8 ms·
No-tipping experiment at Costa Mesa restaurants axed
- lox 10y agoSometimes it's painful to realize how not economically rational people are.
- jimhefferon 10y agoI know, right? Sometimes when I am sitting through an econ talk it is very hard not to say, "But your assumption one is wrong."
- DanBC 10y agoCoincidentally, I submitted this interview an hour ago. "An interview with Professor Richard Thaler, godfather of behavioural economics" http://www.spectator.co.uk/2016/06/id-have-said-lets-not-do-this-what-osborne-never-asked-his-nudge-guru/ http://www.spectator.co.uk/2016/06/id-have-said-lets-not-do-... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11927635 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11927635
- icebraining 10y agoWhy is this evidence of economic irrationality? I'm not a fan of tipping as an institution, but as a buyer, lower prices with tipping gives one more flexibility to choose how much to tip.
- lucio 10y agotipping is not rational?
- gilgoomesh 10y agoI think the argument is that the price to the consumer doesn't change yet consumers changed their habits anyway.
- lucio 10y agoBut he price is changed. You're forced to tip a specific amount regardless of quality of service. Most people do not fancy to be forced.
- reidacdc 10y agoMaybe on average the price didn't change, but in the "no-tipping" case, customers can no longer self-select into their various price points. What businesses actually want out of their pricing model is to have a bunch of people pay the maximum amount they'd be willing to pay for a uniform set of products, even though that maximum varies across the customer population. Having a single price for each of your products necessarily constricts your customer base, and it's actually pretty rare -- even your corner drug store publishes coupons in the shoppers' weekly to help bring the cheapskates in the door. Eliminating tipping puts this restaurant into the "single price point" game, forcing them to pick a number that balances not only revenue per customer against customer volume, but also some intangibles -- having a big waiting list catches people's attention and makes your place seem more desirable, for instance, and lets some people pay with time instead of money, broadening your customer base. Plus the marginal efficiency of the kitchen is pretty high if its going full-bore all the time, and it likely makes better use of perishable supplies that are already paid for. My guess is that what they have learned is that there's no single number you can pick that's "the same" as in the tipping scheme. The article talks about "high-energy millenials" who were put off by the high prices. This suggests a price-sensitive group, so probably not especially high tippers, but with some other feature that makes them valuable -- maybe they buy low cost but high-markup items, or maybe they help create an atmosphere that brings in some high rollers, or maybe they marginally increase the volume in the off-peak, allowing the kitchen to make better use of those already-mentioned already-paid-for, perishable ingredients. Tl;dr a cost distribution is not fully characterized by its average, the shape also matters.
- ghayes 10y ago> At Marin, a large bacon and egg breakfast sandwich was $22, and refillable coffee was $7. On Friday it will go down to $18 and $5, respectively. It was not exactly an inexpensive restaurant to begin with.
- walrus01 10y ago> Marin > $22 egg sandwich I can hear the world's smallest violin playing for the wealthy snobs of Marin County.
- ssalazar 10y agoPerhaps, but this article is about a restaurant called Marin in Orange County.
- droithomme 10y agoIt's interesting too because the price with the tip included is 40% higher for coffee and 22% higher for the eggs. I wonder if 22-40% is the normal tipping range for the area. Would the experiment have turned out differently if for example they raised the prices by 15-20% across the board rather than 22-40%?
- Maarten88 10y agoIn EU businesses have to advertise the whole price of everything they sell: including things like tax and service. I am always surprised that in the US, with all its consumer protection laws, businesses get to advertise prices that are misleading. You have to pay the minimum service fee, or you'll get into a loud argument. You have to pay tax too of course, but it's added to the bill separately, which makes it inpractical too: buy a coffee for USD4, and you have to pay an impractical amount like 4.36. I always suspect this is a ploy by businesses to protest these taxes.
- vacri 10y agoIt's part of why I think that Americans complain so much about tax - their sales tax is both very visible and very annoying, due to the weird numbers that prices end up at.
- the_ancient 10y agoOn the Sales tax issue, the business does not have advertise the price including the tax because the business is not being charged the tax which if my understanding it correct differs from how the EU operate. The individual buying the coffee is being charged the tax by the government, the Business is acting as a pseudo government collection agent, forced to do so by law. In most states te business is infact paid a nominal fee to collect this tax on behalf of the government in most location it is very very minor but it is there As to the not including Tip in the price, well that is because you the consumer set how much you tip, there is not possible way to include it. Outside of "large parties" I will not partake in business that charge a mandatory tip. I am likely one of the few people that actually tip based on the service I get, and I have walked away with out leaving a tip.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoUK VAT is also a charge on the buyer, and just collected by the seller on the government's behalf. It is not a tax on the seller. But B2C businesses must advertise prices that include this tax.
- 10y ago
- gumby 10y agoThis is a shame. Tipping is a pernicious practice in the US. But he seemed to have good data.
- Lazare 10y ago> McKenzie surveyed 40 servers working for moderately priced sit-down restaurants. He asked what hourly wage they would need to voluntarily forgo their current minimum wage and all tips. The rate they wanted ranged from $18 to $50 an hour, according to the study Ouch. Living somewhere where tipping is already not the norm, that seems...wildly unrealistic? I wonder what the average was.
- cafard 10y agoOne would need to know what moderately-priced meant. Three of us went to a Thai restaurant in the Washington suburbs last night. Dinner was $75, and we tipped 20%. Suppose each server had six tables (which I think was about right) and that the turnover is 1.5 hours per table, that's four tips per hour. Our bill might have been on the high side (a beer each, and one more entree than we needed); but it would probably be safe to set $20/person as the low side of the bill, and a table average of 2.25 persons--I saw no solo diners, and a number of tables of four persons. So the hourly turnover during busy hours might be upwards of $180. The slow spells later would be less, though maybe compensated some by more alcohol with the meals. Anyway, with an average tip of 15%, that's $27/hour for the busy hours at least. So $18/hour seems fairly realistic. $50/hour suggests a turnover of something more like $350/hour, so maybe a $90/table charge. I guess that Washington counts this a moderately priced. (It could also be that not all of cash tips come to the attention of the IRS; but I don't know how much cash gets put down in that range of restaurant.)
- toomanythings2 10y agoYou're on the right track but it must also be remembered the time of year affects this along with seniority of the waiter (how many hours they get) and their own availability. Waiters can have great days and weeks followed by poor ones but waiters at good restaurants can make decent money on tips. Too many bad stories are from IHOP.
- the_ancient 10y ago>>Americans complain so much about tax American complain soo much about tax because Americans inherently understand that when a person or group involuntary takes money from you that is called theft.
- Maarten88 10y agoI see taxes as a sign of civilization.
- the_ancient 10y agoSo you believe in order for there to be "civilization" there has to be massive institutional wide scale theft under constant threat of violence? You do not think very much of humanity do you?
- sgift 10y ago> You do not think very much of humanity do you? No, I don't. And looking into a history book for five minutes reminds me why. There is a reason that the tax system has been invented and is used basically everywhere (exceptions are failed states): Hoping to get the money needed for duties carried out by the government institutions on behalf of the state by charity does not work.
- the_ancient 10y agoLibertarianism Is So Dangerous: https://youtu.be/NbNFJK1ZpVg https://youtu.be/NbNFJK1ZpVg
- yongjik 10y agoFunny, when someone is ill and cannot afford medicine, I don't see a lot of libertarians saying "Why does this happen? We need a system where people don't die of preventable disease!" I guess your notion of "thinking of humanity" is different from mine.
- droithomme 10y agoAt the "lower prices" of $18 for bacon and eggs and $5 for coffee, you'd think they could pay the servers more than minimum wage, even with tipping.
- toomanythings2 10y agoHigh end restaurants don't get their ingredients from the same place you do or McDonald's does. The quality there is above and beyond.
- lorenzhs 10y agoThe cost of ingredients for coffee are a small fraction of the cost, whether you charge $2 or $5 for it. There is a student-run café at my university, all staff are unpaid volunteers, they serve really good coffee for 50 euro-cents (~55¢ US). The beans are from a high-end local roasting house, and it's in a real cup. Milk (whole/soy) is included. Coffee is cheap.
- dagw 10y agoCoffee is cheap Rent isn't. I bet those students pay a lot less in rent every month (and quite possibly they don't pay anything at all) than what it costs a nice restaurant to rent a centrally located place.
- lorenzhs 10y agoYeah, but the post I replied to was about the cost of ingredients. And McDonald's has some really expensive locations as well.
- toomanythings2 10y agoLet's not cherry pick. I'm talking about menu items overall.
- lorenzhs 10y ago
- lucio 10y ago"And most were actually working even harder because they were working as a team for Arc, not themselves" Give me a break!
- toomanythings2 10y agoYou don't understand. When you wait tables, you are in a little fiefdom of your own that you are responsible for and no one else's. Helping others takes time away from your space and, potentially, your own income. When your income isn't based on helping yourself alone, then you can form a team to help each other when they run into problems. Note that I am not saying waiters never help each other out.
- pmontra 10y agoThey removed a 15% tip, increased pay from 10 to 15 and prices by 20%, replacing a payment you should do with one that you must do. What could go wrong?
- raverbashing 10y agoUnfortunately it's another case of "Culture eats strategy for breakfast" Maybe it could have been handled differently.