6 ms·
> "Mr. Bernanke has a lot of money, as do the other bankers on the committee and the people who selected them. So they’ve decided to let millions and millions o
by potatolicious 17y ago
> "Mr. Bernanke has a lot of money, as do the other bankers on the committee and the people who selected them. So they’ve decided to let millions and millions of people be unemployed and the rest of us experience the resulting recession rather than risk the chance that some of their money might be worth a little less."
Okay, I was with you until this part - that's a pretty serious claim to make without any substantiating evidence, or even something that kind of looks like evidence.
This seems like a gross oversimplification of a complex problem to me, and like most other gross oversimplifications of the recession, seems to just pin the blame on "greedy bankers".
- CoreDumpling 17y agoI agree. I "work for a living" (whatever that means, though in the context used here it's as opposed to being a "greedy banker"), and I can sympathize with the plight of the unemployed, but I've also made sure I had sufficient savings as a rainy day fund and am also prepared to reduce my living expenses if necessary. I think that I have every reason to be concerned that my little nest egg might be devalued. More apropos to the community here, this could also mean a shorter runway for a bootstrapped startup; I don't see how founders would be pleased by such a move.
- potatolicious 17y agoMore relevant to the general population: when your nest egg's value is anything but safe, you are going to spend your money as soon as you get it - this has more ill effects than I can enumerate This reminds me of my grandfather's stories during the Chinese Civil War (or shortly after the capitulation of the Nationalists anyway), where he'd get his pay and immediately bike at lightning speed to the market to trade it for sustenance. Of course, the only thing that fixed that was a complete currency reset: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Taiwan_dollar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Taiwan_dollar I'm not sure if the US would really be better off with that.
- fnid2 17y agoThe same thing happened in Argentina and the same thing could happen in the U.S. Countless fiat currencies in history have experienced the same fate. The only solution I have ever seen in my research is to return to a commodity backed currency. If there are other solutions, I don't know of them, but would like to.
- cynicalkane 17y agoCurrencies backed by anything are a terrible idea. Most economists now believe that deflation caused by a gold-backed currency was one of the primary causes of the Great Depression. Imagine how much worse it will be with, say, an oil-backed currency. What would 2007 have done to our economy? Central fiat banking is the best known solution to the currency problem. This solution gets hated on by a lot of people who don't know any better, but think they do. The central requirement is that the currency-makers be independent of just about everyone, so that nobody can debase the integrity of the currency for political reasons. This angers everyone who thinks they know better than the central bank, but the anger of the average anti-establishment type is fickle and transient. It also angers the politicans, who are more dangerous--the examples of Argentina and Taiwan given here demonstrate not the dangers of fiat currencies, but rather that any currency should be kept far, far away from politicians.
- Nwallins 17y ago> The central requirement is that the currency-makers be independent of just about everyone Thus ignoring our entire system of checks and balances. Do you not see the danger, here? > This angers everyone who thinks they know better than the central bank AKA, every market participant. > but rather that any currency should be kept far, far away from politicians. In what sense are central bankers not politicians? They are not elected, that's for sure. However, they exercise a large amount of control over our economy and very much influence official political action. In a sense, they are very much a separate executive branch of our political system.
- 17y ago
- gcb 17y agothey would be pleased because loosing the funds for dragging their clientles company for a few more months would be replaced by having a profit faster.
- barrkel 17y agoI'm not trying to justify Aaron's economically illiterate conspiracy theorizing, but I would like to reiterate some of what I first emailed Aaron a few years ago when he first started talking about this (e.g. http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/predatorstate http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/predatorstate ). It's true to a degree that bankers don't aim for zero unemployment - i.e. implicitly they "let millions and millions of people be unemployed" - because to do so would create inflationary effects. Such an economy would be overheating. In an economy the size of the US, you would expect there to be a few million people unemployed at any given moment, simply because of turnover. But this is pretty basic stuff. See e.g.: http://www.investinganswers.com/term/unemployment-rate-809 http://www.investinganswers.com/term/unemployment-rate-809 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAIRU http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAIRU It is however true that the Fed has a rather ridiculously overloaded mandate. It has basically one lever - the interest rate - with which it is supposed to target multiple goals - "maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates". If you think about this for a moment, you'll realize it's not possible.
- scotty79 17y agoIn my country equivalent of FED has only one goal: Keep inflation moderate and manageable. It works out pretty well.
- pinstriped_dude 17y agoAnd "my country" would be _______ ?
- scotty79 17y agoPoland I was a bit imprecise. Not equivalent of whole FED but equivalent of part of FED that makes decisions about monetary policy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_Policy_Council http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_Policy_Council In Poland monetary policy is understood as keeping prices stable not as attaining a set of objectives oriented towards the growth and stability of the economy.
- 17y ago
- shawndrost 17y agoI agree. Although Aaron does offer support for the idea that Bernanke is choosing unemployment over inflation [1], he doesn't support the idea that the bankers are motivated by selfishness. (For example, they may be motivated by the fact that inflation would make the dollar an unattractive investment vehicle to other countries.) [1] Via quoting from the Economist: “Mr Bernanke does not want to risk a de-anchoring of inflation expectations. He is willing to accept 10% or greater unemployment and the resulting economic and political fall-out in order to avoid that risk.”
- scotty79 17y ago> ... he doesn't support the idea that the bankers are motivated by selfishness. ... Isn't that assumption always taken by default when considering nearly all market actions? That actors in the market are primarily motivated by selfish goals?
- drunkpotato 17y agoUnless that assumption would lay the blame for a catastrophe on wealthy people and require changes that would make them less wealthy, in which case we cannot take selfishness for granted and have to assume their motivations are altruistic (if misguided). You really need to be up-to-date on modern market ideology.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoModern market ideology does tend to assume people controlling the government and various agencies (for instance, Bernake) are motivated by selfishness. It also assumes that the home-borrowers, politicians, realtors and bankers who created the housing bubble were motivated by selfishness, as were the hedge fund managers and bankers who helped pop the bubble.
- eru 17y agoThose market actors also only have limited rationality (and not perfect foresight), and skewed incentives (-> principal agent problems). That needn't hinder one from constructing a conspiracy theory, though.
- fnid2 17y agoJust ask yourself this question: If I have $1M and I can decide between two options a) tomorrow my money is worth $2M b) tomorrow my money is worth $500k Which option would you choose? These bankers are human beings. They are naturally and understandably biased. Not only are they making these decisions for themselves, but they are making them for all their friends, family, and business associates -- all of whom are also millionaires and billionaires. I don't see it as much a conspiracy theory as an understanding of human nature. Originally, the fed was created by a secret committee of bankers on a remote island. It was rushed through congress quietly -- I know, because I read the decades old NY Times article covering the legislation at the Will Rogers Museum. Then, if you watch the recent Moore film, you'll see that the current bail out was voted down in congress, then secret meetings led by many of these bankers, GS and the like, prompted a revote and they rushed it through again -- when it passed. What Aaron said is pretty accurate. The bankers aren't looking out for main street and the jobs won't be back for a while. I've been trying to sell a house now for almost a year and many people want it and none of them can get a loan -- they've tried. They have jobs. They have income and the ability to repay the loan, but the banks just aren't giving out any money. Contrast that to 4 years ago when you didn't even have to have a job at all or verify income to get a million dollar loan -- I know, because it was my job to build information systems to help the subprime match makers connect home buyers with the banks who wanted to give them the loans. When I realized how dirty it all was -- I quit and started my own company and I'm very glad I did.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoBut it's really more like his choices are: a) His $1 million earns ~3% interest and depreciates by 2% per year, or b) His $1 million earns ~4% interest and depreciates by 3% per year. You're arguing that these guys are promoting multi-trillion dollar swings in the country's wealth in order to earn a couple more basis points on their investments. If you're going to posit a Greedy Ben Bernanke, why is he being so slow and cautious? He can probably make, at most, 1% per year extra by manipulating the value of the dollar. Or he could take a suitcase full of cash.
- yummyfajitas 17y ago
- johnl 17y agoI think the article is misdirected. A few years ago Japan increased their money supply by 30% to dig themselves out of their depression and it failed to work. So increasing the money supply I doubt will work any better here in the U.S. All those people now being foreclosed on should have had their loan applications disqualified. That responsibility falls to Washington to regulate, not the Federal Reserve, and the biggest scream that "you can't do that" would have been Washington, not the Federal Reserve I believe.