8 ms·
Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us
- jerf 10y ago"Combining the equations for the Fermi paradox and the mediocrity principle, the authors suggests Earth might hear from an alien civilization when approximately half of the Milky Way Galaxy has been signaled in about 1,500 years." Not sure where the paper is, but the Milky Way galaxy is much bigger than that. The Milky Way is expected to be from 100,000 to 120,000 light years in diameter. A ~3200ly diameter sphere isn't "half" that.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoI'm guessing they assume aliens to be scattered homogeneously around the galaxy at some probable density?
- jerf 10y agoI'm assuming "journalist misheard something and isn't intimately familiar enough with space scales to know it". I don't really mean the latter as a criticism... however much fun it may be, there isn't much practical value to knowing the Milky Way is ~100,000lys in diameter.
- drjesusphd 10y agoYeah, the timescale for the Fermi Paradox is millions of years; it'd be a hard sell that 1500 years can make a dent in it.
- pmiller2 10y agoWikipedia claims that the entire galaxy can be traversed in ~1M years. Life on earth has been around for ~3.8G years. If life started somewhere in the galaxy a few million years earlier than that, and evolved into a spacefaring civilization, it's not too far fetched that they could either have already been here, or, if they are close enough, they could pick up our signals and come for a look-see.
- mikeash 10y agoRight, the Fermi Paradox isn't asking why aliens haven't come to visit us now that they've surely heard our radio signals. It's about why we're even here at all, given that it seems like aliens should have come and colonized the place ages ago, or at least why there are no signs of past exploratory visits.
- jerf 10y agoA while back on HN there was a discussion about whether shooting radio waves into space was a good idea, because the game theoretic solution to "why are we alone" might be that extraterrestrial civilizations pre-emptively destroy any other competition they can identify. What finally made me reject this hypothesis is that A: you shouldn't actually wait for intelligent life to develop, because even if humans are somehow progressing at the fastest possible rate and nothing could be faster, a claim I would seriously doubt, we're still developing at this rate dangerously quickly and B: Earth has been broadcasting "I very likely have life!" for not a century since the invention of radio, but approximately 2.3 billion years, since the invention of atmospheric oxygen, which is something that should be possible to determine from great distances by looking at the spectra lines when Earth occludes the Sun. We're already doing that a bit ourselves, and our telescopes are tiny compared to what a full Kardashev-1 civilization could put together, or even what we could put together if this was our top priority. Even on the cosmic scale, 2.3 billion years is a Real Amount of Time. Unless nearly every solar system has life of a similar degree of obviousness from light-years away, making Earth's signal just noise, we've been broadcasting that we're at least worth a probe for a long time. I doubt every solar system has free-oxygen-generating life or any equivalent; you don't have to believe the "Rare Earth" arguments prove that Earth is alone for it to show that even with our current understanding of physics, chemistry, etc. it is very unlikely that every, or even a majority, of systems have advanced life in them. Given that the limits of technology that we now believe in strongly suggest that an unopposed "probe" is probably on its own sufficient to colonize a planet (and thus render it no longer a threat), it remains very strange that we're here at all, not long since displaced by an aliens. In a weird way, it would almost make more sense from the Fermi paradox point of view if we obviously hadn't developed here and if humans were obviously aliens-to-Earth, but humans have an immaculate pedigree for being 100% all-natural Earth-sourced ingredients.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoIt also assumes that aliens could respond at the speed of light. Now in Star Trek, they could, but it wasn't our signaling that caught their attention.
- chmike 10y agoIt's apparently easy to get an article published that say that aliens are all dead, minuscule or not close to reach earth. No one managed to get an article published that say that aliens have been visiting earth for many years with UFOs. There seam to be a very strong bias in peer review on this topic.
- drjesusphd 10y agoYes, because scientists tend to be fond of evidence.
- voidz 10y agoYeah? http://retractionwatch.com http://retractionwatch.com
- drjesusphd 10y agoNot saying it's a universal trait.
- splawn 10y agoThe fact that there are retractions shows that evidence matters... so "Yeah."
- dleslie 10y agoAs it goes, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. I have never in my life seen a mountain gorilla. I am aware of evidence that shows that they exist, but at my age my grand parents did not have access to that same evidence; does that mean that mountain gorillas came into existence when the evidence was found? Almost certainly not, heh, but they would have been valid in disbelieving in the existence of such beasts. There could be a person behind me with a knife, poised to slay me; but I am fairly confident that this is not the case due to a number of factors. On a population scale, such incidents are vanishingly few, and I took precautions earlier today to ensure that my home was locked and secured; but that does not guarantee certainty of my safety. It would be a fallacy, perhaps post hoc ergo propter hoc, for me to believe in the certainty that there is no such individual behind me. Until I turn around and observe the empty space, I cannot lay claim to the existence or non-existence of that individual. We cannot observe all of Earth all of the time, and we cannot do so for the Solar system, or lay claim to having done so throughout history. This does not mean that aliens have visited us, or that they even exist; it means that we cannot be certain that they don't exist and that they haven't visited.
- libeclipse 10y ago"We are on the third planet around a tediously boring star surrounded by other completely normal stars about two-thirds of the way along one of several arms of a remarkably average spiral galaxy."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- WJW 10y agoI'm always amazed by people thinking it is possible for distant civilizations to pick up random radio signals (typically television broadcasts) that were transmitted on earth. Any signals spreading out in space already has to deal with an inverse square law due to the wavefront being spread out. However, the amount of noise stays roughly the same all over the universe (as near as we can tell). This means that "pretty soon" (depending on the original broadcast power) the signal will be orders of magnitude weaker the the noise level in any receiver. There are some techniques to pull up a signal from under the noise floor, eg using matched filters and the like. This is how GPS works. However, can only be done if you already know the signal that you are looking for. For GPS, this is not really a problem since it is well known what signal any given satellite will transmit at any given time. However, with TV shows (or any similarly information dense signal), the signal content is by definition not known already to another civilization. This is not even going into the fact that high-information signals can be pretty indistinguishable from noise anyway if you don't know the exact modulation type and parameters used. Pretty much the only way aliens will be able to enjoy our television broadcasts is if they come close enough to visit the solar system anyway, and by then they might as well land and look at cable TV... (For more information, take a look at http://www.bidstrup.com/seti.htm http://www.bidstrup.com/seti.htm or similar)
- knodi123 10y agoCan we rough out a modified fermi paradox equation that substitutes values for as many constants as possible, and takes into account the issue with the inverse square law vs background noise? Also, can't you distinguish a lot of signal away from noise using parallax and paired telescopes?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 10y agoI think it's ridiculous for us to look for alien civilizations. Why would any intelligent person think that civilizations are stable? I mean, would you really think such a system is stable: Billions of independent sentient planet-polluting evolving biological machines with their own goals continually rewriting their own software (culture) and exponentially increasing their capabilities and rates of change? That has Chaos written all over it. Whatever prospers and lasts in the universe as we know it isn't going to be anything like a civilization. It's certainly going to be nothing like our civilization. In fact, if there is a galactic meta-"society" of some sort, then one should think they'd disdain a chaotic exponentially-expanding civilization in much the same was as we'd individually view an incontinent, incoherent, and violent member of our own species. The fact that we'd expect other civilizations out there is just evidence of our own parochial bias. The stark truth of the Fermi Paradox is that civilizations as we conceive of them simply don't last very long -- which also matches everything we as a civilization have come to know about systems that resemble our civilization. If "we" are going to last, "we" will have become something hard to comprehend and hard to accept by our present day selves. https://xkcd.com/638/ https://xkcd.com/638/ https://xkcd.com/1377/ https://xkcd.com/1377/
- erikpukinskis 10y agoI suspect you come from a culture that portrays itself as disconnected from nature. You think of civilization as a kind of nihilistic growth machine that is totally devoid of meaning. That makes sense. I see a lot of that when I look at the world too. But not every civilization is like that. There is a form of civilization which exists in deference to nature. There is a form of enlightenment which doesn't worship blind reproduction, but instead worships harmony with nature. It sees our role as humans not as an all-conquering virus, but as gardeners, shepherds of life. Not über-wolves, but über-trees. Some people call this "permaculture" but it has lots of other names, and has existed for millennia. I think the culmination of human civilization is to reach a kind of pinnacle of progressive efficiency, combined with an almost regressive reverence for the past and our bodies and the ecologies which sustain them. I suspect other alien life may also be similarly inclined. And this notion you have that planet pollution is the only way to exist is very sad. It's no better than climate denial. It's arguably more destructive, because you are suckering in smart people who would otherwise balk at denialists. I would urge you to spend some time learning about ways of living which nurture ecologies. There many such traditions, spanning every biome.