3 ms·
You should not rely on emergency auto-brake systems anyway! These are systems designed to prevent accidents in case the driver misses something, but NOT for da
by mschuster91 10y ago
You should not rely on emergency auto-brake systems anyway!
These are systems designed to prevent accidents in case the driver misses something, but NOT for daily use!
- icebraining 10y agoAdmonitions don't work; if it works most of the time, people will rely on it for daily use. Either one makes that annoying somehow or it has to be reliable.
- radarsat1 10y ago> You should not rely on emergency auto-brake systems anyway! > > These are systems designed to prevent accidents in case the driver misses something, but NOT for daily use! But you know people _will_. That's what happens with affordances. Design. It changes how people interact with things, and not always in the intended way. It's _very_ important to consider when you're talking about the operation of machines that can kill. Indeed, the presence of emergency brakes could very well reduce the number of accidents, while at the same time making people rather lazy and eventually _causing_ some. Like taking bigger risks on your bicycle when you're wearing a helmet.
- Nadya 10y ago>Indeed, the presence of emergency brakes could very well reduce the number of accidents, while at the same time making people rather lazy and eventually _causing_ some. Is there a psychological term for this thought process? The thought process: People killing people is "okay" but people killing (overall) fewer people because they are relying on "emergency auto-brake systems" is "not okay". For me, it is a no brainer to reduce human casualties as much as possible. But it seems others disagree with that if some automated system is responsible for deaths instead of a human. Is it because blame is harder to place?
- Silhouette 10y agoIs it because blame is harder to place? I suspect that's part of it. Another possibility is that in some cases, these systems may outperform an average driver but not a good one. Removing control or judgement from a good driver in favour of the automated system is then an unnecessary loss. Of course, you also have the problem that around 100% of drivers think they are better than average. The above is a reasonable and valid concern for drivers who actually are better than the alternative automated system, but there's also a problem with other drivers who mistakenly believe they are that good and that the automated system will therefore make them and their passengers less safe.
- Natanael_L 10y agoStatic risk tolerance + altered risk perception. People are only as careful as they think they need to be, because they're lazy. This causes your behavior baseline to change as a result of new safety measures, perhaps too far in the wrong direction. Found this - procedural drift (aviation): http://www.cognitivesystemsdesign.net/Papers/Johnston%20(2003).pdf http://www.cognitivesystemsdesign.net/Papers/Johnston%20(200...
- Nadya 10y agoNot quite what I was thinking of, so I'll make up a scenario and numbers. Take any technology that automates a task. Say it has a 0.00005% failure rate which results in death of a random passerby at the time it occurs. Then take any human being in charge of that same task. Say the risk is 0.05% human error which results in death of a random passerby at the time it occurs. There are people who will argue that the 0.05% is acceptable and will vehemently disagree with and prevent any attempt to switch to the 0.00005% failure rate because the machine killing someone is unacceptable while a human killing 1,000-fold more people is somehow acceptable. Even if human laziness of an assisted (not completely automated) version of the same task had a 0.005% risk it would still be unacceptable when compared with the 100% human-error rate. Morally, I can't wrap my head around the reasoning. More deaths seems to be acceptable as long as some person can be "at fault". The moment the death is "blameless" it cannot be allowed. In other words: 10,000 "someone can be blamed" deaths is better than 10 "who is to blame?" deaths.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhat's the difference between emergency auto-brake and adaptive cruise? I think a charitable interpretation of that driver's actions would be that they expected the car to act like it was adaptive cruising, not that they expected it to abruptly brake for them.
- Animats 10y agoBMW, Mercedes, and Volvo have emergency auto-brake on all the time when installed. Only Tesla only has it on in "autopilot" mode.
- Reason077 10y agoThat's not true. Tesla's AEB and side collision avoidance are always active, regardless of whether Autopilot is on or not.
- Animats 10y agoRead the firmware 6.2 release notes.[1] "Automatic Emergency Braking - a new Collision Avoidance Assist feature — is designed to automatically engage the brakes to reduce the impact of an unavoidable frontal collision. Automatic Emergency Braking will stop applying the brakes when you press the accelerator pedal, press the brake pedal, or sharply turn the steering wheel" In "autopilot" mode, the automatic cruise control prevents you from hitting the car ahead at all. Touch the brake, and you've disabled both Autopilot and Automatic Emergency Braking. Yesterday, that caused another accident.[2] If you drive a Tesla, failure to carefully read firmware release notes can kill you. Compare BMW.[3] [1] https://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/tesla_model_s_software_6_2.pdf https://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/tesla_model_... [2] http://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/05/another-driver-says-teslas-autopilot-failed-to-brake-tesla-says-otherwise/ http://arstechnica.com/cars/2016/05/another-driver-says-tesl... [3] http://www.theverge.com/2015/1/5/7494989/bmw-i3-self-parking-anti-collision-ces-2015 http://www.theverge.com/2015/1/5/7494989/bmw-i3-self-parking...
- Reason077 10y ago