3 ms·
> "For decades, our leaders in Washington pushed us towards "a global economy" and told us it would be so good for us. But there is a flip side. Now workers i
by potatolicious 17y ago
> "For decades, our leaders in Washington pushed us towards "a global economy" and told us it would be so good for us. But there is a flip side. Now workers in the U.S. must compete with workers all over the world, and our greedy corporations are free to pursue the cheapest labor available anywhere on the globe."
Bias much? For one thing, outsourcing would've happened whether we liked it or not. For another, having worked in manufacturing for a bit, corporations by and large aren't laughing their way to the bank by outsourcing American manufacturing jobs overseas - the cost of their goods drop proportionally with labour savings, in the mid-to-long haul anyhow.
I like how we're blaming this on everyone but ourselves - the outsourcing of manufacturing to cheap nations has allowed us to develop a rampant, disgusting consumer culture that has an almost fetishist obsession with cheap, shoddy goods. WE did that to ourselves. Believe me, if there was any significant demand in this country for expensive, well-made products we can bring a great number of manufacturing jobs back... but I suspect the Wal-Mart mentality is here to stay, and there's no one to blame for this but ourselves.
- necrecious 17y agoThis is a common myth. US is still the largest manufacturer in the world. http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/CompanyFocus/the-myth-of-us-industrys-demise.aspx http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/CompanyFocus/...
- anigbrowl 17y agoBy volume, yes, but perhaps that's not the best metric. See http://www.economist.com/specialreports/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15641021 http://www.economist.com/specialreports/displaystory.cfm?sto... for a more meaningful comparison, although I agree that rumors of the manufacturing sector's demise have been greatly exaggerated.
- enjo 17y agoI'm having trouble finding the chart, but we're also the largest in terms of percentage of GDP. That's a measurement I strongly prefer.
- mpf62 17y agoAccording to CIA World Factbook, you're not the largest in terms of percentage of GDP. At least Germany, Japan, Italy and even Switzerland rank better in that metric. All of these single-metric comparisons are flawed. E.g. the world largest manufacturer? In comparison to what? Germany, a country with a labor force that is over 3 times smaller than the labor force in the US? https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/ https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/
- potatolicious 17y agoIt is, but for how much longer? When I was in the auto industry it certainly looked very bleak - I've since lost touch with most of the people from that time, but I doubt it's looking up now either. One of our chief problems when I was working in the auto supplier industry was relentless cost cutting on the part of the major manufacturers (GM was especially bad in this department) - and from what we knew GM certainly wasn't pocketing the difference, all of the cost cutting went directly into hyper-competitive consumer pricing. As a result our cars are dirt, dirt cheap, unsustainably so, especially if your goal is to keep manufacturing jobs on this side of the ocean. But it's not as if people know this - especially the type like the author of the article, who like to play the victim constantly by making vague straw-man references to the greedy corporation. I cannot count the number of times I've heard people make the point that some product "probably costs nothing to make anyways" - and it bothers me greatly. For just about everything except the high fashion industry, manufacturing costs are not that far divorced from their retail cost... but consumers who believe this hogwash are also liable to believe that outsourcing is due to rampant greed, as opposed to their unquenchable desire for cheap crap.
- robryan 17y agoA lot of the manual labor is taken out though, if my factory is pushing out same 10,000 units of something a day with 25 employees mostly keeping a close eye on the equipment, the other 200 assemblers I would have hired before advances in technology are still out in the cold.