11 ms·
Why Young Americans Are Giving Up on Capitalism
- dalke 10y agoI liked the turn of phrase "Capitalism, in other words, holds less appeal in an era when the invisible hand feels like a death grip." The article is very clear that the term capitalism wasn't defined in the survey, so "What do these category-based questions really tell us, then, about the allegiance of youth to ideologies? Nothing." Instead, it says to look to the policy question to get a sense of what young Americans think. My interpretation - young Americans reject neoliberalism. But as the article comments: > “Neoliberal” has gone from a term that describes an advocate of specific economic and political policies to an insult hurled indiscriminately on social media. Err, blush. The end is also nicely put: > You do not need a survey to ascertain the plight of American youth. You can look at their bank accounts, at the jobs they have, at the jobs their parents have lost, at the debt they hold, at the opportunities they covet but are denied. You do not need jargon or ideology to form a case against the status quo. The clearest indictment of the status quo is the status quo itself.
- kinai 10y agoMaybe because except for the 1% most of the population feels the negative effects of it? Doesn't take a genius to see how broken the system is
- partiallypro 10y agoThey do? Global poverty is at an all time low. Things only the 1% had 10 years ago are now in the hands of almost every single individual, information no one had access to 30 years ago is now available to everyone in milliseconds. I'd say capitalism is doing just fine. The problem is that capitalism has been so successful that everyone feels entitled to its gains instantaneously. Because of global trade wealth can easily become concentrated because market expansion pushes up capital availability and equity of people who have it. Most people in the top echelon of wealth hold it in stocks. That's why when we have a crisis (like 2008) the wealth gap collapses.
- ridgeguy 10y agoOn your last point: from a historical chart [1] of U.S. net household wealth (in a 2014 Economist article), it seems the wealth gap didn't collapse or even moderate its increase in 2008. Indeed, it's reached the same territory which, in 1917, inspired the passage of progressive income and estate taxes in the U.S. [1] http://cdn.static-economist.com/sites/default/files/inequality1108a_1.png?1415284532 http://cdn.static-economist.com/sites/default/files/inequali...
- partiallypro 10y agoThat chart is misleading, because it's measuring the top .01%, and the caption gives me the interpretation that it has an agenda. Here's a more leveled look: http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2009/09/15/wealth-inequality-shrinks-during-financial-crisis-study-says/ http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2009/09/15/wealth-inequality-shr... There's no doubt it re-accelerated after the crisis, but a lot of that has to do with credit conditions and tight money for the poor, and loose money for the rich.
- ridgeguy 10y agoThank you for the link. I think the numbers quoted don't indicate a collapse in the wealth gap around 2008. The WSJ article includes this observation: "The world is still staggeringly unequal, with the tiny sliver of those with $5 million or more in assets (we don’t have the exact number but it’s clearly a select club) owning more than the total population of those with $100,000 or less." Perhaps there was a small inflection in the evolving wealth gap curve around 2008, but it seems minor and transitory. The article's numbers seem consistent with that.
- VLM 10y ago>Global poverty Most of the world isn't capitalist, or at least not traditional western capitalism. Including the west currently, which is in an orgy of corruption and distortion and central control and unfree markets. Your explanation of how things that used to be valuable are now valueless is exactly the problem from the article. If technological trinkets that are highly entertaining but inherently fundamentally worthless are our generations Faberge Eggs, or clickbait journalism on the internet or music on the internet or pr0n on the internet or social signalling spirals on the internet, that's "great" that its worthless so everyone can have it even if they have no money. On the other hand, when its labor or skill or craft or art, that's kind of a problem for everyone who has nothing else to sell, when that's basically the entire population. There is also a forest for the trees argument. A state that fails most of its population is a failed state. Doesn't matter if one tree is in the best shape in history, or really that one tree doesn't matter at all, if the rest of the forest is dead. Failed states are ripe for revolution and that really great tree is going to get chopped in the guillotine no matter how great its achievement. A state that fails to serve its population will eventually get replaced, peacefully or otherwise.
- wfoweoi 10y agoCulturally we seem to take the benefits of capitalism completely for granted. Nobody exclaims "capitalism is fucking amazing" when their favorite tv show is renewed for another season, or when a new awesome tv show is created. If people made the connection that capitalism is the thing that's creating all these things in your life that you love.. that those things don't materialize magically as a result of people just doing their thing... that would change the perception of capitalism dramatically.
- mikerichards 10y agoMaybe because except for the 1% most of the population feels the negative effects of it? A Bernie Sanders meme isn't reality. Vastly more than 1% are doing fine.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ChuckFrank 10y agoCapitalism see labor as a cost, and though outsourcing, overseaing, and automation attempts to drive that cost to as close to zero as possible. The fundamental problem is that people derive great benefit and satisfaction from their labor, their participation in production, and the knowledge of a job well done. Capitalism, over a long time, will always deny people that satisfaction. Young people can feel that truth in their everyday. It's Capitalism's fundamental, and intrinsic flaw. Work matters, and it is not a cost, it is a benefit.
- afarrell 10y ago> it is not a cost, it is a benefit This has a pretty strong diminishing returns effect.
- ChuckFrank 10y agoHow so? I don't see any diminishing returns. Pay a living wage for good work, forever.
- afarrell 10y agoPeople derive satisfaction from their labor, but they also derive fatigue, frustration, and dismay from it. There is a reason why people generally demand a for doing non-hobby projects. This means it is, on balance, a cost.
- wfoweoi 10y agoWhat's the best alternative to capitalism in your mind? Capitalism is pretty good at making sure people are doing something actually useful to others, that's where a lot of the satisfaction of work lies in the first place. Not all work is equally satisfying as well. Most kinds of work would make me miserable. Capitalism is great because you have a lot of wiggle room - you choose within the intersection of your abilities and what the world wants. If your preferred work is something useless to society like digging random holes or whatever, you may be able to do that in a capitalist system as well if we implement some sort of basic income.
- thescribe 10y agoMy first knee jerk argument was 'no true scotsman' capitalist edition, but that got me thinking. Capitalism is basically markets on a large scale, and some form of market will exist as long as a single person has opportunity costs and performs some sort of optimization. Markets will always be with us in some form. How could we even go about opting out? Being dissatisfied with capitalism as a concept seems like being dissatisfied with gravity.
- SwellJoe 10y agoThere are anti-capitalists who support markets, and it is not ridiculous to do so. Capital is a concept independent of trade, though the two tend to rub up against one another a lot in the Western world. So, it's not necessary to oppose all trade in order to oppose the notion that one person can own everything people need in order to survive and rent it to everyone else.
- thescribe 10y agoThat's absolutely fair. I was thinking of opposition to capitalism in pretty stark terms before you brought this up. The kind of Stalinist everything is centrally planned kind of totality.
- dwiel 10y agoThat's like saying that hierarchy will always be around so being dissatisfied with it as a concept is like being dissatisfied with gravity (in feudal times). There are matters of degree. Genuinely curious: feudalism is to hierarchy as ? is to capitalism. I think maybe some people think feudalism : hierarchy :: capitalism : markets.
- thescribe 10y agoI hadn't considered it that way, so thank you for a second point of view. I had been thinking of capitalism as the 'natural state' or lack of power being applied. My best shot: Feudalism is to hierarchy as usury is to capitalism.
- bunkydoo 10y agoI think people should be given a stark choice - either eat government provisioned rations, take public transport, and live in public housing (socialism) or contribute to a fluctuating capitalist economy and roll the dice a bit. Then likely make a bit more money on average, although less predictable (capitalism)
- striking 10y agoDon't some of those things already exist?
- VLM 10y agoSo, immigration should be open to everyone, not just preferentially for non-white people?
- rpgmaker 10y agoThe thing is that capitalism[1] can work reasonably well for almost everyone if capitalists weren't so shortsighted (and petty). Many Nordic countries get this right and their populations are the better for it.
- kalleboo 10y ago> Then likely make a bit more money on average, although less predictable (capitalism) And sometimes die because they can't afford health care
- marcoperaza 10y agoAs Schumpeter argued, capitalism enables its own enemies. Under socialism, the critics would be too busy trying to get the next meal to theorize critiques of capitalism. Despite our serious problems, we've never had it so good as in the last half century. We certainly would be worse off under any other economic system. Unfortunately, this is a generation that gets most of their civic awareness from Hollywood, social media, and a homogenously leftist intelligentsia. Throw in a crisis and some stagnation, and is it really any wonder that young people hold such preposterous views?
- devishard 10y ago> Under socialism, the critics would be too busy trying to get the next meal to theorize critiques of capitalism. Under capitalism in America there are plenty of people too busy trying to get the next meal than to do anything else. People in socialist Scandinavia are generally doing better.
- hodwik2 10y ago>" there are plenty of people too busy trying to get the next meal than to do anything else." Incredible that they have on average 6 hours per day to watch television, given how busy you say they are.
- devishard 10y agoWhat is incredible is that you can't conceive of how an average of six hours of TV watching might allow for many people to watch zero hours of television. But since you brought it up, maybe you should look into what kind of people watch >6 hours of television per day.
- hodwik 10y agoPoor people, which was exactly my point. http://www.marketplace.org/2013/11/04/wealth-poverty/income-upshot/behind-data-tv-viewing-and-income http://www.marketplace.org/2013/11/04/wealth-poverty/income-...
- runT1ME 10y agoSure, you can blame it on capitalism if you want, but pay close attention to a recurring theme in this article such as " The minimum wage, which peaked in 1968, would have reached $21.72 in 2012 had it kept pace with inflation." Along with "Prestigious jobs are increasingly clustered in cities where rent has tripled or quadrupled" This is not a mystery. QE and inflation is a direct wealth transfer from the poor to the rich. It's basic math and I'll repeat myself once again. When the upper middle class and rich can leverage themselves into assets that grow proportionally to inflation, they get richer and poor people get poorer. This is in addition to the fact that inflation is often a lopsided event from the top down (Fed lends to banks, which then lend to consumers etc.)
- ytim 10y agoCan you elaborate on how QE and inflation is a direct wealth transfer from poor to rich? Do you mean that QE funds upper class purchase of assets with cheap debt versus inflation's havoc on lower income savings/purchasing power? And isn't QE ultimately beneficial to the poor, in that it's funding labor that would otherwise go unused during a recession (for example)?
- skissane 10y agoThe phrase "direct wealth transfer" might be too strong, but it's clear that in many cases inflation has a disproproportionate impact on low income people than on high income people. Higher income earners are more likely to obtain regular pay-rises than lower income earners, so inflation has less of a negative impact on their pay. Lower income people tend to spend the vast majority of their income on meeting their basic needs, so any decline in real income has an immediate negative impact on their standard of living. Higher income people tend to allocate much more of their income to saving or investment, so a reduction in their real income has a much smaller impact on their standard of living. If an economic change makes the poor poorer, while the rich stay where they are (or even get richer), is it wrong to call that a "wealth transfer"?
- kaonashi 10y agoQE removes government bonds from circulation, replacing them with reserves which pay less interest. This forces those seeking a return on idle cash to seek alternate mattresses, of which real estate is a handy one. This leads to more real estate transactions, and thus higher prices.
- Shivetya 10y agothey should instead be giving up on big government which is undermining capitalism. it is big government that is holding them back through over regulation, over taxation, and playing political favorites. the same big government which has dumped hundreds of billions into education ever since the DOE was created with no improvement, the same big government which has expended trillions in its war on poverty with no improvement. it might be nice to have capitalism again
- Mendenhall 10y agoI think you could get rid of capitalism and the same problems will occure just in a different format. Human nature .
- ben_jones 10y agoBullshit. Americans are doubling down on Capitalism. They're taking out way more debt in order to take a chance at "making it big" a.k.a. a middle class job and a home.
- ChuckFrank 10y agoThat's not doubling down on Capitalism. That's doubling down on a jackpot economy. The two things are very different.
- kristopolous 10y agoThe most interesting thing for me is seeing how the "public comments" section such as this one has started to shift. I remember back when nearly everyone defended the system and people were shot down for suggesting that perhaps those who have power and influence try to influence and exercise power. (For instance, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1182518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1182518, 6 years ago) I think people still deny that this change has happened which make me think it's just a temporary thing.
- calimac 10y agothe fact that we are living in a racist capitalistic nation does not make your Communist crap acceptable. Any and every communist experiment ever endeavored ends in failure and starvation. .. Usually at the hand of an oppressive tyrant. Take your screwed up world view and start your own communist utopia on an island far away from here. America is not a communist country. Progress your way out of this country.
- kristopolous 10y agoThat's the spirit! Glad there's a few of you left! :-) Your hostility is perfect! For the record, I advocate for criticism of all systems and an intellectual honesty and integrity combined with a willingness to learn, listen, and an openness to being wrong about, well, everything.
- lossolo 10y agoFirst they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.
- calimac 10y agoObama is shit. His policies are what have killed the low end entry level worker. It's honestly ironic. Bush piled on the debt and tanked the economy then obama takes it to the next level. I don't have time to argue specifics you can read on your own. I am concerned that youth will not have the compass of true north that the older generations have. Most of Silicon Valley is full of topic skewed world views with a dusting of white guilt on top. God help us all Language is being shifted in a single generation.
- Implicated 10y agoI'm not picking sides here, but I generally stop reading someone's opinion on political matters when they start with blame for the president who presided during the time they believe the problems started. Really, Obama himself is solely responsible for this? Not the party, or both parties, but specifically Barak Obama? That's a tough sell for me.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoWell it couldn't possibly be all of the fabulously obstructionist Repubs in Congress that made it their primary mission to oppose the president on everything and refuse to compromise at all.
- kristopolous 10y agoYour ideas would be taken more seriously if you expressed them more thoughtfully.
- curiousgeorgio 10y agoAsking people who are not thriving in a capitalistic economy (as numerous as they may be) what they think about capitalism is like asking the weakest sheep what they think about survival of the fittest. Of course they're going to associate the idea with hardship and injustice. No surprise there. But I feel it, and I feel for everyone affected by it (and I'm not implying that those people are necessarily weak, by the way). Unfortunately, there will always exist some degree of disparity in resources and prosperity in society (at least, any "free" society), and a "fair" system is just one that provides opportunities for everyone; it doesn't give to those who aren't deserving (and of course, the definition of "deserving" is very much up for debate). But if those who do contribute more to society aren't rewarded any more than those who don't, then fairness ceases to exist. What many people (especially the younger generation) fail to recognize is that capitalism is both the problem and the solution here. The real problem is, our current form of capitalism functions nothing like true "free market" capitalism. In a free market, education would be cheaper (you think the government subsidies, grants, scholarships, etc are doing anything but raise the price of tuition?). Every industry and business would have to prove their value to the masses (rather than certain players getting preferential treatment from government subsidies); otherwise our dollars would be voted elsewhere. As long as the government could ensure a level of transparency, we'd all get what we pay for, and of course, charities would still be able to do tremendous good in giving aid to the less fortunate (those who may be down on their luck, but not deadbeats). I truly believe that America's economic situation would be improved by those two things: increased transparency, and more freedom in the market. When I hear someone blaming capitalism for their economic hardships, I like to imagine that person years in the future, now successful, having earned their way to a decent living. I imagine telling that person "ok, congratulations, but you didn't believe in capitalism, so give me all your wealth - I promise I'll look after it". And at that point, I can't imagine any response other than a resounding string of 4-letter words telling me to get lost.
- 323454 10y agoI think you're deluding yourself, and your arguments have the same tone as defenders of communism when they say "oh of course communism didn't work in the USSR, but that's because they werent doing it properly!" Capitalism in 2016 is a hell of a lot less broken than capitalism in 1916 or 1816 when many markets were much less regulated. The answer is not "freer markets", but I agree with you that it's also not just more regulation. Instead, we need to be able to do more with less regulation, to have more efficient rules that make the economic game better fulfill its purpose of providing for everyone's needs and encouraging useful behaviours.
- VladKovac 10y agoThis isn't some local trend in history, everyone is born with anti-market bias. We come from small bands of hunter-gatherers with fairness and egalitarianism built in through reciprocal altruism. The problem is a lot of market policies seem unfair when you look at them at a glance. That's why older people become more fiscally conservative (including older liberals) because you start to understand the underlying mechanisms and the empirical support of market strategies. Read Bryan Caplan's "The Myth of the Rational Voter" if you want a more thorough discussion of this.
- apsec112 10y ago"Policies like a $15 per hour minimum wage — brought to mainstream attention not by Sanders, but by striking fast food workers years before — are not radical, but a pragmatic corrective to decades of wage depreciation. The minimum wage, which peaked in 1968, would have reached $21.72 in 2012 had it kept pace with inflation." This is very, very false. Adjusted for inflation, the minimum wage in the US peaked at $10-11 in the late 1960s (http://money.cnn.com/interactive/economy/minimum-wage-since-1938/ http://money.cnn.com/interactive/economy/minimum-wage-since-...). Adjusted for PPP, the country with the highest minimum wage is Australia, at $11 per hour (excluding tiny Luxembourg and San Marino; data at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_count...). No one has anything remotely like a $22 minimum wage. The median hourly wage in the US is below $22, ie. more than half of all jobs pay less than that.
- ridgeguy 10y agoI take the last quoted sentence to mean that the minimum wage "...would have reached $21.72...", not that it did reach that. Clearly, it didn't. The author was illustrating the overall decline in purchasing power of the inflation-adjusted minimum wage, despite its nominal increase. Hence the economic decline experienced by minimum wage workers.
- X86BSD 10y agoA lot of this is also simply put an issue of fraudulent paper money as well. Most gas here is $2.21 per gallon. As of today. Here's the rub... Take a pre 1965 quarter. When it was still made with silver. If you take that quarter and melt it down. That .25 has enough silver to buy a gallon gas in today's silver price. $2.25 of fake inflated printed out of thin air "money" or a quarter made of silver. If the currency today was still constitutionally backed by gold and silver you could actually live acceptably working at McDonald's. So I say a good chunk of this is the currency.
- WalterBright 10y agoConsider the software business. It's probably the most free market industry in existence, with a near total lack of government regulation, standards, interference, subsidies, price fixing, licensing, and oversight (with the exception of the disastrous patent system). And look at the results: an ongoing, decades long explosion of new products, innovation, millions earning a great living, costs of software relentlessly driven to literally zero, revolutionary new technology every couple of years - does anyone think that could be made better with socialism? On the other hand, the industries with the most government intervention seem to be doing the worst - finance, health care, higher education.
- lossolo 10y agoSo you are saying that deregulating finance that gave us 2008 crisis was a good thing ? I think there are industries that need to be strictly regulated because they don't work for the good of the whole market if they are deregulated. One of them is finance.
- cderwin 10y ago2008 didn't happen because of a lack of regulation, it happened because of absolutely awful regulation. You don't need more regulation, you need smarter regulation. It is absolutely absurd that the federal government subsidized loans to (insolvent) poor people that they can't pay back -- resulting in subprime the mortgages that caused the crisis. Now, in no way am I saying banks had no hand in it; that's just untrue. But it certainly was not the one-sided affair leftist revisionists wish it were.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoLast time I read up on this, I was led to believe that the regulations were only a minor factor, and the main thing driving the subprime explosion was demand in the investment market for misleadingly-rated mortgage-backed securities. My understanding of the details is almost nonexistent, but I gather that there was some kind of statistical wizardry that let lenders load up a bunch of crappy mortgages into a package that was, in aggregate, supposedly an extremely safe investment with a very attractive return. These securities became the primary product, with the mortgages themselves being the raw material. The market demanded that production increase, so the lenders did the finance equivalent of drilling for tar sands oil. At this point there was no need for the government to mandate subprime mortgages. Lenders weren't just grudgingly implementing policy, they were enthusiastic, shouting from the rooftops for people to apply for mortgages even if they thought they wouldn't qualify. I clearly remember Countrywide's motto: "No one can do what Countrywide can". I guess it turned out that Countrywide couldn't do it either.
- hodwik2 10y agoIt's really heartbreaking. As a person who was raised very leftist, and only became a conservative (to the consternation of all friends and family) in my 20's, I really don't know how to talk someone out of the left's bubble. I count it a miracle that I found my way out of leftism. Their politics are so lush and their imagery vivid. Ours, on the right, are dull, utilitarian, and based on comparatively dry topics like economics and social psychology. It's no wonder politics is swinging left, but it is profoundly frightening. Young Americans, just 5-10 years younger than myself, have reached a new extreme. I believe the US is about to take a hard dive to the left, and I don't want my kids to grow up impoverished by it. I've been looking for a country, to move to, which is more dedicated to classical liberal/capitalist ideals, and who's young people know and understand the value of hardwork, sobriety and dedication. Somewhere in Asia, perhaps?
- andrewclunn 10y agoSurprisingly, Russia may be a good bet.
- lossolo 10y agoSwitzerland. They just said no to basic pay and say no to increase hourly wage through national referendum.
- angersock 10y agoWhat does the left/right split have to do with anything? The rent is too damned high, the wages are too damned low, and none of us stand a statistically-significant chance of getting a return on the value we would bring to a company in this economy (mostly because that's not how equity is split, anymore).
- heurist 10y agoAfter 40 years swinging hard to the right I imagine it will take some time before brash liberalism makes a dent in living standards.
- kristopolous 10y agoI'm curious as to how you characterize "left" and "right" ... what collection of positions do you attribute to each side?
- eanzenberg 10y agoMy 2 cents: Young americans are giving up on capitalism because they are some of the most impatient people I've ever met. They expect their careers to go from 0 to 60 in no time without putting in hard work, effort, time and experience to get the "dream career" they want. They don't see that great things in life require dedication. Yes, hello Sander's supporters :)
- angersock 10y agoAre you talking about the hard work of people like Bernie Madoff? Or perhaps Elizabeth Holmes? Or shit, maybe Mark Pincus? Or maybe we just expect to get paid an honest day's wages for an honest day's work--you know, 8 hours, M-F, 9-5. Maybe we expect to get some actual equity in our companies. Maybe we recognize "experience" as mostly just the same self-serving sonofabitch getting away with taking credit for the accomplishments of those under them. Dedication? To the companies of today? Don't make me laugh.
- eanzenberg 10y agoNot dedication to companies, but dedication to their craft and skills. Many of these young kids expect to become masters of their craft in short time and aren't willing to start at the bottom and work their way up.
- raarts 10y agoI am 55 years old. When I was twenty, I was looking at an entirely different situation than the current generation. Right now the future for them is a lot more grim looking as my future looked in the eighties. TL;DR: you are wrong here.
- patrickg_zill 10y agoWhat we have is no longer free-market capitalism, but "gangster" or "crony" capitalism. The only bright spot in the US economy is the one part that hasn't been taken over via regulatory capture, rent-seeking etc. - the Internet and related technologies. (Although Comcast, Level3, ATT and the incumbent telecoms are trying to change that). This quote is very apt, though over 150 years old: *"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it. "
- angersock 10y agoI can't speak for my whole generation, but I used to be nearly ancap in highschool. We were coming of age a few years after the first dot-com crash, and it looked like a temporary market correction. The War On Terror still didn't sound like a joke, technology and the Web were still exciting and changing and hadn't gone completely walled-garden yet. The game plan was simple, especially with Boomer parents: do well in highschool, do well in college, and then either get a good job (Boomer suggested) or start your own thing (Boomer accepted). 2008 hit, money gets tight for everyone, stock market tanks, and all of us watch as the bankers get bailed out--the ones with enough friends, anyways. My first company's accounts got acquired when Chase ate Washington Mutual and then charged us service fees until they'd drained our meager J2ME game profits. It was abundantly clear that "capitalism", as being practiced in the United States, was not a free market. 2011, a bit over three years later, Occupy Wall Street happened. A lot of protests happened. I saw protests in Houston--after work, of course!--and would later learn that threatened sniper actions against the protestors were ignored by the police. In Oakland, police shot an Iraw veteran in the head with anti-riot gear, landed him in critical condition in the hospital, and nobody gave a shit. In New York, in Zuccotti, the protests were more a spectacle for the bankers and finance folks than a serious way of changing the system, mostly because of the frivolous hippy shit that took it over. In all cases, they were made fun of by the media until they dissolved from internal disorganization and distraction. The "We are the 99%" site was brilliant marketing and had such a clear message of desperation that it probably could've galvanized the entire Occupy movement, but instead we ended up with a bunch of environmentalists and progressives and hippies who were all bitching about their niche agendas and somehow failing to see in their echochamber intersectionality that they weren't saying anything that 95% of the rest of the 99% gave two shits about. And now, in 2015, I see that the startup ecosystem and game is basically based on squeezing labor out of early employees while paying lip service to "visionary" founders. I see that large companies are bemoaning the lack of trained devs and yet who are pushing H1B support at the same time that everybody is pointing out the aggressive "train your foreign replacement" techniques of those same companies. I see great swaths of the Internet grown fat upon the domestic surveillance of advertising, a rot so deep that it'll probably kill off something like half of humanity's accumulated output from the last few years because it'll suddenly no longer be economical. And in this total ratfuck, finally, people are starting to go after the perceived oppressors--ye olde cisthet while males--because that's a more convenient target than grappling with the forces that put them there and are finding ways of flaying them still further in pursuit of the all might dollar. So, yeah, you're damned right I don't believe in capitalism anymore.
- dmfdmf 10y agoIts not young people that matter but the class responsible for educating them, the intellectuals. Few intellectuals even know what capitalism is and what an historical achievement it is. Much to the intellectual's dismay on both the left and right she ain't going away after decades of smears, misrepresentation and attempts to ignore her arguments. Cf. Ayn Rand's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism:_The_Unknown_Ideal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism:_The_Unknown_Ideal NB: This is not a book on economics, in this book she makes a moral case for capitalism based on her ethics of rational egoism, i.e selfishness. She was not primarily interested in politics or economics except as a consequence of her work in epistemology and ethics. I urge anyone who cares about the future of Western Civilization to read her books and judge it for yourself instead of repeating what others say about her. At the very least it will force you to examine some of your own premises and worldview, i.e it will make you think, even if you disagree.
- mikerichards 10y agoThe democrat party is so far to the left of JFK, that there's no real middle-ground between the parties anymore. America is at a tipping point right now. Things could get real nasty in the not too distant future. No wonder there's so many AR-15s sold and no wonder that the left wants to take them away.
- lossolo 10y agoRate of return on capital is greater than the rate of economic growth over the long term, the result is concentration of wealth, and this unequal distribution of wealth causes social and economic instability.
- tehabe 10y agoIn a capitalist economy there is almost nothing worse than a monopoly. Maybe this is the issue of capitalism too. It is a monopoly for over 20 years now. There is nothing anymore to compete with.
- devishard 10y agoI'm not sure I've ever seen someone so readily admit they don't know what the world "socialism" means.
- durandal1 10y agoQuite the opposite, and for the record, I'm a native Swede so I do have quite the first hand experience. Socialism means that production and distribution are controlled by the workers, something which isn't true for any state in Scandinavia. In fact the economies were built through quite liberal market policies.
- devishard 10y ago> Socialism means that production and distribution are controlled by the workers That's not what socialism means. That sounds more like communism. In capitalism, both basic and non-basic industries are privately owned. In communism both basic and non-basic industries are publicly owned. In socialism, basic industries are publicly owned and non-basic industries are privately owned. Of course there is some argument about what industries are basic, which makes this more of a spectrum than three distinct categories. So when you say "mostly liberal states with extensive welfare programs", the "extensive welfare programs" ostensibly cover most basic industries, while the "liberal market policies" you mention cover the non-basic industries. I'm not arguing your knowledge of Scandinavia, I'm saying that's not what socialism means. Corporations have tried to politicize the terms in order to vilify socialism and capitalism, and represent them as oppressive ideologies, but they're just economic systems, and don't inherently have to be tied to totalitarianism as they were in the USSR for example.
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11927038 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11927038 and marked it off-topic.
- maker1138 10y agoIf only people learned history. Look at the comprehensive list of hyperinflations in modern history. Every single one happened under leftist rule of the country [1]. Look at Venezuela, Cuba or any other very leftist state. There's always a rich elite, and a poor underclass. If only people would learn that its socialistic policies that make the rich richer and the poor poorer! Capitalism (voluntary trade and respect for private property) has always improved everyone's lives. What we need is a transition to more capitalism not less of it. If we keep implementing leftist policies that sound nice (like min wage, 'free' education, 'free' healthcare, etc) we'll end up poor like all the other socialist countries before us. It's time to actually have compassion on the poor and create opportunities through capitalism. [1] http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/hanke-krus-hyperinflation-table-may-2013.pdf http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/hanke-k...
- riotdash 10y agoLack of education, low IQ etc.