3 ms·
>> The research also found that among the billion-dollar startup companies, they have collectively created more than 65,000 jobs. Immigrants clearly play a sign
by sandworm101 10y ago
>> The research also found that among the billion-dollar startup companies, they have collectively created more than 65,000 jobs. Immigrants clearly play a significant role in job creation, entrepreneurship and the startup ecosystem in the U.S.
Can we please get over this idea that founders conjure jobs out of thin air. Startups and the jobs they create fill a niche in the economy. That niche is the product of the wider world, not the whim of a founder. Even where a startup does create apparently "new" jobs, they often result in other jobs disappearing elsewhere (see uber v. taxis). Bringing in foreign investment is great. But we don't need to treat well-funded founders as a special class beyond the numerous advantages that already come with being well-funded.
I would hate to be the new hire at a "startup" which turns out to be an immigration dodge, a means of getting a group of founders the necessary documentation. There are already other visa categories for such things (EB-5).
- johncolanduoni 10y ago> Can we please get over this idea that founders conjure jobs out of thin air. Startups and the jobs they create fill a niche in the economy. That niche is the product of the wider world, not the whim of a founder. Sure, but practically if not letting a founder enter the country and create a startup means those jobs won't happen, then how does it change the argument for more startup-friendly immigration at all? Are you saying that enough startups with immigrating founders are removing jobs elsewhere like Uber to make it a net negative? > There are already other visa categories for such things (EB-5). How about for the foreign founders who don't have $1mm to throw around? I can't say I have data on this, but I suspect $1mm of funds/founder is not reasonable for a lot of startups.
- falsestprophet 10y agoIf an entrepreneur moves to Canada or Europe to start their brilliant company, what makes you think an American (or American immigrant) founded and funded derivative company can't beat them in the market and create the jobs here anyway? If Uber was founded in Toronto or London or Shanghai, are you sure that Lyft wouldn't have crushed them?
- rahimnathwani 10y agoHas Uber really reduced the number of jobs for taxi drivers? If that were the case, then it would mean the average number of medallioned taxis in service (either carrying a passenger, or driving around looking for a passenger) has gone down. Is there any evidence that this is the case? Or is it just that medallion owners get a lower cut from taxi revenues now?