3 ms·
Uh, regardless of your stance on the specific topic (refugee handling), isn't this simply a tactical mistake? Let's say the EU is your enemy. They offer you mo
by toyg 10y ago
Uh, regardless of your stance on the specific topic (refugee handling), isn't this simply a tactical mistake?
Let's say the EU is your enemy. They offer you money. Is it tactically smarter to flatly refuse the money (you are poorer, your enemy is marginally richer, nothing has changed) or rather to accept the money and then use it to fight the donor (you are richer, your enemy is marginally poorer and you are effectively turning its resources against itself)?
It feels a lot like cutting your own nose to spite the wife.
- CydeWeys 10y agoThey are hoping that refusing funding will put pressure on the EU to change its harsh stances. I don't think it'll be that effective but that's what they're going for. Yes, in the short term they will suffer for funding.
- nxzero 10y agoSay you are a non-profit that helps drug addicts, should you take money from drug dealers?
- caoilte 10y agoI think he's saying that, "Yes, you should use that money and you should use it to hire Chuck Norris."
- nxzero 10y agoAnd I'm saying that's a horrible childish responses to a situation like this.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoWhy not? Often, addiction centers get money from health insurers, who are in effect dealers in opioids, etc.
- ferbivore 10y agoIf you can find a drug dealer dumb enough to give you money, it would be irresponsible to not take it. That said, your situation has practically nothing in common with MSF's.
- nxzero 10y agoUntrue. Drug dealers often fund rehabilitation groups; good way to find customers, double profits, identify rats, etc. True rehab centers would never take funds from a dealer, and would be happy to go out of business because there were no more addicts in the world. Refugees in the EU would not need Doctors Without Borders; in Turkey, refugees will need Doctors Without Borders. If the EU wants to help Doctors Without Borders' mission, then it needs to take refugees and help them, not make more refugees Doctors Without Borders to help.
- ferbivore 10y agoI didn't realise you meant "take money and also give them your client list in return". If you're going to add strings like that to your question, the answer will obviously be no.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rvense 10y agoThat's one (perfectly valid) way of looking at it. An (IMO equally valid) way of looking at it is that the EU is not 'the enemy' but rather someone you hoped was your ally. But now they're acting against your mission, in a way you feel is unacceptable. They've changed and you can no longer stand with them. In that situation, disassociating from them (with no regard for the tactics) is a sign of integrity.
- petra 10y agoEven so, their view is a bit unrealistic - if the people of the EU don't want to accept refugees, and leaders can't convince them otherwise, why should leaders disobey the people ? Altough one could critize the way refugees we're handled by the authorities - instead of mixing them with the population and surfacing all kinds of tensions, they should have closed, but safe and decent refugee camps, and seperate refugees from the population(and also solve the issue of economic immigration). but now might be too late.
- toyg 10y ago"Camps" in Europe do exist (for all the bad imagery from the last century of European history that the word evokes), but they're chronically overwhelmed. Authorities don't want to fund them, local population often goes NIMBY for the same reasons they don't want them in the country altogether. Like prison, camps tend to amplify and reinforce bad behaviour from all sides. > and also solve the issue of economic immigration Yeah, like that was easy :) most immigrants actually come from failed states like Eritrea, which you just can't "fix" in any easy way. I do agree that economic migrants should be treated differently from war refugees; as in, we should find ways to power economic and social programs that would directly allow economic migrants to return. Pay them to dig holes over there, if necessary. It won't fix the country, but it should stem the flow. War refugees should be hosted and treated humanly though. Their conflicts are often "our" direct fault and we have an obligation to treat them fairly. US/UK/France are particularly bad in this, constantly getting involved in all sorts of international diatribes while rarely (if ever) actually picking up the tab when things go to hell.
- 10y ago
- tgb 10y agoThe point is to persuade people. I'm persuaded, because I firmly believe that msf values these redugees strongly and that the only reason they would refuse funds would be if they thought the situation truly dire. Think of self starvation protests, but at an organizational level.