6 ms·
Review my startup - Quote Feed (step 2)
- pclark 17y agoFind a designer co-founder, right now :) I'm interested in what problem this solves compared to say, Tumblr + WikiQuote? It isn't clear what the specific value proposition to a user is. When I think of Friend Feed I think of importing all my "stuff" into one place, is Quote Feed supposed to import quotes from all over the place into one place?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoMy original idea was to have a place like HN where, instead of reading titles, I could read the quick excerpts from the latest articles and news events all over the web. I also didn't want a simple voting system (insert long discussion about mob voting here) and instead went with a tagged learning system. Later on it occurred to me that social hooks and app-store integration might really help with growth.
- dimarco 17y agoHere's an idea: If people could wrap quotes in some tag like [qfeed]a good quote[/qfeed] in media outlets all over the internet, like Disqus comments for a particular blog or in reply to the quoted post on HN. And then a spider came along and pulled the [qfeed] bit and submitted it to quote-feed. It wouldn't work well for comment-less sites like wikipedia, but it would for "quick excerpts from the latest articles"
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoIt's a limited beta right now and it's only a web service. Here's the master plan for future development. As usual, no plan survives contact with the enemy. This is just the vision and we're actively looking for a pivot point as we continue to work customer development. ---- You're in a conference. The keynote speaker says something cool. You go to tweet it to your friends -- but it's longer than 140 characters. So you key it into your iPad on my app and choose to share it with your FaceBook and MySpace Friends. Over on FB and MySpace, the longer quote appears and has a link back to my web app where the quote is stored. You're reading a political or science article. About half-way down, the author makes a really cool point -- all the ideas seem to be coming together and this text just jumps off the page. You highlight the paragraph and enter it into my app, choosing also to share it on Twitter and FB. You're looking for something pithy to tweet or put on your FB status. You visit my app and read the latest quotes from sources all over the world, sorted and ranked especially according to your tastes. Choosing the one you like the most, you upvote it, make a comment, and choose to automatically email it and post to your status updates. You're looking for the best of the web today. Visiting my app, quotes from much longer articles and speeches are listed, customized to your tastes. Finding one that looks especially interesting, you click the link and go to the longer article, spending 10 or 20 minutes reading the full text. Your friend hears something incredible at a news event. He quotes the speaker, links to the video, and notifies you by using my app. You visit his quote on my app, make some comments, and vote it up. Soon you and your friend have made several comments -- other people have also joined in. Your conversation about this quote is saved for you to return to when you like. Finally, you're reading a book on your Kindle or other device. You find a particularly interesting passage. Quickly you copy it out, tag and save it, perhaps also choosing to share it on your status update. Later on, when you are not at your e-book reader, you can visit the web site and view your quotes -- along with the comments from your social network and other folks who share your same interest. -- Why is it different from tumblr or other micro-blogging services? 1) Message length 2) Superior content preference learning system 3) Niche product
- alilja 17y agoI can do all of this on Tumblr -- with the exception of finding people's quotes. Sell me on why that's the killer feature.
- eagleal 17y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but your strength (as of now) is the app (for iPad, Kindle, iPhone, etc), and the best quotes of the day (trough the learning system). Is this right? (I think I see a piece of your vision, am I the only one who sees this as a solution to one of the YC RFS?) Also if you need a designer, I have plenty of experience in UI/UX. Funny thing, I was going to contact you to join me in one of my projects.
- eagleal 17y agoI maybe need to clarify it: I'm not talking about the iPad apps request (this one also apply), but another (really) bigger one.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoYes. You are on-track. Sorry for the delay. I'm still stunned from this other conversation I was having with alilja. They really described my app better than I could myself. But yes, the idea is Community-Driven Pandora for news running on an iPad (or similar device)
- bmelton 17y ago"Internet Explorer cannot display the webpage" -- using IE7 on Windows XP.
- cheald 17y agoThe design turns me off pretty quickly, to be honest. The color scheme does make it difficult to visually parse and obscures design elements like the upvote arrows - a lighter background and some padding on your quote containers would help a lot. My initial impression of the concept is that it suffers from lack of context - quotes are interesting, but usually only in the context of an existing discussion or topic. For example, in Newsweek or whatnot, their "quotes of the week" page has the quote, and then explains the context it was in. For example: > "Pie is bad, and we are dedicated to providing a safe and pie-free environment for our children as we move towards the future." -- President Obama speaking to the National Cake Frosters Association If you could make the design point to sources more easily, so the users feels like it's a lead-in to a piece of content, that may alleviate that issue. It seems like the niche you could capture would be sort of an expansion what the Twitter trending topics is already - a high-level view of the things being said by interesting people, and what people think of them. I think your concept implements that, but it doesn't really present it to the user. My first impression was "well, it's Reddit, except I have to read more to find something interesting". If you can find a way to present it in such a way that the user is presented with easily-consumable, interesting, relevant information with easy access to context and reactions, it could have some interesting potential.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoLightened the background and increased the padding on the quotes per your request. Awesome feedback. Thanks. So here's the million-dollar question: What is the context that the user is browsing? The people who say things? The web site that sourced the quote? The people who posted things? The topic that the quote falls under (you can see the topic -- it's the tooltip that pops up when you hover over the quote) I'm getting a lot of "get a designer" advice, and I'll cop to being a poor designer any day of the week -- I suck. But even with a designer, you don't want the thing to look like a 747 cockpit. Simply because you can search by something doesn't mean the UI should allow it. With a desire to keep the UI as brutally simple as possible, what do you think is the context people would like to see as a higher-up heading?
- cheald 17y ago
- davi 17y agoNice to see your project! Agree w/ pclark about need for a designer. I even have a quote in mind ("the biggest danger of people doing bad things to you is that it will make you paranoid", http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1192160 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1192160 -- I thought that was pretty good) but really feel no 'win' from signing up and making an account just to give myself the ability to enter this quote. Give me a reason to summon the activation energy, or get rid of the need for it (a la Posterous). Slashdot allows anonymous cowards, maybe you should too?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoGreat comment. I think there are probably 3 levels of users: 1) People like yourself. For those guys probably just a button and a place to put a link for the source should be enough, 2) People who want to vote. For those guys some kind of sign-up is required, and 3) People who want to post their own stuff. You are right on with the anonymous coward thing. Right now you either get nothing or have to sign-up and then you can do everything. That's too big of a hurdle for casual users like yourself (and easily fixed). I'm also finding out that simply because you vote and comment doesn't mean you have the energy to tag and source new material. So there's probably a gradual engagement model that needs to be created.
- crux 17y agoI suspect you might have a credibility problem as long as one of your quotes is attributed to 'Benjamin Franklin, President of the United States'.
- chanux 17y agoYou should visit http://colorlovers.com http://colorlovers.com :)
- greyman 17y agoAs I understand it, your idea is that the user will discover some new interesting quotes and then the community can vote them up. I like the idea, but in a general sense, quote is something shorter (usually just one sentence), and aiming at some basic "truths", like there are quotes about love, relationships, inspiration, etc. But if you mix that with quotes that require some specific knowledge, I am not sure if that will work. For example, I tried to read some quote form your side, only discovering that it is related to U.S. politics. But I don't watch this topic closely, so after reading the paragraph, I just didn't understand what is it about. So the quotes which requires some specific knowledge (like politics of certain country, etc.), will need to have their own subdomain...if you mix it into one place, you will just get a snippets of text understood by only certain people.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThis is great feedback, but I'm not sure how to handle. The idea, for registered users, is that you downvote the first U.S. Politics quote you see. Then the system starts sorting those lower. Over time, if you keep training the system, you'll never see a U.S. politics quote. But for new users, how to handle? Right now for anonymous users I have a basic HN sorting algorithm.What you are saying is that this might not be enough. Should I leave it as is? Should I add some kind of heading or sorting on the page so that people can easily see the topics (topics appear as you mouse over the quote). Not sure.
- alilja 17y agoSo what you're REALLY providing isn't a quote-aggregation service, but rather an intelligent method of showing people content from around the internet based on how much they like a topic. It's like Pandora but for news. EDIT: community-powered Pandora but for news?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoYes. Exactly. The quote gives them a sample of the target material so they can decide whether to take time to consume the whole thing.
- newobj 17y agoImmediate gut reaction: I don't get it... and it's ugly. I wouldn't work on the design if I were you. Honest opinion, it'd be a bit like lipstick on a pig at the moment. I think the fundamental premise is flawed - I cannot imagine in any stretch of my imagination why I or any normal person would visit this page, much less withstand the friction of the service in order to interact with it. My elevator pitch re-imagining of what you're doing: "Quotes can serve as great summaries, excerpts, or lead-ins of a larger story. They also humanize stories or events by putting a face or voice on them. Quotestory.com brings you each day's biggest news and events one quote at a time, presented in a beautiful and simple interface that lets users get a quick read on what's happening in the world." Essentially, the site would scrape the news to pull out candidate quotes, as well as allowing user submissions. Weighting system incorporates crowed voting as well as "page rank" of scraped quotes. The quotes are pegged to a specific point in time, and the front page displays a sort a chronological arrangement of quotes, chunked into days (maybe something hierarchical to summarize entire weeks/months in the past). You get a unique view of each's days events via direct quotes rather than editorialized headline. Quotes click through to an article. If you can extract a attribution, perhaps a small image of the quotee. If you get smart enough, perhaps you can have some sort of point-counterpoint dueling quotes to show both sides of an issue. I'm not saying this is insanely compelling either, but I can at least see a small value add in that some people may prefer to graze on news this way.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoSo I'm going to add you in the "unsure" category. (grin) Thanks for the feedback. You made my day! I love negative feedback. So much of running a startup is getting any attention at all. If they hate you, at least they're listening. Appreciate your time, and I'll work as hard as I can on the value proposition.
- newobj 17y agoHey, I don't hate. Just trying to help! :) I deeply admire anyone trying to do their own thing.
- 17y ago
- tptacek 17y agoYou would get a lot of value out of BlueprintCSS, right away. Your colors do nothing to improve the site. Ditch them. Use black, white, grey, and a single accent color of your choice for text only. What's the deal with the DOCTYPE?
- pclark 17y agothat doctype is wild
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoWill change the colors. Also thinking of hiring a designer to take a look at layout. DOCTYPE is hosed. Looks like a bug in the JS.
- tptacek 17y agoYou're trying too hard. Stop. Go for competant and boring. Switch to Blueprint. Get everything layed out on a grid. Things should line up with each other. This takes programming, not design talent. Use Blueprint typography. You have no discretion in font sizes anymore. Just let it do its thing. Stop setting background colors. On anything. They aren't your friend. If they were an ice cream flavor, they'd be pralines and dick. If you lay your site out on a grid, you won't need the background colors to distinguish elements. Work with three colors: black, grey, and an accent color: * Most things will be black * Things that aren't important --- like all your timestamps --- are in grey. Look at the header on this comment. Metadata fades into the background. * For very important things, use an accent color sparingly. Maybe it's the most important comment on the page. * Count the number of ways in which any two pieces of text differ. Bold vs. not bold: 1 point. Grey vs. black: 1 point. Big vs. little: 1 point. Things should differ by the minimal effective number of points. That means don't set <h2> text in accent red. Just do those things and, instead of springing for a designer, you can go to 99designs and ask for a $250 logo. That'll be money better spent.
- eagleal 17y agotptacek is right! You don't need (at this stage) to spend money on design or anything alike. If you're stack just ask for help.