3 ms·
> Encryption isn't really banned. You can still speak in code. No, you can't. Other than one very narrow exception, you cannot use "codes or ciphers that hide
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> Encryption isn't really banned. You can still speak in code.
No, you can't. Other than one very narrow exception, you cannot use "codes or ciphers that hide the meaning of a message". (The exception is for transmitting control commands to a radio-controlled craft or space station.)
- happyslobro 10y agoSeriously? There are restrictions against, say, sending a stream of packets with PGP encrypted payloads? Why? I mean, what could you do over amateur radio with encrypted comms that you couldn't do over the Internet? And how do hams share information that should be private, like a bitcoin wallet's private key? How do you shell in to the admin interface of a remote tower? You just don't, over amateur radio?
- JoshTriplett 10y agoThe regulations in question all talk about not "obscuring the meaning of a message", so protocols that use authentication without encryption are typically considered acceptable. Other than that: right, you just don't. Hams share information that should be private via other communication mechanisms; amateur radio is public.
- artimaeis 10y agoThat's correct. The bands are for public use, commercial use is forbidden. The only way to effectively enforce that is to prohibit encrypted communications. Using amateur radio bands to send sensitive data is a huge mistake, that's what something like the Internet would be much better suited for.
- tlrobinson 10y agoNote that encryption is banned, but digital signatures are not. In theory you could configure SSH to authenticate but not encrypt a connection.
- happyslobro 10y agoAdministering an expensive, high power piece of hardware in the clear, with a "perfect" authentication and authorisation scheme, would require balls of steel. Someone should try it, maybe write a book about it. For science.
- rietta 10y agoFor PGP encrypted, yup, it's not allowed. PGP plaintext signatures are presumably allowed as they do not obscuring the meaning of the communication. That was my thesis in 2004 and I believe it to still be true based on Part 97.
- sandworm101 10y agoMaybe in the US. Plenty of users in Canada speak in code, particularly in the north.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- falcolas 10y agoIIRC, if you provide the full keys required for decryption alongside the message, you can send encrypted messages.
- rdtsc 10y agoYou can speak Navajo though or other language...? Some communities also use heavy jargon such that unless being part of it, it is hard to really understand what is going on.