3 ms·
"With nearly 40 percent of all pregnancies in the United States unintended, birth control is a critical public health issue." But check the actual source and:
by ars 10y ago
"With nearly 40 percent of all pregnancies in the United States unintended, birth control is a critical public health issue."
But check the actual source and:
"Among women who had unintended births in the United States in 1998–2002, about 40% were using contraception"
So that's very misleading reporting.
Note that they tracked women for 4 years - track someone for their entire life and the numbers who had at least one child while on birth control at some point in their life will rise.
Contraception just isn't effective enough to eliminate pregnancy, it can only function to reduce fertility (number of children).
A typical couple using birth control through their entire life will still have one or two children - which is the average (more or less) of people in the US who choose to have children.
The only function of birth control is to reduce fertility from around 10 to around 2.
- maxerickson 10y agoFrom the third paragraph of the abstract: Results—About 37% of births in the United States were unintended at the time of conception.
- ars 10y agoDid you even read what I wrote? They were not [all] unintended as a result of lack of birth control. Giving everyone access to birth control will NOT stop unintended births. It's not able to do that.
- maxerickson 10y agoSure I read what you wrote. The line you quoted With nearly 40 percent of all pregnancies in the United States unintended, birth control is a critical public health issue. isn't claiming birth control is 100% effective, it's saying that there are a lot of people that might benefit from access. I posted what I posted because I didn't think it was particularly misleading for the article to state a fact that was important enough to the report to appear in the abstract. Your language But check the actual source also sort of implies that the article had misstated the fact. But it did not.
- ars 10y ago> it's saying that there are a lot of people that might benefit from access. Not as many as you would think. The number of people who: 1. want birth control, 2. are unable to get it, 3. had an child as a result, 4. and would have preferred not to, is a much smaller number than the article makes it out to be. I find that misleading. I don't know why you don't. These apps are about saving time for people, they will do nothing at all to the national birth rate.
- maxerickson 10y agoBecause 2. doesn't have to be true for the access to still be important. I mean, go ask someone on birth control if maintaining access is important to them.
- DanBC 10y agoYou said: > "With nearly 40 percent of all pregnancies in the United States unintended, birth control is a critical public health issue." > But check the actual source and: And maxericson quoted the actual source, which says > Results—About 37% of births in the United States were unintended at the time of conception. It seems the report accurately quoted the abstract, and so I'm confused why you think it didn't.
- guelo 10y ago"Contraception" in those CDC questionnaires includes all methods including the withdrawal method, rhythm, condoms, pill, vasectomy, etc. You can't really draw a conclusion about the effectiveness of any particular method from that study. Effectiveness per method data is available, though I can't figure out what argument it is that you're trying to make so forcefully. Things like IUD and implants are >99%/year effective.