4 ms·
This paper is highly, highly questionable. First, if the exhaust is photons, you have a photon rocket. These are easy to build: any light source will do. In
by amluto 10y ago
This paper is highly, highly questionable.
First, if the exhaust is photons, you have a photon rocket. These are easy to build: any light source will do. In special relativity, a photon, like any other massless particle, has momentum p = E/c, or roughly p = E * 0.003 N/MW. The article claims the EM drive gets 0.4 Newton/kW, so the numbers are an order of magnitude off.
Second, the paper says "also when photons attain thermodynamic balance with matter in the cavity, their number is changing, but the photons themselves do not vanish for nothing at absorption to the walls and they do not emerge from nothing at emission from atoms constituting the walls." Photons are bosons, and bosons do get freely created and destroyed. Where do you think the photons in the light from a flashlight (incandescent or otherwise) comes from?
Third, if you don't like perturbation theory and you don't like thermodynamics, you can calculate the force carried by an electromagnetic field directly. Zero field gives zero force.
So, sure, if you're willing to ignore a lot of very well-tested physics, you're welcome to believe this paper.
[the actual paper is at http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/journal/adva/6/6/10.1063/1.4953807 http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/journal/adva/6/6/10.106...]
- Filligree 10y agoI would add that photons, like all other particles, don't have identity. They're 'ripples' in the electromagnetic field; if you cancel them out, then you don't get a ghost photon. You just get no photon.
- dogma1138 10y ago>cancel them out Do you mean destructive interference? because the photons don't go anywhere, they don't disappear, the energy of the wave function and hence the photons remains the same. Other than a photon being absorbed there is no way to "cancel out" a photon, you also don't really have a way to cancel out light with destructive interference because some where else there will be a constructive interference, if we could just "cancel out" light we would have cloaking devices by now ;)
- amluto 10y ago> Do you mean destructive interference? because the photons don't go anywhere, they don't disappear, the energy of the wave function and hence the photons remains the same. Not quite. If both waves are plane waves, the interference could be destructive everywhere or, depending on the setup, destructive everywhere except between your sources. If you calculate the time-averaged power needed to source the waves, it'll sum to zero. And there are no photons in the far field.
- dogma1138 10y agoYes quite, plane waves physically don't exist in reality they are a mathematical idealization. Again you can't make an "anti laser".
- jepler 10y agoThanks, my first question was exactly the one you answered: "is the proposed mechanism within an order of magnitude of explaining the observed thrust?" It sounds like it's not.
- amluto 10y agoIt's worth noting that, depending on how they wired the thing, they could get an extra power of two. Energy carried in massless form, including in a wire, has the same force of (power / c). So, if you wire the thing up so the power cable comes in the back, your apparent efficiency will double. Of course, this is useless in a spaceship that carries its own power source. (Unless you're a solar sail or powered by a ground-based laser.) Actually accounting for the force in a transmission line (e.g. where is it in space) or, for that matter, the power, is notoriously complicated. Also, real wires have tension as well as magic Maxwell's Equations force. I wonder whether the experimenters tried leaving the power cable in place and turning the cavity around. If the thing really worked and they corrected for their cable correctly, they should observe the same thrust in the other direction.
- dogma1138 10y ago>Energy carried in massless form, including in a wire, has the same force of (power / c). What?
- amluto 10y agoTake a pair of parallel wires carrying a current and with a potential difference such that the power flows left to right. Calculate the Poynting vector everywhere along a plane perpendicular to the wires, and you'll find that the power flux is distributed across the plane and that there's a momentum flux, i.e. a force. If you use AC or more complicated shapes, the calculation gets gnarlier.
- dogma1138 10y agoYes that's the electric flux in the field but it has no bearing on this whatsoever, it's also one of the first thing they've isolated while testing the damn thing.
- empath75 10y ago> First, if the exhaust is photons, you have a photon rocket. I was wondering about that. Why not just use a flashlight?