4 ms·
Does anybody have experience with other cross platform GUI toolkits that are still actively developed? It's starting to feel like Qt is going to win it all beca
by criddell 10y ago
Does anybody have experience with other cross platform GUI toolkits that are still actively developed? It's starting to feel like Qt is going to win it all because they are enduring (and excellent).
- darthmaule2 10y agoThis is pretty amazing to me: http://www.noesisengine.com/ http://www.noesisengine.com/
- criddell 10y agoThat looks pretty neat. Have you used it? Can it be set to use native widgets?
- darthmaule2 10y agoI have used it, but for an embedded application, so I'm not sure about native widgets as mine were all custom. We ported part of a poor performing WPF application to use NoesisGUI (because NoesisGUI uses Xaml and emulates the WPF api) and had a lot of success with it.
- RotsiserMho 10y agohiro (https://gitlab.com/higan/higan/tree/master/hiro https://gitlab.com/higan/higan/tree/master/hiro) by byuu (http://byuu.org http://byuu.org) is similar to libui in that it wraps native controls. It isn't quite stable but it's very interesting. I love the simplicity of the API.
- pjmlp 10y agoI had a bad experience with Qt on Android as I had to replicate in QML the native widgets and write JNI wrappers myself. In the end it was more productive to use Java and C++/CX for the views and plain standard C++ for the business logic. However this was in the 5.4 days and I am looking forward to test it again.
- distances 10y agoI'm not convinced that a single UI is desirable for mobile apps. Sure makes sense to share the business logic if you can, but I feel shared UI code will lead to usability compromises.
- zerr 10y agoYes, last time I tested it (several months or a year ago), native look of widgets was great out of the box. One thing I wish - if they had exposed all the QML to C++... i.e. to be able to write only in C++, including UI declarations and callbacks.
- tehrei 10y agoHTML+javascript. Wrap your application in a custom browser instance, have all the ease of developing a GUI in CSS and all the joy of supporting multiple platforms.
- zura 10y agoWhile it doesn't have a similar commercial backing, wxWidgets is still going strong and is quite solid.
- feiss 10y agoI always wondered why, after all these years, the only alternatives that remain are wxWidgets and Qt. It's a very common pattern, multiplatform gui programming! and after all this time, we only have 2 choices..
- RotsiserMho 10y agoIt's an incredibly fast moving target. Just look at the GTK mess, let alone keeping a wrapper toolkit up to date with other vendors' OS updates. Plus for operating systems like Windows it's not really clear which GUI technology to wrap. All the wrappers I've seen so far wrap the old school Win32 API but many modern applications are written in WPF or WinRT. Supporting all three would be difficult. Also OS X is a somewhat different beast in terms of human interface guidelines and form layouts so it's really tough to come up with a unified abstraction layer that both supports new operating system features (and UI paradigms) and still provides a reasonably-sized API.
- vram22 10y ago>Also OS X is a somewhat different beast in terms of human interface guidelines and form layouts so it's really tough to come up with a unified abstraction layer that both supports new operating system features (and UI paradigms) and still provides a reasonably-sized API. Good point indeed.
- distances 10y ago> All the wrappers I've seen so far wrap the old school Win32 API but many modern applications are written in WPF or WinRT. Supporting all three would be difficult. Worth noting here that Qt does not wrap the native widgets, it implements its own widgets that are skinned in each platform's native style.
- 10y ago
- gulpahum 10y agolibui [1] is a promising new cross platform GUI toolkit. If I need a GUI for a small cross platform desktop app, I will definitely try it. It uses MIT license, which means there is less headache for commercial applications. It is also more lightweight. I have always felt that Qt has a lot of unnecessary classes. libui has C api, but it would be easy to write a nice c++11 wrapper around it. [1] https://github.com/andlabs/libui https://github.com/andlabs/libui
- lossolo 10y agoIt has Go wrapper, super easy to use https://github.com/andlabs/ui https://github.com/andlabs/ui
- criddell 10y agoThanks for the pointer. I'm going to watch that project and if it gets to the point where it's settled enough to document, I'll take a deeper look.
- jventura 10y agolibui is a very interesting project but I find it still pretty much alpha: good enough for playing around with it, but not quite ready for production. However it is moving fast, so who knows its state in a few months.. Btw, I'm slowly building a python wrapper (1) and accepting contributions! (1) - https://github.com/joaoventura/pylibui https://github.com/joaoventura/pylibui
- maccard 10y agoNot exactly the same, but you can use CEF - write your UI in html/css/js.