2 ms·
I think there are two seemingly-disjoint perspectives in these discussions, mostly based on whether people have enough time and engage with these appliances as
by derefr 10y ago
I think there are two seemingly-disjoint perspectives in these discussions, mostly based on whether people have enough time and engage with these appliances as part of a hobby; or whether they are strapped for time and engage with them as necessities.
So, I think a clarifying assumption might help: assume that you already have a person who acts in the role of the "glue" for your household—a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majordomo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majordomo. Assume that they then have further staff under them, to whom they can delegate tasks—but that they also have the option of purchasing technology to automate the same tasks. Under this assumption, all the tasks in your household will get done, "magically", by combining some degree of technology with some degree of human effort.
The question that's really being asked in these discussions of "smart" appliances is: where is the optimum ROI between "fully automated" and "fully done manually by a paid human expert"? For any given task, how should the majordomo best allocate your dollars between paying labor and buying "smarter" equipment?
Automation usually lowers the total amount of human labor that must be expended (both by the expert, and by you to earn the money to pay the expert), but it also tends to lower the quality of the result—or "confine" the result to certain strict output products—compared to the results the human expert could achieve. How "smart" can we make a tool without taking away its precision to achieve great results in expert human hands? How "dumb" must a tool be to continue to allow for optimal results to be achieved, rather than mere satisfactory ones? Etc.