6 ms·
I don't think it's "cars" are getting weird, it's just this one weird Tesla and their business model... The article says: "Cars are big computers, and have be
by walrus01 10y ago
I don't think it's "cars" are getting weird, it's just this one weird Tesla and their business model... The article says:
"Cars are big computers, and have been for a while"
Doesn't mean we need to treat them like software development platforms. Most of the challenges are still at OSI layer 1 and most of the problems to deal with are mechanical: Tire still wear out, disc brakes still function much as they did 10 or 15 years ago (and wear out), wheel bearings, hydraulic systems for power steering, etc.
Given that cars have much longer lifespans than typical consumer electronics, the last thing I want is a car with a built in 10" touchscreen running some ancient version of Android. I'd rather have some sort of standardized modular system where I can put my own tablet-sized computer in an appropriate place and have it get power, audio sync with the car's speakers. Look at the crap infotainment systems built into 2015 and 2016 model Toyotas, Hondas and Nissans and compare it with a good $400 Android 6.x tablet. Do you really want that same un-updated OS and software for ten years?
The idea of the "double DIN" size car stereo mounting location was a good one, but we need something bigger than this, and with standardized cable connectors:
http://www.autodvdgps.com/ebay/ZC620/ebay-3.jpg http://www.autodvdgps.com/ebay/ZC620/ebay-3.jpg
Carmakers, please find a way to separate the 'infotainment' part of the car's computer from the embedded computer that's actually required for the car to run (engine timing/valves, fuel injectors, mixture, emissions monitoring, intake oxygen sensor, etc).
- jacquesm 10y agoYes, but API's for cars are not going to be very popular with the manufacturers, who would like you to pay big $ for their crappy un-upgradeable bs. This is one reason why you'll upgrade your whole car, after all.
- aioprisan 10y agoI would image they'll go through the same evolution that was brought on by the competition from Android devices: cheap, full-features, and massively popular.
- aioprisan 10y agoI would image they'll go through the same evolution that was brought on by the competition from Android devices: cheap, full-features, and massively popular.
- Reason077 10y agothe last thing I want is a car with a built in 10" touchscreen running some ancient version of Android... Do you really want that same un-updated OS and software for ten years? One of the nice things about Tesla is their regular, free software updates. Even the earliest Tesla Model S models can be updated to the latest software. You get all the features that the 2016 Teslas have, except of course where the required hardware is not present (like Autopilot).
- dragontamer 10y agoOr in cases as directly described in the post: like when Tesla uses software-limits to prevent the car from using the whole battery... and charges you $9000 for the rights to use the whole battery as it was designed.
- walrus01 10y agoIn things like smart TVs, smart fridges with LCDs on them, and infotainment systems in cars, this is sadly the exception and not the norm. Hardware-oriented manufacturers push a product out the door and things frequently get little or no updated after that. I'm willing to bet money that in ten years from now, a lot of 2016/2017 model year Toyotas that ship today with some sort of infotainment touchscreen system in them will be still running the exact same software. In fifteen years from now such cars will look as quaint as the cars from the 1980s with full LED dashes: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/db/Vfd_car.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/db/Vfd_car....
- toomuchtodo 10y agoAuto manufacturers are restricted from OTA updates due to agreements with their dealer networks. Tesla has no such restriction.
- kirykl 10y agoNot true http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-36478641 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-36478641
- ultimoo 10y agoAgreed. I recently got a Pioneer 4100 NEX aftermarket CarPlay device fitted in my 2010 Camry just for this. Unfortunately, CarPlay itself has many usability issues that have not allowed me to use the system the way I had imagined.
- kylec 10y agoThis is a bit of a tangent, but could you expand on that? I'm interested in getting CarPlay in my next car, but I'd like to know what some of the limitations and downsides are.
- DKnoll 10y agoAre you on Android? If you are I assume you're referring to being locked into the Pioneer interface and compatible apps. There is actually a way to use the native Android interface if you have a rooted device: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2451980 http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2451980 I do not use this personally, but I was looking into the Pioneer 4100 NEX myself and plan to buy one after finding this workaround.
- a2tech 10y agoI'd love to hear more about this-I have a 2009 Camry hybrid that has a janky screen that I've been thinking about replacing with a more modern audio device.
- koenigdavidmj 10y ago> disc brakes still function much as they did 10 or 15 years ago (and wear out) Actually, regenerative breaking means they last quite a bit longer.
- barrkel 10y agoBrake pads are cheap, discs aren't very cheap but are still reasonable. A regenerative braking system? I'll bet that's a lot more expensive.
- pedrocr 10y agoShouldn't be actually. The regenerative braking system on an electric car is just the regular drive train. The energy just flows in reverse. The wheels drive the transmission that drives the motor that charges the battery.
- Reason077 10y agoIn an electric vehicle, regenerative braking is free. It's just the motor turning kinetic energy into electric energy, rather than the other way around. There aren't really any extra parts or systems involved.
- ansible 10y ago> I'd rather have some sort of standardized modular system where I can put my own tablet-sized computer in an appropriate place and have it get power, audio sync with the car's speakers. Oh my gosh yes! The car should be the peripheral, not the main compute device. Is it a big deal to plug in a 10-year old USB mouse into your computer? No, because that is a well-defined interface. Ditto for some other peripherals. This is what I'd like my car to be. I don't think we'll see that anytime soon though. Unless everyone gets on-board with a Bluetooth standard that exposes sufficient functions to the phone/tablet to be useful.
- kylecordes 10y agoProbably everyone here would like something like this. But the decisions aren't going to be made by the sort of people who read this, they're going to be made by auto marketing executives. Then they're going to operate in an environment regulated according to lobbying by automakers. We're going to get auto electronics with software that becomes obsolete about as fast as a typical Android smart phone. I realistically think that when the major legacy automakers ship something vaguely similar to a Tesla dashboard, the best a buyer can hope for is that it remains vaguely updated for a year or two, and then only critical vehicle safety changes might be made forever thereafter. But you can also look at this and the point of view of carmakers. What an amazing boon to sales. This is a way to finally solve the ultimate problem of selling cars today. A car you make today has to compete with the extremely good car you made five years ago that still works great, still looks great, and is much much cheaper.
- seanp2k2 10y agoThis makes tons of sense, especially in these early days of self-driving vehicles. There are of course enthusiasts who will want nothing to do with self-driving until the very end when their manual gearboxes are ripped from their cold, dead hands, who would honestly prefer precisely zero touch screens in their current and future vehicles (I consider myself part of this group). We're a small minority though, and as evidenced by how many cars are still available in the US with even the option to row your own, I don't think it's going to stop any manufacturer from eliminating the possibility of manual control entirely within the next few decades.
- dv_dt 10y agoI don't even want a modular computer slot - I just want a built-in 'remote' display panel & speakers. Just setup a peripherial that can be wirelessly or usb/lightning cable linked that also transmits the touch info back to my phone and plays sound. Maybe a switch to flip the display to access direct car controls (but really just give me hard-buttons/dials etc for climate control and keep the consumer electronic part simple and separate). Extra points if there's a standard for sending car control api calls back and forth to the phone, but 90% of utility could just be handled with a remote touch display.
- ygjb-dupe 10y agoDo you think those are physical switches in cars with tactile components? All of that UX stuff is still backed by a controller. If they are going to proved a remote display, i would prefer those pieces to be integrated so that if I move my mobile device to a different vehicle, then that vehicle imports my settings. While we are wishing for horses, we might as well make them unicorns :D
- Natanael_L 10y agoThat's basically Android Auto.
- espes 10y agoYou are exactly describing Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
- Natanael_L 10y agoWhy not both? Eventually whatever connection you're using will be dated and considered inefficient crap. Would you want to have to deal with Bluetooth 1.0 today? Use a standard modular platform so you can hook up whatever SoC you like. Whenever the old one gets dated, upgrade it and get all the latest fancy radios.
- dv_dt 10y agoA modular platform is a much fatter interface than a display + touch peripheral. To me larger, more complex interface is more likely to go out of date and focused minimal interfaces last longer. People are still using VGA today, and will be using HDMI/DVI for a long long time. Whatever I carry as a phone is going to be updated much more frequently than my car or even a radio/consumer electronics module in my car.
- WalterBright 10y agoI'd like my car computer software to be re-copied from ROM every time the car is started. The ROMs will only be updateable by someone who has physical access to the car so they can push the physical "write enable" switch. I.e. not a software "write enable" switch.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoJust disconnect or shield the wifi or cell antenna used for remote access. For bonus points plumb in a repeater/firewall to filter any traffic you want.
- Silhouette 10y agoThis is a cute hacker-mindset solution until it voids your warranty and/or you don't get an update you actually did want to keep your car safe. The solution to this issue isn't treating the car manufacturer as a hostile party and trying weird tricks to circumvent their future actions. The solution is ensuring that the car manufacturer isn't hostile in the first place. Ideally I'd like to do that with market forces, but that requires the average consumer to understand a lot more about the technology and its implications than is realistic so they can protect themselves. A more realistic alternative is probably statutory regulation and penalties for non-compliance that can become an existential threat to the manufacturer's business.
- WalterBright 10y agoI'm more concerned with stopping hacker attacks and malware infestations. Hence the physical write-enable switch.
- Silhouette 10y agoI completely agree. I'm firmly in the "do not want" camp with a lot of this stuff. I find very few of the modern electronic distractions to be useful or desirable anyway, and I find approximately none of them useful or desirable enough to justify risking safety, security or privacy.
- OscarCunningham 10y agoSadly these are the exact reasons why it won't be modular. They can force you to buy a new car just by stopping support for its operating system.
- chrismcb 10y agoThe car won't stop working just because they do updating the software. At least in America they have to provide parts for at least 10 years. And eventually they won't be able to continue to yell copyright to prevent people from updating the software
- superuser2 10y agoIf the software is internet-facing (hint: it is) and contains unpatched vulnerabilities, it could easily be made to stop working by a drive-by (hah) script kiddie attack.
- xg15 10y agoThis is actually an interesting question when combined with OTA updates. Could (auto maker of your choice) theoretically supply all the parts you want but deny you from using them via software blocks? Or would that be illegal?
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThere are people with John Deere tractors who claim they can no longer use said tractors because the tractor's owner won't pay for an authorized tech to come out and plug into the tractor. Because farmers have to be frugal. So maybe they can yell copyright. On the other hand, things with engines can hurt people so you cannot allow unconstrained access to that port. Safety, IP and "who owns what" will make things more interesting as things emerge.
- 50CNT 10y agoCars aren't iPhones though. Let's assume that the manufacturer supports the OS for 2 years and let's take the Nissan Versa 2016, which has the lowest cost to own of any car. Sticker Price I found was $12,825 ,so let's go with that. Cost to Own for 5 years I found is $28,855. I assume this includes depreciation and that the car fully depreciates in 5 years. If the car lasts for 2 years, the monthly cost comes down to $796/month. If the car lasts for 5, the monthly cost is $476/month, which is a little more than half. Now this is the most budget new car I could find. Straight up doubles in cost. Or you get the situation where people just decide to drive with the legacy version anyways, which sounds a lot like a literal ton of Windows XP at 50mph. And all because you couldn't come up with a universal plug for car entertainment systems.
- moron4hire 10y agoTheoretically, that standardized system is called CANBUS, but companies like Toyota think it should be encrypted and out of your reach.
- Silhouette 10y agoOf all the innovations in modern auto design, I'm not sure that's the one I'd go for. IIRC, a CAN bus design is essentially a jazz model for connecting different subsystems with no built-in security standards. For some reason, I'm not sure externally connected hardware, OTA-updated software, a vehicle's essential mechanical control systems, and implicitly trusted access from everywhere to everything via a centralised bus is a good combination. Some of the relevant technology is patent-encumbered as well, which is rarely an ideal basis for standardisation and interoperability IMHO.
- ams6110 10y agoI think that's what my old Chrysler had. The one where when it failed, absolutely every electrical accessory went dead at the same time. HVAC, radio, wipers, turn signals, tailights. The only thing that still worked was the engine management computer (it still ran fine) and the headlights which seemed to be wired directly. I think the brake lights also worked but I'm not sure.
- douche 10y agoI would really like a 100% mechanical automobile, with no computers involved, designed such that when something breaks and you're fifty miles away from anything, you can actually crawl underneath and fix it. Analog radio, crank windows, keyhole locks on every door, real guages. I'll concede the electric starter and the windshield wipers, since I'm not that nostalgic for the days of the Model T. Completely off-topic, but if I saw a new truck with the old-style floor-mounted stomp pedal for the dimmer switch, it'd almost be a shut-up-and-take-my-money situation. I cannot comprehend why automakers keep piling more stuff into the steering wheel. Some of the little sedans have handles and buttons coming off them every which way.
- tadfisher 10y agoI've found computer-controlled electronic fuel injection much more reliable than carburetors. And OBDII is very handy for diagnosing mechanical problems, even with the manufacturer idiosyncrasies.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoI sense some rose colored glasses. Cars are so much more reliable than they were even 25 years ago. Reliable and longer lasting. My first car broke down if you looked at it wrong. My current car does not have that problem even though it is just as old/has just as many miles on it than my first car did at the time. Breaking down on the side of the road used to be a common part of my life, now it hasn't happened to me in the last 8 years.
- vlehto 10y agoThe reason for that increased reliability is probably because of pump pressure, not controls. Direct injection has several hundred bar working pressure and a separate filter can be used because of such pressure. Traditional float controlled carburetor probably doesn't work because there is some foreign object stuck in the duct. You cant use heavy filtering because the pressures are almost atmospheric.
- sargun 10y agoWhy would you want that? How often does your car actually break? What computer-controlled components break in it?
- Bromskloss 10y agoI just want a car that still runs even if all its electronics (not really counting ignition here) are fried.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoI had a 2003 Camry. I recently bought a 2nd hand 2014 Camry. I have not done any research, but I swear that the car is magically doing things for me. Eg. When the parking break was on and you forgot and tried to drive, the 2003 had some resistance. On the 2014, it seems that it disengages the brake for you if you are not in Park. Which can be annoying if you have to stop on an incline with traffic. It also seems to regulate your speed in very wet conditions. On a straight road, in moderate rain, it definitely feels like I need to push the accelerator down more to get up to speed. I admit the 2014 model is nicer to drive, but I don't know what will happen if the electronics get fried.
- slededit 10y agoThe speed regulator part is probably the traction control. Mandatory on all 2013 and up models.
- yareally 10y ago> "Carmakers, please find a way to separate the 'infotainment' part of the car's computer from the embedded computer that's actually required for the car to run" They have, sorta (but it's still rather limited in functionality): https://www.android.com/auto/ https://www.android.com/auto/ Android Auto and I believe Apple Car Play both run totally from your phone/tablet, with the car just being a view screen. Thus, you get updates when your phone updates.
- Tiksi 10y ago>I'd rather have some sort of standardized modular system where I can put my own tablet-sized computer in an appropriate place and have it get power, audio sync with the car's speakers I did pretty much this in my car, and it was surprisingly easy. ~7 inch tablets are just about the same size as Double DIN radios, so a little but of modification to the mounting bracket, some wiring, and a used Nexus 7 I picked up on ebay got me this: http://paste.click/RILfPr http://paste.click/RILfPr It's hooked into the car's speakers via a USB dac and a small amp, and pulls sensor data from the OBDII port with a cheap bluetooth scantool, but otherwise is completely independent of the car's systems. Turns on and off instantly with the car's power thanks to Timur's Kernel (super low power standby really, but the battery drains isn't much different than having it completely off). I also attached a wireless remote via OTG so I don't have to mess with the touchscreen for simple things like volume and media controls while driving. So it's definitely a viable option. I'm surprised no one has come out with a standardized D-DIN to <popular tablet> bracket yet.
- seanp2k2 10y agoSadly, this is unlikely to happen since car makers can up sell cars based on the software they ship with. Aside from bugs, there's little motivation to ever update that or release newer versions compatible with older models. We even see the same forces in action with the aforementioned android tablets. Consider how long the typical manufacturer releases android upgrades for a given model. It's typically a year or less.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoHow about we don't have "infotainment" in cars? The cumudgeonly John Muir ( who wrote "Volkswagen Maintenance for the Compleat Idiot") is on record as saying cars would be safest if "... drivers were strapped to the front like an Aztec sacrifice" (paraphrased). Exploits to take over cars through the infotainment systems only reinforce my prejudice.