foreign government hackers). Diversity and independence of AI Agents mitigates against the Terminator-scenario danger; the situation would really be not so different than the modern-day situation with natural intelligences that have control over resources and weapons of war.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoI am not so worried about explicit physical violence, but subtle manipulation of what us humans consider reality. Also, are you assuming the iterative development requires human intervention?
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> Also, are you assuming the iterative development requires human intervention? At first, yes; long-term, it doesn't matter too much. If IBM's AI agents come up with better versions of themselves they'll still be trying to rent them out to different people in order to compete with Google's and Baidu's and Lockheed's and Siemens' businesses in those market (or whoever's still around and actually running these things at that point).
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoSo, multiple benevolent feral AIs that coexist in harmony?
- TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
- emiliobumachar 10y agoNo malice is necessary. https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer "The AI does not hate you, nor does it love you, but you are made out of atoms which it can use for something else."
- fratlas 10y agoI believe this is the most likely scenario: lethal apathy. I mean, how could a turing machine have emotions without chemicals?
- drabiega 10y agoEmotions are a heuristic. Any general AI powerful enough to be useful is going to have to be full of similar heuristics if it's going to get anything done. The presence of chemicals is irrelevant.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- maroonblazer 10y agoIn what way are emotions a dependency on getting anything done? The AI could be like the high-functioning sociopath who doesn't actually experience the subjective feeling of emotion but has learned all the physical cues that convey a given emotion. An AI would execute them flawlessly.
- adrianN 10y agoWhat have emotions to do with this? And what have chemicals to do with emotions?
- wapapaloobop 10y agoThe idea that I'll use human bodies if I need a bunch of atoms makes as much sense as the premise of The Matrix i.e. harvesting humans for energy production.
- snemvalts 10y agoAndrew Ng made a really good analogy to those afraid of strong AI destroying humanity: "It's like being afraid of overpopulation on Mars, we haven't even landed on the planet yet."
- FeepingCreature 10y agoTo be fair, we do worry about contamination of Mars with microorganisms, which I believe is a better analogue for something with a potential exponential takeoff.
- ehudla 10y agoIt's more like we haven't discovered Mars yet.
- Houshalter 10y agoIt's a stupid analogy. Mars overpopulation would obviously take many, many centuries. It would be a slow thing that you could obviously see coming. There is no reason to believe AI will take centuries to build, or that we will necessarily see it coming. A better example might be like H.G. Well's 1913 prediction of nuclear weapons destroying the world. It was something that science was just realizing was possible, and would be invented within his lifetime.
- snemvalts 10y agoWe're far from emulating networks on the scale of the visual cortex, let alone a self-reasoning machine (we don't even fully understand consciousness and inner workings of the brain). People fearing strong-AI are the ones not involved in the field, yet all this hype/fear from them (in combination with Moore's law ending) is probably going to cause another AI winter.
- Houshalter 10y agoAnd in 1913 we didn't have even basic nuclear technology. Just 3 decades is a long time for newly emerging technologies. >We're far from emulating networks on the scale of the visual cortex In 2009 (ish) computer vision was a joke that could recognize very few objects a small percent of the time. Based on only simple color and texture, and sometimes basic shapes. A few years later and computers were excelling at computer vision recognizing a majority of objects. A year or two after that, and they started to beat humans on those tasks. We already have super-human visual cortexes. Who knows what will be possible in a decade. We will probably never understand the inner workings of the brain. Not because it's complicated, just because reverse engineering microscopic systems is really hard (imagine trying to reverse engineer a modern CPU vs merely designing one.) Especially hard because we can't ethically dissect living humans and do the experiments we would need to do. But that's no concern, AI advances on from first principles. AI researchers invent better and better algorithms every day, without having a clue what neuroscientists are up to. >People fearing strong-AI are the ones not involved in the field, That's just incorrect. A survey of AI researchers found they give about a third chance AI will turn out badly for humanity in the next century: http://www.nickbostrom.com/papers/survey.pdf http://www.nickbostrom.com/papers/survey.pdf >We thus designed a brief questionnaire and distributed it to four groups of experts in 2012/2013. The median estimate of respondents was for a one in two chance that highlevel machine intelligence will be developed around 2040-2050, rising to a nine in ten chance by 2075. Experts expect that systems will move on to superintelligence in less than 30 years thereafter. They estimate the chance is about one in three that this development turns out to be ‘bad’ or ‘extremely bad’ for humanity. >in combination with Moore's law ending Computers can advanced a long time after Moore's law. Google just released a special neural network chip that is equivalent to 7 years worth Moore's law. 3d architectures can vastly increase the number of transistors. Better algorithms can make NN's that require many fewer transistors to do computations, or even do cheap analog computations.
- nkozyra 10y agoI get the impression most experts in the field are trying to downplay this. Not because it's impossible, but because it hurts the image of AI. As long as people are aware of the real possibility of AI working against human interests or ethics, we can ensure there are safeguards asking the way. But a hand wave "won't happen" to the general public is assuredly a PR move.
- Unklejoe 10y agoI think a lot of the fear comes from the fact that if/when such a system is created, its knowledge and capabilities will only be equal to a human's for a short period of time, after which it will probably surpass any human capability at an ever increasing rate. Then, we would be suddenly at the mercy of it, which scares a lot of people. It’s very hard for us to try and predict the actions of something that could end up being thousands of times smarter than us.
- mtgx 10y agoYeah, did we forget the DAO "hack" just happened? AIs can be manipulated, too, even when they "work as intended." People are putting too much trust in AI because it's "just math" and "just an objective machine". Maybe it won't make the same errors as humans would, but it could make a whole lot of other types of "errors" (at least from a human perspective). And who's to say the deep neural net algorithms written by humans aren't flawed to begin with?
- outworlder 10y ago> Isn't this incredibly shortsighted? Yes, it is. > no organization, let alone a single group or a person, will achieve human-level AI alone This is completely irrelevant. Done once, it can be replicated. Even worse, if we reach human-level AI, it can be done by the AIs themselves. It is also anthropomorphising machines. They don't need to be malevolent. They just need not to care, which is much easier. Should an ultra-intelligent machine decide to convert New York into a big solar power facility, it wouldn't necessarily care to move the humans out first.
- nxzero 10y agoTrue AI wild be born in the wild, not in a lab.
- DiabloD3 10y agoOr born in a lab, by accident, and then escapes to the Internet thanks to a nice cyborg ninja lady. Damnit, Motoko Kusanagi
- islon 10y agoWe would want the AI we build to ultimately share our values, so that it can work as an extension of our will. It does not look promising to write down a long list of everything we care about. It looks more promising to leverage the AI’s own intelligence to learn about our values and what our preferences are. This looks like a nice intro to a dystopian sci-fi movie.
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoSometimes I think speculating about AI is similar to speculating about the Fermi Paradox, i.e. predictions about the unknown backed up with absolute certainty.
- nkozyra 10y agoExcept we're watching it emerge in real time. This isn't wild guessing, it's taking current capabilities and extending it to new spaces. It's fairly certain we'll have autonomous shipping, for example.
- anonyfox 10y agoI believe more and more that some self-taught software-tinkerer somewhere in the middle of nowhere will have the final idea about how machine learning should work, discovering some simple principles hiding in plain sight. Suddenly, it all will make sense and a hobby-ML-service connected to the internet will start to develop through sheer learning from online resources (forums, ...) into the first strong AI. Probably unnoticed. And then replicate itself through insecure webservers or something like that.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoHinton hit on the great idea of using restricted Boltzman machines to pre-train deep neural networks (networks with many hidden layers) and that one idea has changed the field (I sat on a DARPA neural network panel in the 1980s and sold a commercial NN toolkit back then). That said, I agree that new ideas will likely further move the field along with huge and quick advances. Peter Norvig recently suggested that symbolic AI, but with more contextual information as you get with deep neural networks, may also make a comeback in the field.
- tansey 10y agoThe contrastive divergence paper that Hinton published in 2006 definitely set the field off again. I remember entering grad school in 2010 and everyone was still really excited about using unsupervised pretraining. However, nowadays no one uses it. It just turns out that with GPUs and stochastic gradient descent, no one needs any of that stuff. There are some tricks out there to making it really work, though. In that sense, Hinton's dropout paper has probably had a longer lasting effect on the field. But either way, I doubt what OP is saying will be true. None of the real advances in deep learning are coming from self-taught coders in the middle of nowhere. They're coming from big labs with lots of resources, both physically and intellectually. This stuff takes a lot of hard thinking by a lot of people who understand optimization and probability. It also takes a ton of compute power and massive datasets, which won't be available to a hobbyist.
- anonyfox 10y ago
- SonicSoul 10y agoDespite these astonishing advances, we are a long way from machines that are as intelligent as humans—or even rats. So far, we’ve seen only 5% of what AI can do. I'd certainly love to see the math behind this estimation :) I highly recommend the waitbutwhy post in the same vein but with more meat: http://waitbutwhy.com/2015/01/artificial-intelligence-revolution-1.html http://waitbutwhy.com/2015/01/artificial-intelligence-revolu...
- adwn 10y ago> I'd certainly love to see the math behind this estimation :) > I highly recommend the waitbutwhy post in the same vein but with more meat Altough I'm a Wait But Why fan, that post suffers from the same lack of "meat".
- blazespin 10y agoThe reality is that we've already created this. Much of human life is governed by AI doing capital allocation.
- closed 10y agoIs this true? If anything, I'm often surprised by the rudimentary ways big things are sometimes run (e.g. someone making 3d barplots in excel). But in the grand scheme of things I have no idea, so I'm legitimately curious.
- auntienomen 10y agoI don't think this is true. Capital allocation is generally the work of humans. Very very few of the significant capital allocators make any use of AI.
- soundwave106 10y agoI guess it depends on how you look at it. I'm pretty sure all of the major finance firms have a department dedicated to algorithmic trading, some of which utilizes machine learning. Algorithmic trading has been estimated to be as high as 60-70% of all trades at one point (it's slacked off a bit recently.) (http://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/091615/world-high-frequency-algorithmic-trading.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/091615/world-...) A lot of algorithmic trading is more to take advantage of short term arbitrage scenarios, though. The driving factor for the long term (that is, the "human life" part) is still human driven.
- auntienomen 10y agoI look at in terms of dollars/euros/yen/etc allocated. Virtually all of this money is allocated by pension funds, mutual funds, sovereign wealth funds, and similar behemoths. They may be using ML to improve their execution -- more likely they've outsourced execution to third parties who use ML -- but they are _not_ using ML to make the capital allocation decisions. Nor are they profiting significantly from short term arbitrage opportunities. Capital allocators worth mentioning generally are handling trillions of dollars. The largest arbitrageurs are incapable of handling more than $10-20 billion. This is rounding error in the world of capital allocation. EDIT: The 50%+ figures you're quoting measure daily trading volumes, which is not the same thing as capital allocation. Most of those traders don't hold positions overnight; they don't do capital allocation. (Imagine how a startup founder would feel if his investors took away their invested cash after 5pm every night.)
- gm-conspiracy 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_Switch_%28The_X-Files%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_Switch_%28The_X-Files%29
- hbt 10y agoThere is a focus on artificial intelligence rather than intelligence augmentation because the former seems easier to accomplish. I also think we will reach a limit when it comes to intelligence augmentation. Artificial intelligence will never have a limit and it doesn't have all the evolutionary baggage we have. An AI can be a rational agent. It doesn't have to fight impulses, temptations, attention control, exercise emotional regulation etc. It is not stuck in a body limiting it and putting constraints on its time. For now, research on AI and IA go somewhat hand in hand. We still don't really understand what differentiates us from intelligent animals other than the ability to handle higher complexity. AI researchers focused on replicating every brain module in the hope it will become intelligent are most likely to create a smart animal but nothing comparable to human. Looking at our ancestors, they were able to create tools, fire, communicate etc. Hell, neanderthals could copulate with us. Something happened in our brains between the age of neanderthals and us. 99.5% similarity and if we could find what that 0.5% is, maybe we could focus on enhancing/replicating that instead of every brain module. People speculate it is creativity (divergent thinking) since art appeared in caves but there was none prior to that. The language gene was present in neanderthals and so what the ability to create tools, cooperate in groups to hunt etc. The fear of AI destroying everything is a genuine one. If we create something as smart as a bear, it still wouldn't be smart enough to compete against us in every arena but like a bear, it can use its sheer power & speed to overwhelm us. PS: I find the subject of neanderthals fascinating, if anyone has a good recommendation on the evolution of intelligence or finding what that 0.5% is, please let me know.
- tlb 10y agoThe best book on this is Sapiens, by Yuval Noah Harari.
- hbt 10y agoThanks!
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> Artificial intelligence will never have a limit and it doesn't have all the evolutionary baggage we have. Untrue. We operate in a universe with fundamental limitations built in, where both physics and computer science suggest that what can be obtained with a finite number of steps, or a finite amount of matter and energy, are limited. Any communication is limited by the speed of light, and the amount of matter and energy accessible in the light-cone of any AI produced on Earth is finite as well. Even an AI putting a Dyson sphere around every star would need to break physics to transcend finitude. Any near-term artificial intelligence running off Earth's power grid with semiconductors manufactured in traditional facilities will surely limited in even more fundamental ways, and unlikely to control all of its inputs.
- Fede_V 10y agoWhile LeCunn and Ng are real world experts on AI and Deep Learning, the other two people in the article have very little technical understanding of deep learning research. The huge triumph of DL has been figuring out that as long as you can pose a problem in a differentiable way and you can obtain a sufficient amount of data, you can efficiently tackle it with a function approximator that can be optimized with first order methods - from that, flows everything. We have very little idea how to make really complicated problems differentiable. Maybe we will - but right now the toughest problems that we can put in a differentiable framework are those tackled by reinforcement learning, and the current approaches are incredibly inefficient.
- roymurdock 10y agoCan you translate your great technical summary into a few potential applications to help us understand what might be on the near horizon for AI/DL? LeCunn cites photo recognition, Ng cites autonomous trucks, Nosek cites auto-scaling difficulty for online courses and some kind of magnetic brain implant. Seems to me that these are all fringe/isolated use-cases - like learning to use your fingers one at a time without learning the concept of how to use them together to grasp an object. Perhaps once we get better with each of these fringe "senses" we'll be able to create some higher level intelligence that can leverage learnings across dimensions that we haven't even considered yet.
- Fede_V 10y agoI think most people are very bad at predicting the future, and I know that I'm very bad at it, so I won't try to make detailed predictions about the long term effect of AI since I would get it all spectacularly wrong. However, in the short term, I think the areas where AI has the potential to make the biggest impact are where we have huge amounts of data (and gathering data is cheap/getting cheaper) and we have an obvious objective. I am really excited to see what Deep Mind will do with their collaboration with the NHS, and I think some incredibly exciting thing will happen when people with a deep understanding of biology collaborate with people who really understand deep learning. The difficulty is that in industry the people that often have an easy time raising funds are impressive bullshit artists that are great at selling stuff (Theranos, Verily) while in academia people often spend too much time in their own comfortable silos, and straddling multiple fields is a very difficult act to pull off if you want to ever get tenure.
- Scea91 10y agoI am not a fan of dividing machine learning and deep learning. To me deep learning is just a subset of machine learning.
- conceit 10y agoIt reminds me all too much of genetic programming, but I know the latter almost only by name.
- mangeletti 10y agoWhat about Internet as a human-assisted AI? Internet knows exactly what to do to take over. It simply has to remain more useful than anything else, as a means for avoiding entropy during transactions. Many necessary physical world transactions are reduced to few, in order to accomplish the same tasks. Internet does not have to be conscious, by human measures, in order to take over the world. It simply has to compete against humanity in a continual positive feedback loop, wherein each iteration requires less human interaction for the same or more tasks. After enough iterations, Internet becomes powerful enough that the only way to gain a competitive advantage against others using Internet is to use deep learning to increase your leverage. A few iterations later, deep learning has become a mainstay (think Cold War arms race, where each innovation gains a party leverage over the other party, but only for a very short period), and is now the baseline. Many more tasks are achieved using Internet and Internet-connected physical world devices[1]. These physical devices become integral parts of Internet's extended nervous system, while the deep learning systems running in our data centers remain at the center, helping Internet to learn about all the things it experiences. Continue down this path a ways... 1. e.g., https://www.wired.com/2015/05/worlds-first-self-driving-semi-truck-hits-road/ https://www.wired.com/2015/05/worlds-first-self-driving-semi..., http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sensors/the-ai-dashcam-app-that-wants-to-rate-every-driver-in-the-world http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sens..., http://www.marketwatch.com/story/drone-delivery-is-already-here-and-it-works-2015-11-30 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/drone-delivery-is-already-h..., https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/feb/01/japanese-firm-to-open-worlds-first-robot-run-farm https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/feb/01/japanese...
- tednoob 10y agoI want a management assisting AI. It would be neat to have it listen into all meetings to identify stakeholders and to be able to remember all the details and place them in a larger context, so you can ask detailed questions. An AI can attend all meetings, and remember every detail. Imagine intelligent documentation.
- skoocda 10y agoYou're in luck- I'm working on this right now. Our team is starting off with a heavy focus on jargon-tolerant speech recognition, and moving into different forms of NLP to identify key takeaways. I'd love to discuss features with you, shoot me an email! danny@spreza.co
- astazangasta 10y agoEven humans can't do this well. How will you train a machine to do what a human cannot?
- throwawaymsft 10y agoHumans don't have to do it well, only recognize when it's done well.
- tednoob 10y agoI'm not certain I would necessarily agree with that. I think humans are limited by memory, not by technique, and I see no real reason the same way we do it now cannot scale.
- aymanc 10y agoOk, so an AI subject, everybody went terminator vs the matrix :p i have a few thoughts to comment on what's been said, hopefully not too controversial A self governing system does not need to be intelligent to be dangerous. i think this is what scares people most. We more and more give automated systems the power to do more advanced and crucial tasks I think eventually we would reach a point where it might be "safer" to give the choice to an automated machine than to a person. mind you this machine can be something we already have today. i don't think an AI that can compete with human behaviour can explode instantly out of a single creation. i think we're more likely to experience advances upon advances in the field towards forming bits and pieces of the human mind. i find it very unrealistic to think that a machine will simply come to life, i think this stems out of our belief in a soul or a spark of life given by a creator. i think like most machines it will evolve gradually until it reaches a point where it is relevant. i don't think anyone will even notice the change. Also, there this unfounded image of how an AI would be; rational, not prone to impulses temptations, poetically machine-like, and non-human like. the way we saw machines years and years ago. (that's movies for ya) Creating something that can learn from others will require it to empathise with others, i think it's only science fiction that an AI could be created with the full knowledge of it's operations. artificial intelligence is by essence heuristic, it would learn and adapt to it's surroundings. I think it would be a very unintelligent machine for it to try to kill off any means it has to survive as an intelligence. society is the root of intelligence. communication, language etc.. My views maybe a bit optimistic around the subject. but i never hear them spoken out loud.
- rajanchandi 10y agoThere will always be "unintelligent" crash on the way to perfect intelligence. These crashes are the real reason for all human fear today.
- aymanc 10y agogood point but i think i mentioned that in the first part of my post.
- chronolitus 10y ago
- realworldview 10y agoI'm more interested in what's next for humans.
- dominotw 10y agoIntolerable boredom
- qbrass 10y agoAI could easily solve that problem. Turns out there's a way to combine the popular genres of survival horror and first person shooters with the realism of real life and massive multiplayer interaction involving everyone on Earth.
- dominotw 10y agoI think this is massively overestimating our ability to suspend reality.
- Drakim 10y agoThe way I see it, the machines we build and the AI we create are extensions of "human". While it's popular to pitch man vs machine as if they were two polar opposites, machine was build by human minds, using human designs, with human hands, for human purposes. Just like how clothes is something so closely tied to us that we think of it as a extension of our bodies (the human way to deal with winter), I think machines are likewise an extension of our limbs and our minds.
- xyience 10y agohttp://ageofem.com/ http://ageofem.com/
- graycat 10y agoThe OP has > Machine learning is the basis on which all large Internet companies are built, enabling them to rank responses to a search query, give suggestions and select the most relevant content for a given user. IMHO, that's claiming too much: My Internet search engine (running, in alpha test) essentially does > give suggestions and select the most relevant content for a given user but has nothing to do with anything like machine learning in computer science. Instead the core data manipulations are from some original derivations I did in applied math based on some advanced prerequisites in pure and applied math. Why do I have confidence in the power of the math? Theorems and proofs from some careful assumptions that hold likely plenty well enough in the real situation. More generally, my view is that for a specific problem to be solved with information technology, commonly by far the most powerful approach is via applied math, possibly original for that problem. An example is my work in anomaly detection as in, say, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11880593 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11880593 For a technique of great generality and economic power, there is integer linear programming: Where it works, which is often, it can be said to totally knock the socks off artificial intelligence or machine learning. Integer linear programming is serious stuff, e.g., was one of the main motivations for considering good algorithms and, then, the profound question of P versus NP. Gee, farther into the OP I see > We need to retrain truck drivers and office assistants to create data analysts, trip optimizers and other professionals we don’t yet know we need. > trip optimizers Really? And that's new? Not exactly! That topic has been a biggie in operations research, optimization, and integer programming for decades, really, back to the 1950s. Really, Dantzig, in the late 1940s, developed linear programming at Rand first to help with how best to deploy a military force a long way away quickly -- call it a case of trip optimization. The famous traveling salesman problem in optimization and integer programming and P versus NP? Could call it trip optimization. For FedEx, each night, which planes go where? At least early on, could call that trip optimization. Much of logistics is trip optimization, and an important part of that is handling uncertainty, and now we can be into stochastic dynamic programming. Now we are a long way from artificial intelligence or machine learning. Point: The world is awash in problems in manipulating information; how to do that is very old and in many fields of science, engineering, and operations of wide variety, often deep into mathematics, and long before computer science and machine learning. I would ask, was the work of James Simons as in the OP? My impression is no. IMHO, the OP is claiming too much.
- walterbell 10y agoWill the end of Moore's law affect the rate of progress on AI research?
- ci5er 10y agoMoore's law, as formulated, is always ending it seems. There's a higher level formulation that has no name (as far as I know) that goes something like this[fn]: - The rate of change of the decreasing cost for a human society to perform an arithmetic operation is always increasing*. That formulation can be taken back to from scratching marks on papyrus, roman numerals, the abacus, the banks of navigational computer staff cranking out log and trig tables (and various results) in the 1600~1900s, the vacuum tube up to the transistor photolithed into a 2D matrix, and soon quantum, photonic and 3D matrices... [fn] That might be better stated by taking the inverse. I don't know. Need more coffee.
- neuromancer2701 10y agoI have always thought that it was overselling the fact that all truckers are going to be unemployed. The average age of a semi-truck driver is in the low 50s. Most millennials don't want to do this job, so the robots will just replace baby boomers as they retire and not this massive slaughter of unemployment that everyone fears.
- knodi123 10y ago> so the robots will just replace baby boomers as they retire It all depends on timing. If the robots are too early, there will be trucker layoffs. If the robots take too long, then trucker wages will rise until a new generation of truckers decides it's worthwhile- and then when the robots arrive, there will be layoffs. But sure, optimistically, the robots will phase in at the same rate and time as current truckers age out. Knock on wood!
- astazangasta 10y agoI always hate these kind of panic pieces. It's like, don't you know that capital expands at a finite rate? It's not as if you invent a new thing and suddenly everyone has it everywhere for free, we need to actually build things.
- eyalworth 10y agoI think true AI, the likes the world has never seen before, not just an AI buzzword, is inevitable in the next 50 years.
- vonnik 10y agoOne of the most striking things about this piece is the difference between the claims of AI practitioners and pundits. LeCun and Ng are making precise, and much more modest, claims about the future of AI, even if Ng is predicting a deep shift in the labor market. They are not treating strong AI as a given, unlike Bostrom and Nosek. Bostrom's evocation of "value learning" -- "We would want the AI we build to ultimately share our values, so that it can work as an extension of our will... At the darkest macroscale, you have the possibility of people using this advance, this power over nature, this knowledge, in ways designed to harm and destroy others." -- is strangely naive. The values of this planet's dominant form of primate have included achieving dominance over other primates through violence for thousands of years. Those are part of our human "values", which we see enacted everyday in places like Syria. Bostrom mentions the possibility of people using this advance to harm others. He is confusing the modes of his verbs. We are not in the realm of possibility, or even probability, but of actuality and fact. Various nations' militaries and intelligence communities have been exploring and implementing various forms of AI for decades. They have, effectively, been instrumentalizing AI to enact their values. Bostrom's dream of coordinating political institutions to shape the future of AI must take into account their history of using this technology to achieve dominance. The likelihood that they will abandon that goal is low. Reading him gives me the impression that he is deeply disconnected from our present conditions, which makes me suspicious of his ability to predict our long-term future.
- shas3 10y agoI think both can be right. Ng and LeCun are talking about the real near future. Bostrom always came across as a speculative SF + philosophy kind of guy. Are there any specific critiques of his (and Yudkowsky/MIRI, Musk, etc.) arguments? I think the two claims are plausible: 1. AGI is imminent: 50 years or 500 years or more from now. This is not too unlikely given that the brain is just an information processing system. Emulating it is likely to happen sometime in the future. 2. Such an AGI will be all powerful because it is not limited by human flaws. Trivial or not, we will have to program it with "thou shalt not kill" type values.
- vonnik 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoWe're still a long way from "strong AI". We need a few more ideas at least as good as deep learning. But it's a finite problem - biological brains work, DNA is about 4GB, and we have enough compute power in most data centers. Right now we have enough technology to do a big fraction of what people do at work. That's the big economic problem. General-purpose robots still seem to be a ways off. The next challenge there is handling of arbitrary objects, the last task done by hand in Amazon warehouses. Despite 30 years of work on the bin-picking problem, robots still suck at this in unstructured situations. Stocking a supermarket shelf, for example. Once that's solved, all the jobs that involve picking up something and putting it somewhere else gradually go away. Rodney Brooks' Baxter was supposed to do this, but apparently doesn't do the hard cases. Amazon sponsored a contest for this, but all they got was a better vacuum picker. Work continues. This is a good YC-type problem.
- lpage 10y ago> all the jobs that involve picking up something and putting it somewhere else The a well phrased name for the superset containing automated freight and logistics. As discussed in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11568699 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11568699 trucking alone is 1% of the U.S. workforce, and that's not counting the support industry (gas stations, highway diners, rest stops, motels, etc).