3 ms·
> this weird zone where it's kind of law, but kind of also the United States can do whatever they want because they own all the aircraft carriers and what are y
by toyg 10y ago
> this weird zone where it's kind of law, but kind of also the United States can do whatever they want because they own all the aircraft carriers and what are you going to do about it punk?
That definition should go on university books, seriously. A lot of what we talk about when we discuss "international law" is a contorted way of making this or that nation prominence as morally justified.
> and no other nation would bat an eye
... however, this is a bit too cynical. The UK definitely did "bat an eye" when Hitler seized Gdańsk/Danzig. Russia is currently under sanctions after its Crimea annexation. Just because we don't constantly respond to crisis with full military force, it doesn't mean that we don't care.
I personally don't see the equivalence between this situation and international law, because this can really be resolved by a higher power (the State), if necessary by suppressing ethereum altogether. In international relations, there is simply no higher power.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> Russia is currently under sanctions after its Crimea annexation. Aye. And who's going to sanction the US for Iraq and Afghanistan? Russia? The fact that sanctions are imposed one-sidedly, only to the designated adversaries of the US is a testament to the fact that "international law" is just the will of whoever can enforce it (currently the US, duh).
- krrrh 10y agoWhile you could say that the invasions of Afganistan and Iraq were misguided or detrimental, they are in a different legal category than outright annexation or territory, which also violated a specific clause in an agreement signed between Ukriane and Russia.
- iofj 10y agoI think this is a major example of the fact that international law doesn't exist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Security_Assurances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit... You see: America and the UK signed a treaty with Ukraine that specified that [1], in trade for Ukraine giving up the nuclear weapons it had "inherited" from the USSR, they would go to war with Russia if Russia violated the territorial integrity of Ukraine (and this explicitly covers Crimea) As everybody knows, Russia invaded Crimea. The US ... well ... essentially canceled Putin's netflix subscription. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Security_Assurances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit... Remember this the next time someone says somebody violates human rights. You have no human rights (in the sense that you can sue someone for violating your human rights. Of course in the US, you would almost never need to, except if you get a one way ticket to Guantanamo. And those cases ... failed). That means complaints about human rights are nothing more than a political talking point. But don't worry, the government that executed 15 people so far this year for calling for elections is guarding your human rights ! [2] [2] http://havecoffeewillwrite.com/?p=47493 http://havecoffeewillwrite.com/?p=47493 Of course if you said that it's the religion of islam itself that's a human rights violation. Well, at least for sharia, that's certainly true.
- sgentle 10y agoI agree that there are situations where eyes would be bat, just not in the case of seasteading or trying to declare a new micronation in the Danube. Even in the case of Danzig and Crimea, I would argue it's as much about the country doing the seizing as the people being seized. Most likely if Putin decided to put boots on the ground(?) in Sealand, the West would care just because fuck that guy. I think the parallel isn't in the way that the State might swoop in and do State things, rather that until or unless that happens, Ethereum exists in a similar contradictory place where in principle it's a system of laws but in practice the nation-state miners will decide what happens.