8 ms·
Now A No-Evil Zone
- aditya 17y agotl;dr Tim Bray is going to google to work on Android from Vancouver because he thinks Android is great.
- robin_reala 17y agoI’d like to think that Hacker News is the kind of community that doesn’t need a tl;dr before they dive into the comments…
- ubernostrum 17y agoTo be honest, that summary was about as long as the article needed to be. There really wasn't anything else in it which hadn't been covered either in previous posts on Tim's blog or in the general atmosphere here (do we really need yet another "Walled gardens are evil!!!!!!1", when that's been rehashed so many times already?).
- ubernostrum 17y agoOK, so I'll break the rules and go all meta... The one-line summary which started this little sub-thread was accurate and contained basically all the salient details. Most of the rest of the linked blog post is Tim explaining why he thinks Android's better than iPhone (and/or why he thinks Google is better than Apple). None of that material is new or noteworthy, none of it is new coming from Tim (he's expressed opinions on the subject before) and none of it will be unfamiliar to anyone who frequents any geek-oriented forum. As I write this there are 48 comments in the thread here on HN. 40 of those 48 comments are the same Android vs. iPhone arguments everyone here has seen more times than they can count. Of the other 8, 3 are related to the process of how Tim got his new job. So that's a whopping 45 out of 48 comments which have nothing whatsoever to do with the actual bit of news announced in the linked article. Which raises a couple questions: * Is that really what you want from HN? * Is a one-line summary of the article, minus the flamewar fuel, more or less useful than the actual article? * Gee, Brain, what are we doing to do tonight? (Answer: The same thing we do every night, Pinky: argue about Android versus iPhone!) (and for completeness' sake, yes, I flagged this link)
- dbz 17y agoI found this piece very interesting =] Joining Google for Andriod- yet never making a useful Application for it. I wonder what he will be doing exactly...
- bretthoerner 17y agoI think Bray is mostly an evangelist at this point.
- Kilimanjaro 17y agoAnd a very good at that. Just his first post made me want to learn about android right away, even if I consider the iPhone a way superior experience.
- gvb 17y agoWhile "no useful app" may be strictly accurate, he has written app(s) and blogged his experiences. http://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/200x/2008/12/18/Android-Diary http://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/200x/2008/12/18/Android-Di... [edit: Direct link to Android Diaries" rather than a google search]
- ilamont 17y agoHis description of the iPhone universe: "It’s a sterile Disney-fied walled garden surrounded by sharp-toothed lawyers. The people who create the apps serve at the landlord’s pleasure and fear his anger." Unfortunately for Android, many or even most consumers prefer a Disney-fied experience. Can Android achieve that without the walled-garden approach?
- davidw 17y agoOne area where Android might easily be very successful is for businesses that need to do custom things, and don't want Apple sticking its nose in their affairs.
- pvg 17y agoThis exists, for large businesses - http://developer.apple.com/programs/iphone/enterprise/ http://developer.apple.com/programs/iphone/enterprise/ In house apps can be distributed without the App Store.
- davidw 17y ago> the iPhone Developer Enterprise Program is available to companies with 500 or more employees and a Dun & Bradstreet number. Android is available to... anyone.
- pvg 17y agoDoesn't change the fact that large businesses have a way to get around having to use the App Store. Small businesses can use 'ad hoc' distribution which lets you distribute to 100 iPhones. Your point was based on the assumption that the App Store is the only way a business can distribute an app to iPhones. This is not the case.
- davidw 17y agoNo, my point was that Android is open, Apple is not. There may be some businesses out there who just don't want to go through all that bureaucracy and hoop jumping to do something new and interesting. Android gives them that possibility, Apple does not.
- ananthrk 17y agoOT: Just curios. Would someone like Tim Bray (who is well-known and has a reputation) be required to take part in the technical interviews that other Googlers go through? EDIT: better phrasing
- simonw 17y agoFrom the article, it sounds like it. "I think I talked to eleven people in the course of my day there, failing one logic puzzle but acing the what-does-a-browser-actually-do test." - sounds like my Google interview a few years ago.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rimantas 17y agoLooks like this kind of comparison is there to stay: As of now, they’re selling around 90K iPhones per day compared to around 60K Android handsets. It’s a horse race! How about "they're selling X Macbook Air's compared to Y Win machines". Does this version sound right?
- romland 17y agoI don't consider the comparison wrong in this context. We are talking about Operating Systems here. Not phones. In other contexts it might be wrong, however.
- rimantas 17y agoEven in this case iPhone OS sells only on two devices (so far) and Android is on ~20 I assume.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jokermatt999 17y agoNot including the iPod Touch is a mistake, in my opinion. Also, you have to account for the issues with apps on different versions of Android. I'd love this competition to be as close as the article makes it out to be, but I don't think it's there quite yet.
- dalore 17y agoAndroid might be catching up, but it is also fragmented. When developing for Android you don't know what features the phone has. It's going the way of Java Mobile.
- newsit 17y agoI know I'll get my ... kicked for this comment, but anyway. The iPhone experience is not sterile at all. It comes with a browser and there is no restriction for the websites you can open. Google ('the web is the computer') should be the ones to best understand this. Since when is controlling the quality and security of the content at a marketplace that you operate equal to limiting people's freedoms? If I own a grocery shop and refuse to sell someone's rotten tomatoes does it make me necessary evil? Not letting people charge 0.99$ for balloons in swimwear using your own infrastructure has nothing to do with their freedom of speech. They can always create a web page and show it to the world.
- dalore 17y agoTry open one of them flash based porn sites.
- somebear 17y agoThere are porn sites that have started supporting H.264, possibly in order to cater to the iPhone users, although I have no data to back up that assumption.
- p6 17y agoIm sure you dont wink
- isleyaardvark 17y agoThe iPhone's web browser supports open standards. I'm not too upset it doesn't support a closed (if popular) format. Not only that but I'd say the iPhone/iPad will give the biggest boost to HTML5 video, due to increased demand.
- hackoder 17y agoI dont think there's an issue with controlling the quality and security of the content at a marketplace. Its an issue that its the _only_ marketplace that they're controlling.
- 17y ago
- cschneid 17y agoAm I the only techie who DOESN'T want another totally open device? I have a mac, a windows pc, another mac laptop, my girlfriend's computer, my girlfriend's mom's linux system, etc. I already provide tech support to some degree or another for all of them. I don't want another device I have to understand to the core in order to avoid viruses, trojan apps, and other mundane problems. I want a damn phone that runs a few apps. I like that I can outsource most of my worries to Apple, and let them worry about it, and the price is that I don't have root. I wonder how we can make both sides happy: both my side of "I know what I'm doing, but I don't want to do it.", and "It's my toy, let me do what I want". I see the merits of both, but I worry even about putting a "unlock me please" button in the settings panes somewhere, since it will end up with phones trojaned, dialing 1-900 numbers so the owner could have a cute animated cat on their unlock screen.
- jrockway 17y agoThe iPhone has more viruses than Android.
- mechanical_fish 17y agoLink, please.
- cschneid 17y agoA quick google corraborates his argument, as long as you stick to a strict definition of virus (there was that SMS one for the iphone, none came up on google for the android), although the android has had trojan software in its marketplace.
- cschneid 17y agoI know there have been security holes in the iphone, and there will be in Android as well. The big thing I worry about are real trojans like: http://www.bit-tech.net/news/bits/2010/01/11/banking-trojan-hits-android/ http://www.bit-tech.net/news/bits/2010/01/11/banking-trojan-... Beyond that, there's another article on HN front page that talks about the painfulness of upgrades to the android OS, and how various phones run different versions. My basic thing was that yes, I can understand it, but I don't want to worry. I just want a phone, that runs some chunk of apps. The lack of management capability is a feature, as well as a handcuff.
- wglb 17y agoA word from the poster. I didn't expect to see the focus of this article on a debate between open and closed and between google and apple. I found it interesting because I have followed Tim's blog, if only sporadically, for some time now. I have a lot of respect for him, as he is a visionary , and has worked on some of the relevant technologies of our time: 1) Author of one of the first search engines 2) co-author of the XML standard 3) technically very savy fellow. What I have been wondering about his tenure at sun and his subsequent decision timed deliciously to leave sun just before he became an oracle employee is how it might foretell the future of the sun technologies and how oracle decides to treat the sun legacy.
- acangiano 17y agoThey asked freakin' Tim Bray how a browser works. That's a bit overzealous if you ask me. I hope they withheld questions about XML at the very least. I wonder if they asked logic puzzles and the like to Peter Norvig as well. I can already imagine the interview. 25 yr old interviewer: "What sorting algorithm would you use to sort a billion integers?" Norvig: "Son, ..."