5 ms·
Streembit[0] is missing in the discussion. It's not a new company and just a FOSS project. I believe it has same if not better potential than Ethereum[1] but wi
by DyslexicAtheist 10y ago
Streembit[0] is missing in the discussion. It's not a new company and just a FOSS project. I believe it has same if not better potential than Ethereum[1] but without the risks associated with Ethereum or Bitcoin (e.g. Sybil attacks, blockchain block size debate, time it takes for proof of work, fully decentralized* etc). Plus it is up and running and can be tested by anyone who wants to give it for a spin[2]. Compared to Ethereum it has optional blockchain hooks, but uses a Kademlia[3] DHT. One can inject scripts that achieve more complex tasks (Smart-Contracts, Code to use the blockchain instead, centralization[4] logic, etc) on top of the Streembit network by injecting the Javascript into the DOM.
Streembit is currently the only such project actively participating to W3 Web of Things standardization group and already incorporates all currently evolving standards put forward by the W3 Web of Things (WoT). We're working on a proposal to standardize "IoT over P2P" that we can put forward to IETF.
[0] https://streembit.github.io https://streembit.github.io
[2] http://blog.valbonne-consulting.com/2016/06/09/streembit-hello-world-1st-ever-video-call-over-a-decentralised-p2p-network/ http://blog.valbonne-consulting.com/2016/06/09/streembit-hel...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kademlia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kademlia
[4] despite popular believe P2P networks suffer from centralization issues in P2P bootstrapping. Also Ethereum is not truly decentralized as the DAO attack shows
Disclaimer: I do not financially benefit from evangelising Streembit though I'm a voluntary contributor to the project so my position is certainly one that I would want to see them succeeed.
- the8472 10y ago> despite popular believe P2P networks suffer from centralization issues in P2P bootstrapping. That's a fairly modest problem. You need a bunch of nodes with above-average capacity to handle the bootstrap traffic and a way to occasionally update lists of such nodes. But a bunch of 10$ per quarter virtual boxes at a hoster of your choice and a bunch of domains with DNS SRV records can do that job. In the absence of any/multicast-for-everyone someone will have to pay a little money or (ab)use a handful of non-decentralized services for the bootstrapping but that's more of a philosophical problem than a practical one. There certainly is no single point of failure, you can have plenty of redundancy in the bootstrap process.
- tzpardi 10y agoThe number of existing bootstrapping nodes do not solve the fundamental problem of current centralized bootstrapping. Not even if a virtual box costs $1 instead of $10. The issue is how a connecting node knows about other nodes in the network, and the current propagation of this information i.e. the DNS or IP of the seed nodes introduces centralization. The closest and best solution for this problem was the early days idea of Bitcoin to use IRC to publish the listening seed information, but IRC still not decentralized, so IMHO decentralized bootstrapping is a real problem which we need to solve. I kicked out a discussion for this at https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/streembit-dev/Xl2DpGpd-vw https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/streembit-dev/Xl2DpG...
- the8472 10y agoIt is decentralized in the sense that it is not centralized, i.e. there is no central entity in control managing entry into the network. The key point is that any node in a p2p network can be used to join the network, so any number of independent entities can publish lists of ways to join the network. Certainly, i would also love some multicast/anycast support on the IP level, but we don't have that, so making sure that you have many independent entry points into the network is the next best thing. Maybe you're thinking distributed, not decentralized? https://i.imgur.com/YsiiKeq.png https://i.imgur.com/YsiiKeq.png
- zzzcpan 10y agoI don't think bootstrapping per se is a problem. You only have to do it on first install and this allows for a simple solution to distribute bootstrapping in time, i.e. changing hardcoded bootstrapping data every N minutes, so new users could bootstrap from different nodes, than the users before them and so on. A bigger problem is how software is developed. The development itself is centralized, but even worse, traditional software development approaches cannot predict all future problems, but rely on fixing them to keep the software working, which means it must be delivered to users in a centralized way too.
- tzpardi 10y ago