4 ms·
> sending a message that caring for people forced from their homes is optional So, they're implying that it's mandatory? How come? Admitting foreign citizens,
by golergka 10y ago
> sending a message that caring for people forced from their homes is optional
So, they're implying that it's mandatory? How come? Admitting foreign citizens, spending resources on them sounds like a definition of charity — how charity can not be optional?
- raverbashing 10y agoPretty much this I understand the refugees are in a difficult position, but there is a limit to the help that can be given (which should be obvious) If MSF doesn't want the money that's fine.
- dalke 10y agoThere are "limits" and there are "limits". If the receiving country has no room, is broke, and its citizenry are on the edge of starvation, then that's one limit. Somehow I don't think that's the limit you are talking about, but that's the only obvious one I can think of. What do you think is the limit, and why do you think the EU countries already past or even near to that limit?
- raverbashing 10y agoThe limit is the receiving countries not becoming what they're fleeing from, obviously If you disagree, my suggestion is that you take in your house as many refugees as the number of people that currently live in it. > If the receiving country has no room, is broke, and its citizenry are on the edge of starvation, then that's one limit. Oh of course, let's destroy whole countries otherwise people like you will think they're racist and petty. Genius.
- dalke 10y agoBoo-hoo. I live in Sweden. We have taken in huge numbers of people. I will gladly pay extra in taxes to help them out. Sweden is also far from becoming like Syria. If Sweden's policy is the limit, then most of the other EU countries fall far short of the limit you are concerned about.
- raverbashing 10y ago> Boo-hoo. I live in Sweden. We have taken in huge numbers of people. The difference between being charitable and naive is a thin one. > Sweden is also far from becoming like Syria. Let's hope so. And while I agree most of the "news" on the Internet about Sweden are crap, Sweden has an important gender imbalance and increasing problems with violence Also nobody speaks anything and pretends it doesn't happen because "it's racist". Like: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/11/swedish-police-accused-cover-up-sex-attacks-refugees-festival https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/11/swedish-police... > then most of the other EU countries fall far short of the limit you are concerned about Portugal and Spain are looking for more people but it doesn't seem anybody wants to go there.
- dalke 10y agoSo you agree that most of the EU countries are not near the limits that you are worried about, yes? Then why aren't they taking more refugees?
- raverbashing 10y ago> Then why aren't they taking more refugees? I know it's a matter of wording, but no country "takes", but has people apply for asylum either before going or when there. Though Canada provided transportation to those approved. It can be said that countries might need to facilitate/advertise this more (and not only in Europe). Some South American countries took some people as well (not as much as Europe though) Oh and Poland received a lot of refugees from Ukraine (some say around 1Mi)
- dalke 10y agoTake has many shades of meaning. "We take AmEx" means "We accept American Express card if you wish to pay that way." It doesn't mean that if I see an AmEx card I grab it. If it helps, feel free to interpret my use of "taking" as short for "taking in", with meaning of "to admit; receive".
- lucio 10y agoSo, by following your reasoning, a sound-economy country, should receive aliens until such receiving country has no room, is broke, and everybody are on the edge of starvation?
- dalke 10y agoNo. Everyone agrees that there are material limits to what a country can provide. It is indeed obvious that there is a limit to the amount of help that a country can provide. But raverbashing used a bait-and-switch argument, to say that because there are limits, we (people who live in the EU), can now prevent refugees from entering the EU countries. What I asked is clarification of what those limits are, and how they were determined. One limit is "tolerance for foreigners." That's certainly a limit. Is that the limit that raverbashing is talking about? Another limit is "there is no place to put them." Sweden has problems with that. I can think of other limits. But none are the sort of existential limits that everyone agrees exists.
- xyzzy4 10y agoI'm guessing the perceived limit is that NIMBYs feel too uncomfortable to handle more refugees? It doesn't seem like a real limit to me.
- forgotpwtomain 10y agoHow about Europe taking responsibility for their interventionist policies in the Middle East and their support for the US military agenda in the Middle East which created most of these problems in the first place?
- Drakim 10y agoFirst of all, Europe is not one country. To hold the entirely of Europe responsible for what some countries do is just as absurd as holding all of Asia responsible for what China does. Secondly, many countries inside Europe have opposed US military actions in the Middle East.
- forgotpwtomain 10y ago> First of all, Europe is not one country. To hold the entirely of Europe responsible for what some countries do is just as absurd as holding all of Asia responsible for what China does. Germany, France and the UK (which actively supported interventions in the Middle East) contribute ~50% of the EU budget - it's silly to even suggest that these laws are being passed without their support. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union#EU-28_contributions_.282014.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union#E... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Afghanistan_(2001%E2%80%9314) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Afghanistan_(2001%E2%80... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_Libya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_involvement_in_the_Syrian_Civil_War#Support_for_the_Syrian_opposition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_involvement_in_the_Syr...
- Drakim 10y agoEU != Europe. I live in Europe yet I'm not part of the European Union. Also, measuring by "budget", what's up with that? At least use population number or something that's semi reasonable. It's roughly the same as thinking that the US == Continent America, and that Canada, Argentina and Mexico should be responsible for the actions of the US.
- RobertoG 10y agoThere are many cases where helping others is legally mandatory. For instance, if you find somebody stranded at sea. But we are talking about countries here, so legality is not the issue. The issue is, in my opinion, that for years, the EU have sold itself as an humanist endeavour. There is also the issue that we, Europeans, are responsible for a lot of what this people is running away. There is also the practical issue that hide one's head in the sand it's not going to solve the problem. Oh, and there are ethics, of course. But that is a boring unfashionable issue, so we will forget about it.
- igk 10y agoThey are specifically talking about "sending a message that caring is optional". Not quite the same thing. Going on your second question, there are good arguments on why not being charitable, solidaric, or however you want to call it is immoral and shortsighted. The strongest for me are 1) if you accept human dignity as an inalienable right (one of the tenets of humanism) then you have already created an ethics in which you either care or are immmoral 2) more pragmatically, by not being charitable and solidarity, you imply a) that the world has winners and losers,b)with the winners having the right to treat the losers poorly,c)that you are a winner and always will be. That to me is delusional and suboptimal, since at any point a blood clot could render you helpless.
- raverbashing 10y ago> on why not being charitable, solidaric, or however you want to call it is immoral and shortsighted Which is a very nice strawman > if you accept human dignity as an inalienable right (one of the tenets of humanism) then you have already created an ethics in which you either care or are immmoral Nice way in making people guilty and only seeing black and white. You are as intolerant as ISIS, you're just not killing people for it > a) that the world has winners and losers,b)with the winners having the right to treat the losers poorly,c)that you are a winner and always will be Again, you see the world in pure black and white. > That to me is delusional and suboptimal Yes, see the above point
- johncolanduoni 10y ago> Which is a very nice strawman I'm curious as to what is a strawman in that statement? You are arguing charity should be optional, he said "not being charitable". Where in that sentence is he misrepresenting the position he is claiming is immoral and shortsighted? Is the word solidaric that much of a sticking point? I've found quite a few arguments against allowing the influx of migrants from the middle east to continue unabated to be at the very least reasonable (I have family in Greece that are seeing it first hand), but none of them start and end with "black and white", with the middle filled with comparisons to ISIS. If you have something to say about the actual issue, I'd love to hear it.
- dalke 10y agoBecause the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, of which the EU countries are signatory, gives special status to refugees. This status is not the same as simply "admitting foreign citizens." For example: > The Convention further stipulates that, subject to specific exceptions, refugees should not be penalized for their illegal entry or stay. This recognizes that the seeking of asylum can require refugees to breach immigration rules.
- manmal 10y agoI read that most refugees pouring into the EU are there for economical reasons, and states argue that as such they don't have to admit them. Cannot find that article right now.
- zyngaro 10y agoThey should let only wealthy refugees in then right ?
- corin_ 10y agoThe question isn't whether being rich/poor affects somebody's potential status as a refugee for non-economic reasons (e.g. persecution in their home country), it's whether enconomic reasons alone are enough to justify "refugee" status. Which side you come down on regarding this is subjective, but either way your comment isn't relevant.
- dalke 10y ago"Many" as in absolute values like "more than 1,000"? I can believe that. Or "many" as in relative values like "more than 30%"? I have difficulties believing that. If so, it's amazing how coincidental the timing is between the start of the ongoing civil war in Syria and the start of the refugee crisis. It's also amazing how the UN "has identified 13.5 million Syrians requiring humanitarian assistance, of which 6.6 million are internally displaced within Syria, and over 4.8 million are refugees outside of Syria." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_W... . Are the ones you mentioned in addition to those numbers?