4 ms·
To some extent government is always income redistribution. Even a flat tax rate still takes more money from the rich, in absolute amounts, and uses it to build
by the8472 10y ago
To some extent government is always income redistribution. Even a flat tax rate still takes more money from the rich, in absolute amounts, and uses it to build things and provide services that benefit everyone.
So unless you think all governments should cease to exist you indirectly agree to some level of income redistribution already.
And it's not like subsidizing clean energy infrastructure in developing countries would magically equalize everyone's living standards like communism claimed to do. So it's still fairly limited redistribution.
So where exactly is the problem? You're not saying any more than "fixing the problem will take some money that has to be invested globally, not just locally".
- briandear 10y agoThat's not my point. My point is that climate change policy isn't about climate change, thus I am skeptical about climate change activists because their goal isn't climate, but redistribution. Essentially, they're lying.
- the8472 10y agoAll they're saying is that it'll take more than just a bit of regulating emissions. If anything they're being honest. You're confusing goals and solutions here.
- spdustin 10y agoIt is about climate change. The knock-on effects of the short-term changes made to benefit the climate include wealth redistribution. Stop taking that quote out of context.
- hx87 10y agoThat's an unfalsifiable claim, since no amount of evidence would reduce, much eliminate that skepticism.