4 ms·
>iPhone 6s It's a funny thing with monks. Quite a few are former businessman who want to try something more spiritual for a change but still are wealthy. I wal
by tim333 10y ago
>iPhone 6s
It's a funny thing with monks. Quite a few are former businessman who want to try something more spiritual for a change but still are wealthy. I walked a bit with a young monk on the way to Tengboche Monastery and his main interest as we talked seemed to be designer sunglasses and which brand would be good to get.
- coldtea 10y ago>It's a funny thing with monks. Quite a few are former businessman who want to try something more spiritual for a change but still are wealthy. So mostly phonies being tourists in spiritual-land?
- nsomaru 10y agoRenunciation is defined with reference to your mental attitude towards possessions, not the presence or absence thereof. See, for example the 'Royal Sage' (Raja Rshi).
- coldtea 10y agoHypocrisy though is defined by "the presence or absence thereof".
- cscurmudgeon 10y agoThat is a Western view of things where spiritual and material realms are different. Dharmic religions consider the spiritual realm to be a superset of the material, not separate from it.
- fnordsensei 10y agoYou meant to write "the spiritual realm to be a superset…", I'm sure.
- cscurmudgeon 10y agoGah!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- christophilus 10y agoNot really. Detachment from love of material possessions doesn't imply having no material possessions. It implies a lack of a disordered love for them. The true test of hypocrisy would be to see how one of those monks responds when his phone gets stolen.
- davesque 10y agoAttachment also applies to doctrine and ideas.
- nsomaru 10y agoYou're right, of course, but it's not binary (either you're attached or you're detached). Instead, the idea is to become attached to subtler (read: causing more lasting happiness) aspects of life, as a consequence of which one becomes detached from the grosser (read: causing more fleeting happiness) aspects. This moving in stages applies on physical, emotional and intellectual levels. Jumping to absolute detachment is not really possible.
- tim333 10y agoI'm not sure a former businessman being spiritual is particularly more phony than anyone else doing it.
- davesque 10y agoPerhaps, but based on a similar experience I had with a Tibetan monk, I'd say there's actually quite a lot of room for flexibility. Just because someone has a handful of materialistic interests doesn't mean they're incapable of being a good person or teacher. That was probably the main lesson I learned from the monk I knew. As outsiders, we often have a very romanticized, storybook view of monkhood that doesn't line up with reality.