4 ms·
> Instead, Libya's arguments take the form of: We didn't really mean what those contracts said. We didn't understand them. [...] > What JPMorgan did was expli
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> Instead, Libya's arguments take the form of: We didn't really mean what those contracts said. We didn't understand them.
[...]
> What JPMorgan did was explicitly allowed by the rules, but that doesn't mean that it was allowed.
This seems like both the biggest feature and the biggest bug of our legal system. On the one hand, the court system exists to adjudicate cases that aren't clear-cut, and often establish precedent in the process. On the other hand, that makes it extremely difficult to construct a system where all the rules are clear cut and have "let the buyer beware" all over them, and not have someone "cheat" and ask the court system to reverse a result that didn't go in their favor. Heads I win, tails the court system might say I win anyway.
If you want a contract where the "spirit of the law" prevails, write it that way. For example, the electricity regulations mentioned in the article could have been written to say "if you find way to arbitrage this and produce infinite money, you're wrong; this is governed by the spirit of the law as interpreted by $governing_body".
But there should be a way to write a "letter of the law" agreement, too, where people can actually rely on the rules. There should exist a sufficiently strong disclaimer that anyone agreeing to it will get summarily rejected from a court saying "you should have known better". There should exist agreements where someone giving their word is ironclad and irreversible.
You can build systems that incorporate human judgment and reversibility on top of such an ironclad rule-based system. But the reverse isn't true: you can't build an ironclad system on top of a system where anyone can cheat by saying "no fair, I lost my money and I didn't really mean it" to a court.
Sometimes, people find it comforting to have a "soft" system backing them up that will look at the human factors involved; for some systems, I do too. But in some cases, you want the comfort of knowing that you can rely on the rules as stated and not someone saying "actually, now that I've lost money I don't like the rules anymore, give me my money back".
- mikeash 10y agoWhat would be the use case for "letter of the law" agreements, and how do you avoid massive problems due to buggy contracts as we're seeing?
- danharaj 10y agoThe ability to dismiss any grievances with "tough luck" for one. A mechanistic system that engulfs and defines human activity rather than being defined by it, another: it is immune to politics. Just guesses from me; i don't think blockchain tech addresses any aspects of society that i personally find problematic.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoYou don't. There are two conflicting and irreconcilable centres of gravity in law - justice/fairness, and the exploitation of power asymmetries for profit. Which is why it's literally not possible to reduce a contract to code, and it never will be. Even if you could produce perfect bug-free code at reasonable cost - a fantasy in itself - you still have to contend with the irreconcilable motivations of the parties to the contract, and the fact that contracts are used to hide motivations as often as they are to reveal them. It's perfectly possible - common, even - that the motivations are conflicting, irreconcilable, and ambiguous, to the extent that the true practical meaning of a contract can only be defined by an external higher legal and political authority. Or by one party rolling over. Because making that more likely is what many lawyers get paid for. (And what some of them live for.)
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> There are two conflicting and irreconcilable centres of gravity in law - justice/fairness, and the exploitation of power asymmetries for profit. I don't think that's a reasonable dichotomy. "Letter of the law" isn't exclusively useful for people looking to exploit power asymmetries or create unfairness. It's also useful for smaller entities to protect themselves from threats that larger ones have enough insulation to just weather and survive.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> What would be the use case for "letter of the law" agreements Consider a service where you take money from a user, and then use that money to run a service on their behalf, in a fully automated fashion. You get $x, you spend $y on a server and bandwidth, and you pocket x-y as profit. But if the user pays for your service on a credit card, they could dispute the $x, and leave you on the hook for $y, which could be arbitrarily large; you can immediately cancel their service, but that doesn't get you the $y you've already spent back. It'd be nice to have an enforceable agreement that "you can cancel at any time and stop paying us, at which point the service goes away, but under no circumstances will we owe you anything". (This is also one reason why companies often don't offer discounts for paying up-front for a year or more, and credit card processors consider those high-risk: too many people dispute the transaction after a short time and get all their money back, including what they've already paid.) I can imagine many more scenarios that rely on "once you have the money it can't go away", that don't work nearly as well with reversible transactions. > how do you avoid massive problems due to buggy contracts as we're seeing? In cases where you want human judgment as a safety precaution, write it in at the top level of the contract. "Notwithstanding anything else, all transactions are reversible for up to X days based on the judgment of Y, to be supplied via Z mechanism; if such judgment is not supplied, the transaction becomes immutable after those X days have passed." (Or, if you want, "all transactions can be disputed for up to X days, which will then hold them for judgment by Y for up to Z days".) The equivalent of "don't run untrusted software in ring 0"; the "pure letter of the law" space is ring 0, and many things could be built on one or more layers of indirection above that. In cases where you don't want human judgment, then you avoid buggy contacts the same way you avoid buggy software: get a lot of people looking at it, and limit how much you trust things that haven't been heavily hammered on for years. Anyone investing millions into a "smart contract" today is taking an absurd risk. You could also purchase insurance of some kind. If the price of that insurance is absurd, that should tell you something. But not every transaction should have to price in built-in insurance (and actuaries to properly price it).
- bunderbunder 10y agoOne of the things that many legal systems try to enshrine is a principle of fairness. One part of that is acknowledging that many contracts are entered into in a state of information or power asymmetry, which makes it easy for certain parties to create unfair contracts that the counterparty doesn't recognize as unfair or doesn't realize they can argue against. This is really a good thing. The most tangible example I can come up with is employment law in California: One big thing that distinguishes the labor market in California from other regions is that non-compete clauses are basically unenforceable. Non-compete clauses being a big drag on innovation (since they basically imply that if you have a good idea that is related to your current line of work, and your current employer doesn't see the value, then you're SOL and not allowed to have a go of it), there's a very strong argument to be made that Silicon Valley couldn't have happened in any other jurisdiction.
- dogecoinbase 10y agoBut there should be a way to write a "letter of the law" agreement, too, where people can actually rely on the rules. There should exist a sufficiently strong disclaimer that anyone agreeing to it will get summarily rejected from a court saying "you should have known better". There should exist agreements where someone giving their word is ironclad and irreversible. These would be great to make people sign at gunpoint!