4 ms·
Wouldn't you also need a source of carbon that is not contaminated by nuclear fallout? Afaik it's not the oxygen at all but rather radio isotopes in the air, i
by dogma1138 10y ago
Wouldn't you also need a source of carbon that is not contaminated by nuclear fallout?
Afaik it's not the oxygen at all but rather radio isotopes in the air, it's the same reason we can't use carbon dating on anything since the first nuclear test because the isotope ratios are screwed up now and we can't estimate by how much.
- mikeash 10y agoDoesn't the carbon usually come from coal?
- dogma1138 10y agoI don't know for sure hence the question mark :) What I know that Carbon 14 which is used for carbon dating is a cosmogenic isotope which is created when high energy cosmic rays hit carbon atoms in the atmosphere and in other places. Nuclear tests release radiation which created much more carbon 14 than what was created with the natural process of absorbing cosmic rays. I'm not sure what's the current source of carbon for steel, I don't think it's coal it was always too impure and contain allot of contaminants especially sulfur, and I that high end crucible and powdered metal steels are made with considerably more pure and precise sources of carbon, from wikipedia it seems that the source of carbon for modern steel is charcoal (which is affected by C14 imbalance) and coke (which i have no clue if it's affected by post nuclear blast radioisotopes or not) which is refined coal but this only references to modern steel (late 17th century onwards, and I'm not sure what is used today).
- y4mi 10y agosadly, there are not private messages on HN, nor is your eMail public so i'm posting this as a comment. you might be interested in reading this http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.de/2010/04/alot-is-better-than-you-at-everything.html http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.de/2010/04/alot-is-better-... its a minor typo which you consistently repeat :)
- dogma1138 10y agokek thanks alot ;) I don't know where this typo even coming from tbh. And because allot is to allocate something my iphone doesn't autocorrects it gah. /sadpanda /happy alot
- mikeash 10y agoFunny, that's the same reason I used my question mark! If you looked it up then you're already ahead of me. Sounds like non-coal carbon is common. Although it sounds like coal could be used as a source of low-radiation carbon if you wanted to make new low-radiation steel.
- gus_massa 10y agoI'm not sure about the general case, but here in Argentina one of our biggest steel factories had a very big eucalyptus forest just to make coal. From https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aceros_Zapla_S.A https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aceros_Zapla_S.A Autotranslation: https://translate.google.com/?tab=TT#es/en/Aceros%20Zapla%20(ex-%22Altos%20Hornos%20Zapla%22)%20era%20un%20complejo%20minero-forestal%20sider%C3%BArgico%20que%20se%20encuentra%20en%20el%20departamento%20Palpal%C3%A1%2C%20provincia%20de%20Jujuy%2C%20Argentina.%20Fue%20el%20primer%20centro%20sider%C3%BArgico%20de%20Argentina%2C%20donde%20se%20realiz%C3%B3%20la%20primera%20colada%20de%20arrabio%20el%2011%20de%20octubre%20de%201945%20(70%20a%C3%B1os).%20La%20planta%20se%20encuentra%20a%2013%20km%20de%20San%20Salvador%20de%20Jujuy.%0A%0AContaba%20con%2015.000%20ha%20de%20un%20bosque%20de%2030%20millones%20de%20%C3%A1rboles%20de%20eucaliptos%20para%20extraer%20el%20carb%C3%B3n%20necesario%20en%20el%20proceso%2C%20para%20lo%20cual%20estaba%20el%20pueblo%20Centro%20Forestal.%20El%20complejo%20integraba%20dos%20minas%20de%20mineral%20de%20hierro%3A%20Mina%209%20de%20Octubre%20y%20%22Puesto%20Viejo%22%2C%20a%20no%20m%C3%A1s%20de%2027%20km%20del%20alto%20horno%3B%20y%20la%20explotaci%C3%B3n%20de%20caliza.%0A%0AEn%20la%20actualidad%20la%20fabricaci%C3%B3n%20de%20acero%20es%20a%20partir%20de%20chatarra%20exclusivamente https://translate.google.com/?tab=TT#es/en/Aceros%20Zapla%20.... > "Aceros Zapla" (ex- "Altos Hornos Zapla") was a steel forest mining complex located in the department Palpalá province of Jujuy, Argentina. It was the first steel center of Argentina [...] > It had 15,000 ha of a forest of 30 million eucalyptus trees to extract the necessary coal in the process, which was the village Forestry Center. [...] > Today's steelmaking from scrap exclusively.
- sandworm101 10y agoYou would, but coal from deep underground normally isn't. This stuff need not be strong. So you don't need a perfectly pure source of carbon, just one that isn't very radioactive. Old steel was made with carbon from coal. So while using coal isn't perfect, it's at least as good as the old steal. If you wanted to you could probably centrifuge the carbon to filter out radioactive isotopes.
- dogma1138 10y agoI don't know what steel you need but you don't use coal to make steel it would not be a good source of carbon the sulfur in it would make it very brittle. From the looks of it much of the steel is made using charcoal which is very pure form of carbon and it has very little impurities in it, or coke which is a refined fuel. Charcoal definitely absorbs radioisotopes especially Carbon 14 from atmospheric CO2 but I don't know if C14 has any effect on the suitability of the steel for aforementioned use cases. Centrifuging the carbon would be very expensive it would have to effectively be a process of converting carbon to gas (CO2 most likely) centrifuging it like one would enrich Uranium and then convert the CO2 back to carbon by assuming growing plants in an isolated environment and pumping the "distilled" CO2 into them. Then you you'll have to burn the plants to make charcoal using non-atmospheric oxygen in order to prevent atmospheric radioisotopes from being an issue again. So no I don't think anyone could centrifuge carbon to filter out the heavier elements, if anyone would do so that steel would become by far the most expensive metal on the planet by so many orders of magnitude I can't even begin to estimate it's price, you would effectively be making unobtainium.