3 ms·
This is the part that did you in: Instead, you brushed off our claims, calling them “absolutely without merit,” among other things. Now even if you are all em
by dasil003 17y ago
This is the part that did you in:
Instead, you brushed off our claims, calling them “absolutely without merit,” among other things.
Now even if you are all emotionless, 100% objective researchers with no interest other than the greater good, this very sentence will make it impossible for humans to read your letter without implying a certain level of snark.
If you want to project pure motives for the letter then it would have been best to leave their reaction to your original research out of it, or, probably more appropriately, don't publish an open letter at all—contact them directly.
- madair 17y agoAh yes, Appeal to Motive, that'll do it, now I'm not going to accept anything they said because of my interpretation of their motives. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_motive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_motive
- dasil003 17y agoOpen letters are about politics, not logic. What an individual critical thinker such as yourself believes has no bearing.
- madair 17y agoOpen letters are about communicating a message, they are also by definition political, and it's really helpful to our social systems when they are based on logic. Analysis of motives is of course valuable. But it's not an argument against the matter at hand. It may not have been clear that I was being facetious.
- foldr 17y ago>now I'm not going to accept anything they said I don't think anyone is refusing to accept anything he says. They're just disapproving of his motives, which is fine.