6 ms·
But you aren't opening an unlocked window (or door, or curtain). You're asking the property manager to open it for you, and they do.
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
But you aren't opening an unlocked window (or door, or curtain). You're asking the property manager to open it for you, and they do.
- tptacek 10y agoAlso breaking and entering!
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoBreaking and entering implies there is no authorization but here we have the property manager saying yes. Also, breaking and entering is generally a misdemeanor rather than a felony. And on top of that, there is no entering. People love to paint bad abstractions on top of computers, but fundamentally all there ever can be is you asking the remote computer to do something and it deciding whether to do it or not. That doesn't look anything like B&E or trespass. The best meatspace analogy is social engineering. But there is no generic law against manipulating people and the laws against specific types of manipulation are highly context-dependent because so is the harm.
- tptacek 10y agoWhere are you getting this "misdemeanor" thing from? Burglary is a felony, and it's defined in most places simply by entering a building or vehicle without permission and with illicit intent (that intent need not be "to steal stuff").
- EdHominem 10y agoThe physical building metaphors are yours and you keep pushing back to those. The whole point of a standards-compliant webserver is to speak to standards-compliant web clients. When used without a password, on a public IP, at a standard port, the simple existence implies you're allowed to speak to it. Asking a human for a document isn't a crime, so it shouldn't be when you ask a computer. Fraudulently claiming to be someone else to get a document is a crime, and that's how it should be on a computer.
- tptacek 10y agoThis is another super popular argument about computer security, and it falls apart almost instantly under scrutiny. By your logic, I can dump a SQL database full of credit card numbers due to an SQLI in a GET handler, because, after all, the software components are just doing what they're meant to do!
- Natsu 10y agoNo, at least in my standard, that would be material deception. You said that was your name/address/whatever, but it's actually an SQL command. I suppose you'll ask what if someone's name really is Bobby Tables, but then I submit that it either can't be tailored to your database, or that their intent when changing their name to exploit you counts as social engineering and I don't consider it worth optimizing for.
- tptacek 10y agoHow is that any different from "I can reasonably infer that my customer ID is 101, but I told you it was 102 in a URL to see the account information for a different customer"? These issues are less fraught than people seem to think they are. We walk through commercial spaces all the time that are full of unlocked, unmarked doors, and it rarely takes us more than a moment to realize when we've gone somewhere we weren't meant to be. It's not a new problem.
- Natsu 10y agoYeah, but we don't normally hammer people that open the wrong unmarked door by mistake in a long hall full of unmarked doors. It's not hard to typo a URL. It's not unreasonable to connect to anonymous FTP--they choose to authorize you and you have no good reason to second-guess them. Now, yes, when you do that 100 times with a script, you can argue that they're doing something bad... which is why I also advocate a safe-harbor for people who report the bug only to the site owners or the government. If someone is making a reasonable effort to help you fix your bad security, we shouldn't be treating them like a bad guy.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> Where are you getting this "misdemeanor" thing from? http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/punishments-for-breaking-and-entering.html http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/punishments-fo... Breaking and entering is generally listed as a misdemeanor. Misdemeanors result in jail sentences of less than one year. However, breaking and entering is often associated with the felony crime of burglary. Burglary is usually defined as "breaking and entering with the intent to commit a felony while on the premises". The difference between burglary and B&E of "intent to commit a felony" is the sort of thing that justifies the felony charges. I don't see that requirement in the CFAA.
- tptacek 10y agoNope, same deal with the CFAA, which is why the CFAA cross-charging with the Wire Fraud statute is so problematic.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe CFAA doesn't have "intent to commit a felony," it has committed in furtherance of any criminal or tortious act in violation of the Constitution or laws of the United States or of any State, which is much broader. It allows felony penalties without felonious intent. And as you point out, even that limitation is basically swallowed by the fact that the Wire Fraud statute covers very similar conduct to the CFAA, so they can charge you with computer fraud in furtherance of wire fraud.