14 ms·
For the last 4 years I have worked for the first time in my career as employee of a big corporation. The "managing class" of MBAs reminds me of the way a commun
by maxxxxx 10y ago
For the last 4 years I have worked for the first time in my career as employee of a big corporation. The "managing class" of MBAs reminds me of the way a communist state like East Germany was run. Centralized decision making, information withholding, the desire to plan out everything for years, saying one thing while meaning the opposite, hanging up motivational posters "we are innovative" while squashing innovation, ignoring of inconvenient facts and so on. All that comes with the appearance of "management science" and its own insider language.
- jostmey 10y agoUniversities and Hospitals are infected with them. Like full blown infestation.
- Amygaz 10y agoYep! But his is not like an autoimmune disorder (e.g. type 1 diabetes). It's more like an acquire disease (i.e. type 2 diabetes), for which we fully understand how to prevent and alleviate, but somehow do not implement the necessary measures.
- marblar 10y agoGuess whose job it is to implement the necessary measures.
- lostlogin 10y agoLet's sort that at the preliminary scoping meeting before assigning it a team at the next quarterly.
- popmystack 10y agoThis comment is exactly what's wrong with the general hackernews community. You couldn't be more off base.
- bluejekyll 10y agoDid you read the article? This comment, while mildly joking, is derived from that article. I think the most important thing that it says: people should do a better job of thinking, and do less of regurgitating other people's philosophies. The points at the end are quite good, if very abstract.
- crdoconnor 10y agoIt's more like a host/parasite relationship. The cure, in any case (unionization of the value producers), isn't particularly obvious to most.
- mymosh 10y agoHow do you unionize just the value producers, without also unionizing (and entrenching) layers of middle management?
- crdoconnor 10y agoWhy would middle management need unionization?
- mymosh 10y agoWould a senior programmer be ejected from the union when they are promoted to say a project manager? I'm just not sure you can isolate value producers.
- crdoconnor 10y agoThe key question isn't "do they produce value?", it's "can they hire and fire?" Once people acquire power over resources/people the shift from value creation to value extraction is pretty natural.
- lsc 10y ago> The key question isn't "do they produce value?", it's "can they hire and fire?" This is traditionally the line that people draw, yes, but I think the reasons for that come from the other end. That's the thing; the manager who manages the cashiers at the grocery store doesn't have more power than the individual contributor software engineer who writes the software for the registers, not in any reasonable sense. That's not why the the line is traditionally drawn where it is. The line is traditionally drawn where it is because it is management's job to act as a proxy for the will and interests of the owners, and pretending to do that while being in the same union as the workers would be very difficult, or at the very least, quite awkward.
- horsecaptin 10y agoNow you know why healthcare and education costs so much in America.
- digi_owl 10y agoIt is spreading to the rest of the world under the "new public management" moniker. Effectively it is a scheme of metrics, and attached incentives and punishments, cooked up by MBAs to emulate market mechanics within public services.
- jacques_chester 10y agoWell, yes. This is because both are examples of command economies and both evolve additional non-hierarchical mechanisms to achieve actual outcomes. In any large enterprise there is always a Nomenklatura who actually "make things happen". When explaining to people that trying, for the billionth time, to create The Perfect Reward Scheme won't work, I put it this way: GOSPLAN had decades, and access to unlimited men with guns and dogs, to make its plans work. And it failed.
- ced 10y agoSo what's the alternative?
- Spooky23 10y agoPush decision making out as far as possible.
- WillAbides 10y agoDon't participate
- Spooky23 10y agoI've been part of that group within large organizations at a few different levels. It's both an intensely rewarding experience -- you get to fix things that are broken and get a lot of creative license. Simultaneously, it's also intensely depressing, as you get to learn how the metaphorical sausage is made.
- dingbat 10y agonot to discount your experience, but how do you know that your sense of being part of the core group that actually "makes things happen" isnt shared by many others who also feel that they belong to the group that really runs the place?
- Spooky23 10y agoI'm sure that people feel that way. And to some extent they are correct -- ultimately they keep the trains running. But few other teams can do anything new in a reasonable period. Unfortunately I think that "truth" is a tough nut to crack in political scenarios. Perception generally rules the day, and most of these teams that play that role are successful in acquiring the trappings of corporate power -- fast action on HR, access to the decision makers/purse stringers, and perks. It doesn't last forever, because like in the Soviet system, these things depend on powerful patrons.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>The "managing class" of MBAs reminds me of the way a communist state like East Germany was run. Centralized decision making, information withholding, the desire to plan out everything for years, saying one thing while meaning the opposite, hanging up motivational posters "we are innovative" while squashing innovation, ignoring of inconvenient facts and so on. Huh? What's wrong with centralized decision making and planning out everything for years? The rest I can agree with, but 1) in any company, you need centralized decision making or you won't get anything done; the point of a company is not to be a democracy, it's to be a machine that generates profit, and centralized decision making accomplishes that. And 2) what can possibly be wrong with planning things out far ahead? I worked at Intel for years and they did this, and it worked, for the most part. (Obviously, circumstances forced plans to be altered or even abandoned at times.) If you don't have a plan several years out of what you want to be doing, you're not going to accomplish anything big. How do you think the Moon missions could have worked if they didn't plan that out years in advance? It sounds to me like you're comparing whatever little podunk 20-person company you used to work at with the big corporation you find yourself in now, and you're trying to assume that everything the little company did was somehow correct. It wasn't; the big company got to be a big company by doing something right. Many of the other things you complain about just sound like typical bad management, and things you'll find in any organization that isn't perfect. Information withholding and saying one thing and meaning the opposite and ignoring inconvenient facts: aren't those common with the US government? I saw these in several small companies I've worked in (and big companies too). It's not unique to big companies. There's definitely more of it in poorly-run companies, which should be no surprise. There's no shortage of poorly-run companies out there, big and small. As for the motivational posters, that's a fad (though admittedly it's been around a good 15-20 years now). I recommend getting your own motivational posters and hanging them in your cubicle (if you even have a cubicle; working at big companies was a lot nicer 10-20 years ago before this idiotic "open plan office" craze). You can get some excellent posters [here](https://www.despair.com/collections/demotivators https://www.despair.com/collections/demotivators). (What kind of site calling itself "Hacker News" doesn't even support some kind of basic markup for embedding links? Come on guys.)
- naasking 10y ago> What's wrong with centralized decision making and planning out everything for years? The rest I can agree with, but 1) in any company, you need centralized decision making or you won't get anything done; the point of a company is not to be a democracy, it's to be a machine that generates profit, and centralized decision making accomplishes that. No it doesn't. Top-level decision makers are poorly informed about what's possible and what's actually effective. Complete top-down decision making is Dilbert incarnate. Top-level executives need to make the goals of the company clear to team managers, and that's not just "profit", and they need to set the constraints that any direction in pursuit of those goals must satisfy (such as legal or marketing requirements), and let the engineers find optimal solutions within that space. Engineers excel at finding effective solutions given a set of constraints, executives excel at defining business policies that effectively shape a successful business. Let each employ their appropriate skill set. > And 2) what can possibly be wrong with planning things out far ahead? Inflexibility to changing market conditions. Having invested time, money and effort into forming such an intricate long-term plan drives us to stupidly believing sunk cost fallacies, and ignore evidence of ineffectiveness.
- PythonicAlpha 10y agoI always find it a very negative sign for a company, when the corridors are getting filled with pep talk posters, which could have come directly from the latest management magazine. For me it is a clear sign, that innovation and real work done in the company is going rapidly downwards. Continuously repeating, how good "we" are clearly says, that the company is currently "not good enough". What might work in personal psychology, does not in corporations, where everything else tells the workers, that their work does not count, but only the work of the poster creators.
- Elrac 10y agoCan confirm. I've heard that my company has been told to tighten the belt, that there are a lot of positions in the company that don't produce value to paying customers. At pretty much the same time, I'm seeing a wave of self-aggrandizing motivational posters. I think I see a connection.
- cafard 10y agoA woman of my acquaintance, a substitute teacher in one of the local school systems, has said that the number of posters about values and respect is in inverse proportion to the quality of the schooling.
- pasbesoin 10y agoAmen. That's a very good, concise, and apt description. It mirrors my own not inconsiderable experience. I simply can't take it anymore.
- MagnumOpus 10y agoDon't blame the MBA degree as the root cause of these symptoms. I have had a Mathematics PhD manager who exemplified these exact traits to a T. Doing an MBA is just a symptom of the ladder-climbing mentality, just like the buzzword bingo, the elevation of ignorance to a virtue and the do-as-we-say-not-as-we-do leadership.