6 ms·
His description of the iPhone universe: "It’s a sterile Disney-fied walled garden surrounded by sharp-toothed lawyers. The people who create the apps serve at
by ilamont 17y ago
His description of the iPhone universe:
"It’s a sterile Disney-fied walled garden surrounded by sharp-toothed lawyers. The people who create the apps serve at the landlord’s pleasure and fear his anger."
Unfortunately for Android, many or even most consumers prefer a Disney-fied experience. Can Android achieve that without the walled-garden approach?
- davidw 17y agoOne area where Android might easily be very successful is for businesses that need to do custom things, and don't want Apple sticking its nose in their affairs.
- pvg 17y agoThis exists, for large businesses - http://developer.apple.com/programs/iphone/enterprise/ http://developer.apple.com/programs/iphone/enterprise/ In house apps can be distributed without the App Store.
- davidw 17y ago> the iPhone Developer Enterprise Program is available to companies with 500 or more employees and a Dun & Bradstreet number. Android is available to... anyone.
- pvg 17y agoDoesn't change the fact that large businesses have a way to get around having to use the App Store. Small businesses can use 'ad hoc' distribution which lets you distribute to 100 iPhones. Your point was based on the assumption that the App Store is the only way a business can distribute an app to iPhones. This is not the case.
- davidw 17y agoNo, my point was that Android is open, Apple is not. There may be some businesses out there who just don't want to go through all that bureaucracy and hoop jumping to do something new and interesting. Android gives them that possibility, Apple does not.
- pvg 17y agoNo, it wasn't. Your point was if you are business, Android might have an advantage because Apple 'sticks its nose in [your] affairs'. Yes Android is more open. Yes putting apps on your iPhone without the App Store is more of a hassle. But it is possible and relatively straightforward. And it's not what you said. Which is fine, lots of people don't know about Apple's alternative distribution programs. It's better to be wrong than to be a weasel, though.
- davidw 17y agoDude, you can go call someone else a weasel. My point is this, again: Android is open, and that lets business do things even without signing up for some Apple-supervised Dun and Bradstreet-number-requiring enterprise program. I never said nor implied that you can't, somehow, do stuff with the iPhone, just that it's a more invasive procedure, and a lot of businesses might not care for that. Also, there is a ton of stuff that you can do with Android because it is open from top to bottom that you will simply never be able to do with an iPhone. That is going to be a win for some, and possibly many businesses.
- pvg 17y agoDude, you can go call someone else a weasel. Oh I do! Right now I'm calling you a weasel. For weaseling. My point is this, again: That's your weasel-point. It's not the point you brought up. Both small and large businesses can easily put their apps on the iPhone without the App Store.
- almost 17y agoPlease try and be more civil in your posts here. Thanks!
- yummyfajitas 17y agoIf your business has 499 or fewer people, you are stuck with Android. Incidentally, I know of at least one small business (4 people) which would like a mobile app for their employees. They are stuck with apple on the desktop, android on the phones.
- imajes 17y agoYou really don't need the apple store to distribute apps. with a small handful of people, it's easy to get their uids and build the app for them.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI don't know the full details of the decision, since I don't work for that company. As I understand it control was a major issue. The app was designed to monitor and control a hedge fund (i.e., automated alerts and kill switches while you are at lunch). Hoping and praying that Apple won't break things was simply not an option. Lack of multitasking on the iphone was also a problem.
- mseebach 17y agoAt the moment, yes. But the Android experience is rapidly improving, and all it takes is one single killer app that's not possible on the iPhone because of the walled garden approach. One such killer-app could be the competition on the handsets. I have an HTC Tattoo - it's a low-end device, compared to Nexus One and HTC Hero, and it feels cheap, but it packs the entire smart-phone experience. And it's less than $200 (subsidised on the plan I'm getting anyway) and falling.
- btipling 17y agoProbably a porn app.
- jokermatt999 17y agoWasn't that supposed to be Google Voice?
- glhaynes 17y agoIndeed. It's hard for me to imagine the "killer app" that can't be done on a platform that has a completely open web browser and a locked-down app store. Google Voice seems as close to one as I can think of and note the following things about it: a) not THAT many people cared. You may think they did if you are a geek/work with geeks, as I am/do, but your perception in that case is way off b) Apple's restrictions were circumvented via a web app c) if such an app became important to have to enough people that it caused concern to Apple, they can easily change their policy at any time to allow it. I mean, there are a couple of things I'd really like to do on my iPhone OS devices (ScummVM on iPad would be awesome... yeah, I know I could theoretically jailbreak) but these are really minor annoyances compared to what I get out of the platform. It's just a pragmatic choice for me, not a holy war. And I can quit anytime. Really -- my cost of switching away from iPhone is the cost of replacing like 5 or 6 $2.99 apps. Jiggly boobs apps may be popular (within a fairly narrow niche), but hardly anybody is going to switch devices over that. It's something people download on a whim and play with for a couple of minutes then never open again. Welcome to the $0.99 software market. It's not good or bad, it just is. I guess what I'm saying is just this: all the cries of "software freedom!!" as though it were a revolutionary political struggle ring hollow to me. This isn't Stalinist Russia that people are being saved from if they're convinced into buying an Android device instead of an iPhone OS device. There's literally ZERO chance that Apple is going to completely own the smartphone and tablet computing worlds. The great concern with Windows throughout the nineties was that their lone real competitor was going to go out of business and they'd essentially be all that's left and all devices would only be able to connect to them and, with the advent of the internet, they'd entirely control the publishing platform of the 21st century. None of that applies at all to this circumstance. We've won: the web is open. Now it's down to games and jiggly boobs. So all the non-browser apps will always have plenty of places to be built. Innovation isn't going to ground to a halt. You're just as free to buy a non-Apple device as you ever were and you'll still be able to get to all of the same web services as you do on an Apple device. All your documents and file formats are still open no matter which route you go. All the options are good. So if this topic matters a lot to you, buy non-Apple. But all this talk about them being "evil" seems ... startlingly lacking in perspective.
- Tichy 17y ago"Unfortunately for Android, many or even most consumers prefer a Disney-fied experience." Even so, there is still the other consumers. I simply can't help the Disney-fied consumers. Consumers also like to eat candy all day and watch TV, but I don't want to feed them candy and TV because I know it is not healthy. Should be possible to find some business model that I can also agree with.
- dejb 17y agoHistory shows that walled-garden approaches are severely limited in their scope. They don't scale. If you read the article it says > As of now, they’re selling around 90K iPhones per day compared to around 60K Android handsets. It’s a horse race! If those figures are accurate then it's not a horse race. The iPhone is dead. Do the math on growth rates. The iPhone is dead as the dominant platform and will soon occupy the small niche that its closed nature consigns it to.
- barrkel 17y agoThat was the visceral feeling I got about a day after I received my Nexus One. It's Mac vs Windows all over again.
- davidw 17y agoExcept that Android is way more open than Windows ever was, which makes it that much cooler. Also, regarding the someone hyperbolic grandparent post, iPhone will always have its place, just like Macs have survived nearly 30 years despite being the more tightly controlled platform. Likely (and hopefully), that niche will let them continue to do interesting, beautiful things, without ever coming close to dominating the market, which is a very scary prospect for fans of 'open'. Also, in terms of the "dominant" platform, outside of the slightly-behind-the-mobile-times Silicon Valley, which seems to have only started noticing mobile phones with the iPhone, the dominant platform, by a long shot, is Java ME.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pvg 17y agoI'm somewhat surprised he's chosen to take such a dump on his own credibility. I'm sure he has genuine misgivings about the way Apple's App Store process works. But this level of breathless hyperbole in the same post as an announcement that he now works for an iPhone competitor is like titling your blog entry "I am now a shill". Just a year ago he wrote "The iPhone has proved that a mobile device can really truly be a first-class citizen of the Net."
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoHe's been saying the same thing for at least 7 years: Are You a Sharecropper? · If you’re developing software for the Windows platform, yes. Or for the Apple platform, or the Oracle platform, or the SAP platform, or, well, any platform that is owned and operated by a company. They own the ground you’re building on, and if they decide they don’t like you, or they can do something better with the ground, you’re toast. They can ship their own product and give it away till you go bust, then start charging for it; and use secret APIs you can’t see; and they can break the published APIs you use. All of these things have historically been done by platform vendors. http://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/200x/2003/07/12/WebsThePlace http://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/200x/2003/07/12/WebsThePla...
- ynniv 17y agoFor the love of pete, the iPhone "Internet experience" has no parallels to any Disney product. Apple has basic restrictions on the types of native apps that can run on it, and they are far more permissive than "child friendly". Additionally, there is no restriction on Web browsing at all... This marks yet another article I stopped reading because the author said something clearly emotional and not rational.