9 ms·
How Hired Hackers Got “Complete Control” of Palantir
- leroy_masochist 10y agoHow does Palantir's response stack up? Having read the article, I'm not sure whether to read it as: "The extent to which the red team was able to exploit the network is a sign that Palantir's network security is bad" or, "Despite Palantir following best practices and having a lot of smart people on their security team, the red team was still able to do a lot, which bodes really badly for other companies that don't have the same internal resources"?
- rando289 10y ago"Our systems and our customers’ information were never at risk.", their pr team is clueless. Security is not binary.
- argonaut 10y agoThe fact that they had a specific team test their security is already evidence they aren't clueless. Clueless would be refusing to have teams test your security.
- meowface 10y agoWere never at risk as a result of this pentest. Obviously, there is still a risk of data loss... but that risk is present among nearly every company on Earth.
- keithpeter 10y agoAccording to the report (and I'm never sure how far one can trust leaked documents simply because you don't get the full context) the intrusion was not noticed until the intruders reached one compromised laptop that had non-standard software installed on it (LittleSnitch) that tripped an alarm when the intruders tried to upload a screen shot. Perhaps best practices might include more and more varied trip wire software of this nature? Disclaimer: I'm a civilian. My exposure to infosec begins and ends with being careful about email and USB drives.
- tptacek 10y agoI don't understand why we're reading this. Was it leaked? Pretty much every big tech firm does this twice a year, but nobody releases the reports.
- npkarnik 10y agoThis is such bad PR - probably leaked maliciously.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- omonra 10y agoI would not be surprised if this is related to the Gawker debacle.
- salemh 10y agoWhy at all? Because Thiel is an investor in Palantir? I googled a bit to try and something that relates Gawker and Palantir beyond that.
- jblow 10y ago"... in the next phase, you too will be subject to a dose of transparency. However philanthropic your intention, and careful the planning, the details of your involvement will be gruesome." http://gawker.com/an-open-letter-to-peter-thiel-1778991227 http://gawker.com/an-open-letter-to-peter-thiel-1778991227
- hobs 10y agoHaving tried to avoid that entire story up until reading that, I remain pitiless for gawker's position in every way and I hope it burns to the ground.
- 10y ago
- hendzen 10y agoI don't think Palantir should be shamed for this. It's laudable that they invested in penetration testing - better they find out this way than by an actual APT/hacking group.
- quanticle 10y agoExactly. And has been pointed out elsewhere, pretty much every large tech firm does red-team/blue-team tests these days. It's just that we don't hear about the vulnerabilities that are found at those other firms.
- jwcrux 10y agoExactly. It's crappy that they are likely getting flack over this. Chances are, it was leaked by a disgruntled employee. But the fact is that the red team started on the internal network and used tactics that would work on darn near every org these days. Palantir is no different. The only issue is that their pentest report was leaked.
- jzwinck 10y agoGiven the nature of Palantir's business, isn't it sort of a big deal in itself that an internal report was leaked? What if the leak had been some other internal document, say one that contained customer secrets?
- tptacek 10y agoThe leak, if that's what this is, is a big deal. The contents of the report are not.
- hackuser 10y ago> It's laudable that they invested in penetration testing I don't think they should be lauded for doing their jobs and discovering they failed at them. If your QA team discovers huge numbers of bugs, you don't laud yourself for doing QA. If a leading accounting firm hires an outside auditor and discovered their own books were rotten, should they be lauded? I guess there's a silver lining in everything. I guess I'd be willing to trust Palantir's advice on hiring penetration testers, but not on securing my systems.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hackuser 10y ago> Palantir does an incredibly comprehensive job with PR and damage control Those are just two more aspects of controlling information.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- secstate 10y agoHa! ... quick turn around by Fortune, http://fortune.com/2016/06/18/palantir-hack-buzzfeed/ http://fortune.com/2016/06/18/palantir-hack-buzzfeed/ Bizarre to watch a company move like that ... a bit unnerving in an Enders-Game sort of way. Information manipulation, and suddenly you wonder who's wagging the dog.
- argonaut 10y agoYou haven't actually commented on the actual content of the Buzzfeed article or the Fortune article, but instead have decided to go the route of putting forth FUD about sockpuppets and media manipulation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- argonaut 10y agoHow do you know Buzzfeed's source isn't a competitor with an axe to grind? You don't. So this almost-unfalsifiable FUD is useless.
- arca_vorago 10y agoHonestly it's as if people have forgotten one of the fundamental principles of strategy and tactics. The attacker almost always has the advantage. Its true in the book of five rings, its true in the art of war, it's just a basic principle. Now, thats not to say an adanced attacker still can't be defended against, but as a sysadmin who has seen the inside of companies from law firms to publicly traded big guys to the IT firms themselves... And that's that almost no managment has put forward the personell or the budgets or the culture needed to really secure things. Hell, a family member of mine recently got a tour of spacex and was apalled at the security. If Musk and his money dont do it right or well, almost nobody is. I've basically told people who run windows systems for business they're already comprimised most likely, and the best thing to do is to be doing hids and good log analysis so you catch it when it happens quickly... but you probably arent going to stop any kind of semi-advanced attacker. So to be frank, it completely makes sense to me that a company like Palantir would be massively vulnerable from thr inside. The edge of the sword they live on cuts both ways. These days, its about response time and forensic afteraction. "When Palantir’s information security employees finally discovered the intruders, they “provided a rapid network response in which they identified and mitigated” the “majority” of the red team’s actions within days, the report says. Compared with other large companies, this defensive response was unusually robust, the industry source said, based on a reading of the report."
- muglug 10y agoThe red team also had the big benefit that there would be no legal ramifications if/when they were discovered. That no doubt encouraged them to take bigger risks, and consequently get further, than a malicious hacker would.
- snarf 10y agoDo you honestly think that state sponsored hackers care about the legal ramifications of being discovered?
- meowface 10y agoIn some cases, they do care very much. Just not from a legal standpoint. Many nation states prefer not to be detected when conducting espionage. And if they are detected, they really prefer to not have the attack be attributed to their country. At the very least, they want some plausible deniability; ideally full-on anonymity or framing, if they can. Sometimes they really don't care if the source of the attack is known. It depends on the political rationale behind it. But when they do care, they're definitely at more of a disadvantage than a hired red team. The red team has no real anxiety over whether they're caught or attributed, and can act more quickly and aggressively.
- ScottBurson 10y agoWow, this is sobering. I've certainly heard it said that if you're a big tech company, you are already infiltrated by state-sponsored hackers. But since I've never seen one of these red-team reports, this synopsis provides a lot of color on how people can get around inside the network, once they get in, that I wasn't aware of (obviously I don't work in opsec). Too bad for Palantir that this got leaked, but perhaps it can be instructive for many of us.
- utefan001 10y agorelated.. https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/johnromsft/2016/06/14/why-you-should-use-rdp-restrictedadmin/ https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/johnromsft/2016/06/14/wh...
- amjo324 10y agoThe truth is that when reputable information security specialists are engaged to perform a no holds barred internal network penetration test or red teaming exercise for a client, they will gain full administrative access of the network in more than 9 out of 10 cases. There are well known and documented techniques for escalating privileges and traversing through a network. This is just the reality if you operate a typical Windows corporate network of a sufficient size. In the past, companies mostly just accepted this risk and focused on protecting their network perimeter. Over time, this attitude has shifted and organisations now recognise the insider threat (e.g. a rogue employee/contractor or an external attacker who has already breached the perimeter).
- utefan001 10y agoThis recent post from microsoft describes how to mitigate some of the risk that got Palantir. https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/johnromsft/2016/06/14/why-you-should-use-rdp-restrictedadmin/ https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/johnromsft/2016/06/14/wh... "I can’t stress how important this change is – an administrator who connects using “normal” RDP exposes his or her credentials to the remote system with every connection. RDPRA, on the other hand, ensures that credentials aren’t exposed to the attacker on the remote computer being managed."
- nerdponx 10y agoWhat a ridiculous clickbait title
- nikcub 10y agoShaming companies for carrying out pentests is counter-productive, i'm more interested in who is leaking against Palantir and why. This is the third story now that William Alden has written about Palantir that appear to be based on internal documents[0] His profile of the company a month ago opened with: > A trove of internal documents and insider interviews has pulled back the curtain on one of Silicon Valley’s most secretive and highly valued companies, Palantir Technologies. There isn't much public interest in large parts of the profile nor the follow-up stories, so it has a feeling of a disgruntled employee. A really difficult class of threat to defend against and stop, but each additional story and leak provides a few more bits of data that can narrow down the suspect pool. I really hope the leaker and journalist in this case know what they're getting themselves into - because based on the pentest report the infosec team at Palantir appear capable of tracking the leak down. [0] https://www.buzzfeed.com/williamalden?language=en https://www.buzzfeed.com/williamalden?language=en [1] https://www.buzzfeed.com/williamalden/inside-palantir-silicon-valleys-most-secretive-company https://www.buzzfeed.com/williamalden/inside-palantir-silico...
- threatofrain 10y agoThe leaks at Palantir might not be connected to a single source, but rather a cultural issue, and thus multiple leaks. Having the special talent to track down hacking threats and actively patch problems is different from the ability to wonder whether your next information release is going to be leaked through non-technical means. Finding the leak is going to involve assigning different truths to different individuals (like what Hollywood does with film previews), which will itself lead to more cultural issues.
- argonaut 10y agoNo company finds leaks that way (assigning different truths). Finding leaks is a matter of looking to see who accessed which documents.
- threatofrain 10y agoIf a company sends out communication to a group of authorized employees, then presumably they all accessed the documents -- as they should have. In the case of a security test, presumably many people were made aware so that they could improve their security. Who among those employees leaked? You can only know by access if that information was sufficiently isolating or unique.
- jacquesm 10y agoSo, who will take the bet that it was only the red team doing the pentest that managed to get this level of access? The one saving grace here is that the red team had to be 'let in', in other words, they started from a position that is substantially different from being a complete outsider. It also makes you wonder what else was leaked besides the report.
- kriro 10y agoWhat is the standard measures taken to protect against spear phishing? Mostly educating users and trying to filter out the mails? Palantir basically started the red team in a position where they had successfully spear phished someone and that seems to be common practice. Is trying to protect against it just a waste of time and should the resources be invested into proper segmentation to protect against the successful spear phis case? Or are people usually 80/20ing this and taking anti spear phish measures but only to an extend that covers a lot of ground at relatively low cost/time?
- bobedybobbob 10y agoPhishing is generally 1. run a command or 2. give me your credentials. To prevent these you need good solid technical controls like U2F for password based authentication (which is origin bound). Similarly binary whitelisting will prevent most users from running rogue executables.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bobedybobbob 10y agoWith time, creativity and motivation a good offensive security team will always win. All we can do as defenders is to find ways to raise the cost of such an attack. A bit disappointed they seem to have started on the internal network rather then coming in from the outside :)
- Bromskloss 10y agoWhat does Palantir do, really?
- SCHiM 10y ago> A Palantír is a dangerous tool, Saruman. They are not all accounted for, the lost Seeing Stones. We do not know who else may be watching! It's weird that this story is considered newsworthy. I skimmed over the article and it looks about normal for the industry. As sad as it sounds, they aren't doing much worse than many other companies out there.
- graycat 10y agoGee, we have to wonder if some good anomaly detection https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11880593 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11880593 would have detected that intrusion?
- swingbridge 10y agoEvery major company performs these sorts of "red team" tests and virtually no major company passes with flying colors... so it's not surprising that Palintir has its fair share of issues. What is surprising is that all this stuff leaks out about Palinitr while other companies manage to keep things under tighter wraps.