4 ms·
That might just be human pattern matching at work, rather than actual similarities. Regarding intelligent life looking similar, I sometimes have the opposite t
by mikeash 10y ago
That might just be human pattern matching at work, rather than actual similarities.
Regarding intelligent life looking similar, I sometimes have the opposite thought. What if the reason we haven't seen any aliens isn't that they don't exist, but rather that they are so different we can't even recognize them as intelligence or life? If intelligent creatures existed that were built out of magnetic field lines in the Sun, or variations in density in the interstellar medium, we might never recognize them as life, and they might never recognize us.
- npace12 10y agoThis comment reminded me of the book Dragon's Egg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg
- 542458 10y agoAt risk of spoilers, The Ouroboros Wave also qualifies: http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7326882-the-ouroboros-wave http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7326882-the-ouroboros-wav...
- qrendel 10y agoSolaris, by Stanislaw Lem, also seems to qualify. (The novel, not the movies.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solaris_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solaris_(novel)
- rdtsc 10y agoYes. Solaris is the first thing I thought of. Well I liked Tarkovsky's rendition. Here is an example of how Tarkosvky envisoned the ocean: https://youtu.be/USCiKknufaM?t=647 https://youtu.be/USCiKknufaM?t=647
- p1mrx 10y agoWhen I read Dragon's Egg a few years ago, I realized that it had been the basis of my favorite ST:VOY episode: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blink_of_an_Eye_(Star_Trek:_Voyager) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blink_of_an_Eye_(Star_Trek:_Vo...
- jerf 10y ago"That might just be human pattern matching at work, rather than actual similarities." In many cases there are actual similarities. Waves appear everywhere because wherever you see a -d^2 x over d^2 t, you get waves. Explosions happen at many scales because wherever you get an exothermic reaction that makes itself happen faster you get an explosion. As the article itself says: "Because they are made of a water-loving and water-repelling layer sandwiched together, their interactions with a watery environment make them self-assemble into the spaghetti- and lasagna-like structures known as endoplasmic reticulum," where you get two things that attract and repel in the same way as fats and water, you get characteristic shapes. Many similarities aren't just visual, they really do represent underlying similarities in the relevant processes. "If intelligent creatures existed that were built out of magnetic field lines in the Sun, or variations in density in the interstellar medium, we might never recognize them as life, and they might never recognize us." Life needs to be able to expel entropy faster than the environment jams it in, or it isn't life anymore. It is very likely that nothing can possibly live in a star, because entropy is getting jammed in to every cubic centimeter pretty hard. Interstellar-medium-based life has the problem that it must necessarily interact multiple orders of magnitude more slowly than Earth life because all of its components are much more separated and it has the same speed-of-light limits as our biochemistry has, so even if it somehow overcomes the problem that having complex, information-processing-capable structures that function without chemistry (to a first approximation, the interstellar medium is a tiny puff of hydrogen gas) doesn't seem possible with just gravity, from its point of view the universe is probably too young to even have the initial life form, to say nothing of the fact that on that time scale, the interstellar medium is constantly getting stirred up by things.
- jlj 10y ago"Interstellar-medium-based life has the problem that it must necessarily interact multiple orders of magnitude more slowly than Earth life because all of its components are much more separated and it has the same speed-of-light limits as our biochemistry has.." When I read about quantum entanglement of two atoms at a distance, I wonder if it could have something to do with serendipity moments, like when you get a phone call from someone you were just thinking of. Interesting to imagine what aspects of life and consciousness might be related to that branch of physics. From my very basic understanding of quantum entanglement, it might not have speed-of-light limits.
- Razengan 10y agoYes. Personally I'd like to think that the Universe, for all its apparent infinity, wouldn't be so — boring — as to be easily figured out by a single species operating within a very limited sensory window, that have yet to leave the comfort of their chair as it were (our home planet), in barely just 200 orbits around their star.. I'm no scientist but I wonder if there isn't a TON of things that we've just been assuming to apply universally. If all matter in a solar system is largely formed from the same cloud or nebula, then it must limit what we can learn from our sun and neighboring planets, and asteroids or comets. Other systems may have radically different composition and occurrences of different elements and their isotopes, maybe effectively having different periodic tables, so to speak. The size, gravity, color, radiation of a star may have great influence on how planetary matter forms and interacts with each other; maybe water will have different observable properties in such different systems. As for life; we have yet to catalogue the complete scale of life on Earth alone. We still get surprised by discoveries like Tardigrades and deep sea creatures. I'm sure the Infinity of the universe has even more surprises in store. There may be creatures flying around in dense nebulas, not bound to any planet. There may be rogue planets drifting through interstellar darkness with no sun to orbit, but still supporting life under the surface near their warm cores. There may be little asteroids inside gas giant planets, effectively making tiny solid worlds inside a sea of different gasses. As for life that develops industry; just look at the bodies of octopuses and what they're capable of. It's a shame they have such short lives and hostile environments to contend with, though. For now.