4 ms·
Serious question: how is this legal? I can't imagine I could make someone sign a form that he waives his right to sue me and then shoot him, right? Assuming he
by lucb1e 10y ago
Serious question: how is this legal? I can't imagine I could make someone sign a form that he waives his right to sue me and then shoot him, right? Assuming he doesn't die and it's him, not the government, that prosecutes/sues me.
- mmanfrin 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_Mobility_LLC_v._Concepcion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_Mobility_LLC_v._Concepc... 5 to 4 decision, along the same lines as you'd assume.
- pdabbadabba 10y agoNot exactly. This opinion only decided that an arbitration clause can disallow class-wide arbitration. The real answer to GP's question is the Federal Arbitration Act (which, by the way, was also the statutory basis for Concepcion): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Arbitration_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Arbitration_Act
- EpicEng 10y agoWell that would be a criminal act and the state would be pressing charges, not the victim. Bad analogy.
- the_watcher 10y ago> I can't imagine I could make someone sign a form that he waives his right to sue me and then shoot him, right? To answer your question - yes, you could legally have someone sign a contract waiving his right to sue you for shooting him. However, the contract would be unenforceable, and he could sue you (for both shooting him and potentially for the contract - IIRC, that depends on the state). One of the things that became abundantly clear in contract law is that you can put essentially anything into a contract, legally. It's enforcement of said contract that the legal system gets involved in.
- lucb1e 10y ago> you could legally have someone sign a contract waiving [t]his right [...] However, the contract would be unenforceable I understand I can write any nonsense and sign it, probably because of freedom of expression or something. My point was whether that contract would be enforceable. If such a thing wasn't enforceable Google and others wouldn't be putting it in their contracts.
- Vraxx 10y agoNot necessarily true. You have to challenge it to find out if it's enforceable in many scenarios, and it might act as a deterrent as well. Even a widely known unenforceable clause can deter someone who doesn't previously know that it is unenforceable from doing the action that the clause prohibits. So I can definitely see plenty of reasons to include these types of things in a contract. Plus, what does it cost them to include it in the contract?