2 ms·
The FreeNAS version I was using had the bug wrt hot spares... and I didn't use ECC... The errors also weren't clear which drive was failing... was 0 in some pla
by tracker1 10y ago
The FreeNAS version I was using had the bug wrt hot spares... and I didn't use ECC... The errors also weren't clear which drive was failing... was 0 in some places 1 in others, and it turns out it was both. The LSI board I was using apparently had some buggy issues as well.
That combined with using Seagate 7200 rpm drives in a year that was particularly bad (an offline storage company mentioned them in a blog article iirc). just a bad chain of events. The drives when I pulled out and tested them individually after the entire array crashed, about 7 out of 12 had significant issues, and of the other 5, 2 more developed errors shortly after (I only used them as scratch/project drives).
Honestly, today, I'd probably get another Synology box, a bit more expensive, but been so much less hassle. I had upgraded my 4-drive (2010 plus model iirc) synology box to 4TB wd red drives, and been running that ever since. I don't think I'd ever do a homebrew NAS on a single machine ever again. If I had to do something in a company, would probably lean towards distributed file systems for that level of redundancy.
- colejohnson66 10y agoWere there Baracuda 7200.11? That firmware version was notorious for corruption
- tracker1 10y agoIIRC, yes... horrible drives.
- lmm 10y agoWere you not scrubbing at all? (Blaming FreeNAS rather than you if so - but if one's doing it by hand following the ZFS HOWTOs it's definitely something that's impressed on one to set up).
- tracker1 10y agoWhen I use a NAS software, that's meant to be a NAS, I expect it to do maintenance that's required. I don't expect to have to be an expert in ZFS. By the same note, I don't expect to have to know what the storage and growth configurations of AWS RDS instances either. My Synology NAS device has been in service for around 6 years now... I upgraded the drives from 4x1tb to 4x4TB when the freenas server bit the dust... and it's still going strong... I don't have to think about it, it just sits there and runs.... A single-purpose software like this should do its' job. The end.
- lmm 10y agoAgreed. I just think it's not really fair to say that ZFS lost your data, if the main cause was that FreeNAS uses/configures ZFS in a way directly contrary to the ZFS documentation.