3 ms·

I admit that these numbers do not include people who did not apply for asylum. But in your own source theres a chart showing the distribution of all 1.0919M re

I admit that these numbers do not include people who did not apply for asylum. But in your own source theres a chart showing the distribution of all 1.0919M registered entries. 39.2% Syrian 14.1% Afganistan 11.1% Irak I'd say even though not all of the 1.1M register as asylum seekers (or have not yet registered). Their distribution is quite similar to that of the people who registered.

DominikR 10y ago
Most applicants from Afghanistan are not granted asylum at the moment. The problem is that Afghanistan isn't willing to take them back. Also it isn't like everyone from Iraq is given asylum. Oh and btw - NGOs in Europe are actively teaching prospective asylum seekers to say they are from Syria. Most of them do not even speak Arabic. Edit: reply to comment below: Please see this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=11928413 https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=11928413 "More than half of those fleeing to Europe from the Middle East and Africa are economic migrants and not asylum seekers fleeing the horrors of war in Iraq or Syria, according to first vice-president of the European Commission, Frans Timmermans.
- timtammittee 10y ago
  In the Frontex Western Balkans Annual Risk Analysis 2016 Frontex investigated Nationality swapping and they found: "In 2015, 173 042 migrants who claimed Syrian nationality were screened; of which 85.8% were assumed by screeners to be Syrian nationals. As regards the rest, 8.6% were assumed to be Iraqi; 2.5% Palestinian, 1% Moroccan, and 2.1% were assumed to be of other nationality." So yes, 14.2% of the people who claimed to be from Syria really originated somewhere else. But, if we again sum up those who come from a country who is currently in a state of conflict (I included Palestine), we gain 97%. Edit: Also, you should note that people are screened again during the process of applying for asylum. So I guess the number of wrongly assigned nationalities is neglectable.

DominikR 10y ago

Most applicants from Afghanistan are not granted asylum at the moment. The problem is that Afghanistan isn't willing to take them back. Also it isn't like everyone from Iraq is given asylum. Oh and btw - NGOs in Europe are actively teaching prospective asylum seekers to say they are from Syria. Most of them do not even speak Arabic. Edit: reply to comment below: Please see this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=11928413 https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=11928413 "More than half of those fleeing to Europe from the Middle East and Africa are economic migrants and not asylum seekers fleeing the horrors of war in Iraq or Syria, according to first vice-president of the European Commission, Frans Timmermans.

timtammittee 10y ago
In the Frontex Western Balkans Annual Risk Analysis 2016 Frontex investigated Nationality swapping and they found: "In 2015, 173 042 migrants who claimed Syrian nationality were screened; of which 85.8% were assumed by screeners to be Syrian nationals. As regards the rest, 8.6% were assumed to be Iraqi; 2.5% Palestinian, 1% Moroccan, and 2.1% were assumed to be of other nationality." So yes, 14.2% of the people who claimed to be from Syria really originated somewhere else. But, if we again sum up those who come from a country who is currently in a state of conflict (I included Palestine), we gain 97%. Edit: Also, you should note that people are screened again during the process of applying for asylum. So I guess the number of wrongly assigned nationalities is neglectable.