4 ms·
Those deep structure may be active, but reading was never in their design documentation. Our brains evolved to what they are today long before reading was a th
by sandworm101 10y ago
Those deep structure may be active, but reading was never in their design documentation. Our brains evolved to what they are today long before reading was a thing. The fact that we read so well is probably a hacked-together scheme tying together structures meant for pattern recognition and speech.
I see reading much like swimming. None of us can swim without practice, as none of us can read. The scary thing is that even the best of us can only swim about as well as the average dog. So pity us on the day we find a creature actually designed for reading.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> I see reading much like swimming. None of us can swim without practice, as none of us can read. Newborn babies can swim, obviously with no practice. In fact isn't it a classic example of an instinctive human behaviour?
- xorcist 10y agoNewborns can't swim in the sense that they stay afloat. A baby will drown if dropped in water. They do have some reflexes related to swimming, in that they will hold their breath and work their feet, but those reflexes disappear with time and have to be re-learned. It's fair to say that swimming is a learned practice.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> ... will hold their breath and work their feet. Imho that isn't related to swimming. That's them trying to keep their heads above water by standing up, hopefully in relatively shallow water. Even with drowning adults, they don't so much try to swim as try to grasp onto something. Compare dogs. They have a swimming instinct dedicated to movement. Dogs don't tread. They move forwards. We flail around trying to climb out of the water. They are trying to get to shore. That has to be some sort of evolutionary relic speaking to very different ancestral environments. Polar bears instincts accommodate both treading water and swimming within moments: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scFiRRTU5jg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scFiRRTU5jg
- Tharkun 10y ago> structures meant for "Meant"? Nothing in your body or brain is "meant" for anything. There is no "meaning", or "intention", for starters. And the brain is nothing if not adaptable. If your brain is "meant" to be anything, it's versatile.
- sandworm101 10y agoThere are parts of the brain meant for specific tasks. It isn't a homogeneous mass of neurons. The bit that is working the eyes atm was designed (via evolution) to work the eyes. As was the bit that takes the message from the eyes and ups the heart rate when a lion appears in your field of view. There is certainly some flexibility, but the basic task layout is a layout, not a random allocation.
- nommm-nommm 10y ago>The bit that is working the eyes atm was designed (via evolution) to work the eyes. Evolution is a random process, there is no designing, there's no goals.
- sandworm101 10y ago(1) Evolution is not random. Mutation may be random, but feature selection is based on a rule. (2) There is a goal: species survival. (3) The only rule is that whatever aids (2) is a rule for purposes of (1).
- gumby 10y agoSpecies survival? Gene reproduction you mean. The organism is simply a way for the gene to propagate itself. Check out Dawkins' The Selfish Gene.
- sandworm101 10y agoI disagree with Dawkins. If genes were the unit for evolution, we wouldn't exists. We would all just be bacteria spewing out copies of genes, with the planet buried in a pile of tiny protein chains. Genes are the servants of the species. They are a tool used by species to pass on traits, or even to acquire traits from other species. Genes are inert absent a species using them.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> Our brains evolved to what they are today long before reading was a thing. You could be on a poster for "evolution stops at the neck". Obviously, our brains did not evolve to what they are today long before reading was a thing, because that happened before today. There was no point at which brains stopped evolving.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> There was no point at which brains stopped evolving. Evolution operates on a different timescale. For all intents and purposes, our physical structure hasn't evolved since reading became widespread in the population perhaps a couple hundred years ago.
- tremon 10y agoMore like five thousand years ago: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_A#Chronology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_A#Chronology and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumerian_script#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumerian_script#History
- thaumasiotes 10y agoCharitably, reading was not "widespread in the population" at that time. sandworm101's comment shows a pretty appalling understanding of evolution -- the selective pressure for reading ability exists as soon as anyone can benefit from learning to read, not when everyone is required to try -- but a somewhat better understanding of history. Very high literacy rates within endogamous subpopulations go back much farther than a couple hundred years, though.
- gnicholas 10y agoThere's an excellent book [1] that explores the neurological aspects of language. TLDR: language evolved to be efficient for our existing brain structures—our brains did not evolve to be good at language. 1: https://www.amazon.com/Reading-Brain-New-Science-Read/dp/0143118056 https://www.amazon.com/Reading-Brain-New-Science-Read/dp/014...