5 ms·
I disagree. American society has always had something of a love-hate relationship with intelligence, and there have always been examples like _Big Bang Theory_
by gwern 10y ago
I disagree. American society has always had something of a love-hate relationship with intelligence, and there have always been examples like _Big Bang Theory_ venerating intelligence ('Sputnik moment' and astronauts, anyone?). Intelligence correlates with success cross-culturally and over time, so that's not in question.
What is in question is the 'increasingly'; the only evidence offered, aside from anecdote, is that the returns from education have increased. This is inadequate. The research literature I'm aware of (http://www.gwern.net/Embryo%20selection#iqincome-bibliography http://www.gwern.net/Embryo%20selection#iqincome-bibliograph...) shows that intelligence has consistently been correlated with SES/income/occupation and it's not that clear it has been increasing at all. Particularly relevant is Strenze 2007, "Intelligence and socioeconomic success: A meta-analytic review of longitudinal research" http://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/Intelligence-and-socioeconomic-success-A-meta-analytic-review-of-longitudinal-research.pdf http://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/Intelligence-... who says:
> Several studies have investigated changes in the association between intelligence and success during past decades. Although Herrnstein and Murray concluded that “ the main point seems beyond dispute ” (1994: 52) and some studies have found support for this point ( Murnane, Willett, & Levy, 1995 ), there are still serious reasons to doubt that the importance of intelligence is or has been growing. Neither the meta-analysis by Bowles et al. (2001) nor the review by Jencks et al. (1979) found any clear trend in the correlations between intelligence and success. The same conclusion was reached by Flynn (2004) and Hauser and Huang (1997) . Breen and Goldthorpe (2001) found that the association between intelligence and occupational status in England is, if anything, declining
Strenze's own meta-analytic results using ~44 studies are on pg13 Table 2, where the correlation of intelligence with education/occupation/income over the 20th century show no clear pattern of increase or decrease:
> The influence of the third moderator variable, year of success (i.e., year of the measurement of success), is analyzed in the third section of Table 2 . Year of success ranges from 1929 to 2003 in the present meta-analysis. Judging by the sample size weighted corrected correlations ( p ), there appears to be no historical trend for any one of the moderator variables: correlations with education and occupation remain more or less stable throughout the period under study; correlations with income fluctuate more but without any obvious direction. Quite surprisingly, if unweighted and uncorrected correlations ( r ) are observed instead, then the correlations with education and occupation exhibit a declining trend.
So, if American society 'increasingly mistakes intelligence for human worth' and 'as recently as the 1950s, possessing only middling intelligence was not likely to severely limit your life’s trajectory', why are the more intelligent, if anything, less likely to be successful when we go from 1920 to 2000?
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI'm curious if more recent data would disagree at all with this. I agree the whole 1950s as some sort of turning point (or near to) is likely false based on the meta-analysis you linked but I find the idea that this started taking off in the 21st century to be a plausible hypothesis. Another thing to consider is that though actual correlation with success may not have changed, the cultural attitudes surrounding it may still have. My high school years were in the late 2000s, and although my elementary/middle school years lent credence to the "nerds get beat up by jocks" cultural cliche, my experience (and that of many other nerds) in high school was not anything like what I expected. Not only that, but the nerd/jock divide was blurred to the point of being essentially non-existent. A lot of the people on our championship-winning football team were at the top of our class, and definitely not by virtue of the teachers just passing them because of pressure from on high. This doesn't seem to be such an uncommon experience for my generation. On a more subjective note, I actually find the attitude aspect to be the more detestable one. One can defend intelligence being correlated with success from a lot of at least not totally evil viewpoints: it makes sense to have more intellectually skilled people in jobs requiring more intellectual skill, intelligence requires some level of cultivation so there should be incentives to do so, etc. But while the social carrot has some arguments that start from acceptable terminal values, the social stick does not. I would be very surprised to learn that chastising people for being stupid across the board made them (or anyone else) smarter. The only motivation I can only see for it is purely egotistical.
- onion2k 10y agoThe Big Bang Theory is a show where most of the laughs are derived from the characters being incompetent in some way or another. The basis of the show is "people failing at things outside of their specialist domain." That isn't venerating intelligence.
- vacri 10y agoIt's also just a standard sitcom, one that just happens to have the trappings of higher education in its scenery. Same jokes, same cadences, same formula as so many others. Curiously, I find Raising Hope, a sitcom about a dumb-as-rocks family, to be far more intelligently written.