9 ms·
FBI says utility pole surveillance cam locations must be kept secret
- JadeNB 10y agoIn the "boy who killed parents pleads for mercy as an orphan" department: > Winn, meanwhile, wrote to Judge Jones that the location information about the disguised surveillance cams should be withheld because the public might think they are an "invasion of privacy."
- ivanca 10y agoIt's the year 2034, the FBI just killed 168 unarmed Americans. It claims that disclosing the reason why they were killed may scare off similar targets. A warrant to do the killings was avoided due to similar concerns.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoClearly there needs to be Yellow "FBI Surveillance" stickers you can put on utility poles. Put the stickers on all the poles and note the ones the FBI takes off, build your geo database and add it to OpenStreetMap!
- mirimir 10y agoHow can they be detected? Just visually? Radio link?
- x1798DE 10y agoI think he means that you put stickers on every utility pole and see which ones they take down to "keep their secret". Unless you mean how do you detect utility poles, in which case visually should suffice ;)
- mirimir 10y agoI doubt that the FBI is that stupid. But seriously, it'd be cool if someone could share a photo of one.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThat is exactly what I'm suggesting, and don't put it past the FBI to not think things through. If it was too obvious if all the poles got tagged you could do them slowly over time.
- mirimir 10y agoRight, just keep hitting them at random, and see which ones disappear the fastest. But you'd need to crowd-source it, and build an app so people could quickly geo-tag as they apply them. I can't imagine that putting stickers on utility poles is illegal ;)
- Navarr 10y agoIt probably actually is illegal under something like "defacing public (maybe private?) property" and just not enforced. But might be for something like this
- mirimir 10y agoRight. I used to put up posters for stuff, and people did say that it was illegal to put them on utility poles. But everyone did.
- Johnny555 10y agoIf they look anything like the cameras in these articles, they are easy to spot - a big white box with a glass covered lens slot on the side: http://www.dailytech.com/Federal+Court+Cops+Cant+Spy+on+Your+Yard+and+Home+Without+Warrant/article37002.htm http://www.dailytech.com/Federal+Court+Cops+Cant+Spy+on+Your... https://sipseystreetirregulars.blogspot.com/2011/04/smile-youre-on-candid-camera-cameras.html https://sipseystreetirregulars.blogspot.com/2011/04/smile-yo...
- aaron695 10y agohttp://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/srp-removes-mystery-box-from-power-pole-after-phoenix-homeowners-complaint-8174824 http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/srp-removes-mystery-box-... http://www.kcbd.com/story/31589368/only-on-kcbd-lpl-lpd-address-surveillance-cameras-on-utility-poles http://www.kcbd.com/story/31589368/only-on-kcbd-lpl-lpd-addr... For sale http://www.covert-systems.com/sale_items/pole_cam_VP2c_2450.html http://www.covert-systems.com/sale_items/pole_cam_VP2c_2450.... http://www.app-techs.com/video-surveillance/covertsentry.asp http://www.app-techs.com/video-surveillance/covertsentry.asp
- mirimir 10y agoThe KCBD ones are fairly small. And the Covert-Systems.com one is clever, but would take dangerous work to install properly. But then, it could maybe communicate via power grid.
- mirimir 10y agoThese are huge! Why not use little ones?
- splitdisk 10y agoProblem is the FBI will see people doing this, and most likely profile/track these individuals... Wait, you're one of them aren't you!
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIf they're on all the poles, the FBI has no reason to take them off.
- Aloha 10y agoIf these cameras had a warrant attached to them, there would be no question that the locations should remain secret - I fail to understand why its so hard to get a warrant for this kind of surveillance - but I am at least somewhat understanding (its kind of obvious) why the camera locations should remain a secret. I'd rather see my government operating above the board (even if the records are sealed until trial) rather than casting a wide net and throwing back what they ought not have caught later.
- themartorana 10y agoThis assumes they're throwing anything back. They're not. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/30/nsa-americans-metadata-year-documents https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/30/nsa-americans-...
- ternbot 10y agoThere is one at 12th and Denny on Cap Hill (unless they took it down) - solution - use Snapchat - ID basic form of box - pachao
- freehunter 10y agoA paintball could cover the camera lens pretty nicely.
- knodi123 10y agoBut those cameras are FBI agents, and now you're pointing a weapon at a federal officer. If you think courts would never declare an inanimate object to be an FBI agent, then you'd probably also be shocked to hear there was a court case titled "United States v. Article Consisting of 50,000 Cardboard Boxes More or Less, Each Containing One Pair of Clacker Balls".
- talmand 10y agoThat's not even close to the same thing. But destruction of government property is a crime.
- knodi123 10y agoof course not. it's mildly satirical. but for the record, I didn't say they were the same, I just implied that, clearly, bizarre legal theories about the personhood of objects are not off the table.
- themartorana 10y ago"If the public knows X, we won't be able to use X without the public's knowledge. Further, the public might demand we get a warrant to use X, making using X without a warrant more difficult." Well then... I guess everything the FBI does should be withheld from public scrutiny because national security.
- tdy721 10y agoI'm interested to see how the British handle this. There are certainly lots of cameras in London, but I believe they are rather conspicuous. Perhaps this is more about protecting technology than knowledge? Like, it's not about location, it's about the method.
- Symbiote 10y agoI don't know if there's a national list, but one FOI request to one council in London got results. (Most cameras are private, for example in a shop. I don't know if anyone has a list of these.) https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/fixed_cctv_camera_locations_12 https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/fixed_cctv_camera_loc...
- dingaling 10y ago> I'm interested to see how the British handle this CCTV with a view of public areas in the UK are generally labelled with the operating agency's name and contact details. Per the Information Commissioner's Office: You must let people know when they are in an area where a surveillance system is in operation. https://ico.org.uk/media/for-organisations/documents/1542/cctv-code-of-practice.pdf https://ico.org.uk/media/for-organisations/documents/1542/cc...
- vidarh 10y agoAs others have pointed out, most CCTV in the UK is private, and very little of it is networked, so they are rarely accessed. Even so, if you capture the public (you run a shop or other venue that invites the public in, or you have a camera capturing areas beyond your property), you need to label your cameras, and you will be subject to the Data Protection Act (and in a wider context, this is an implementation of the EU Data Protection Directive, so similar laws apply in all EU countries, though details may vary). This means that you need to regularly assess whether there is an objective need for the camera, and register your data controller with the Information Commissioners Office. You'll need to have clear procedures for how you handle the data to ensure compliance. You need to ensure the data is stored securely. You need to ensure the public can't see monitors showing the camera feeds unless the cameras are placed in public in the immediate vincinity (e.g. store cameras with visible monitors are fine; visible monitors with camera feeds from elsewhere is not without ensuring people are not recognisable) You also need to deal with Subject Access Requests - basically anyone can file a request with you to obtain copies of footage of themselves, with minor restrictions, within 40 days, and charging no more than 10 pounds. Public authorities are further subject to Freedom of Information requests. And you need to ensure retention is as short as possible for your intended use. So while we're filmed a lot, there are lots of safeguards and a lot of the restrictions are aimed at making it beneficial to retain as little as possible for as short as possible (e.g. if you only have a 24h loop you save yourself the hassle of anyone filing a subject access notice more than 24h after they believe they were filmed) Doesn't mean I like it, but most of the time when the high amount of UK CCTV is brought up, people have a very skewed idea of the actual impact it has because it seems people have this idea of widespread networked government monitored cameras, while most of them are only rarely ever looked after a crime has occurred.
- a_e_k 10y agoI should think the "no expectation of privacy in a public space" principle cuts both ways.
- th0waway 10y agoyeah, it would be interesting to crowd source surveillance of a high-profile public official, and place the info on the Internet. After all - if there's no expectation of privacy, it does cut both ways, right? But I'm sure there would be some law somewhere that would be brought into play.
- Dr_tldr 10y agoThis is pretty shocking and should be more widely publicized. A government agency covertly spying on the public with no warrants, no disclosures, and a fundamental lack of accountability rarely ends well. Even worse, both parties and most of the state and federal government bureaucracy are in fundamental agreement about the need for a national security state, only disagreeing about some of the implementation details. People in tech are in the best position to create some pushback on this, be it through lobbying as stubbornly single-issue voters, or creating some direct (legal) technical counter-measures. It's not that hard to tell which ones are bugged if you inspect the light poles closely, and threatening to imprison people who take pictures of public lightpoles would almost certainly create more backlash than they're willing to risk.
- CamperBob2 10y agoThey're not doing anything Google isn't doing. Public streets are fair game for anyone with a camera, and that includes the police. It's best if that doesn't change.
- xoa 10y ago>Public streets are fair game for anyone with a camera, and that includes the police. It's best if that doesn't change. While this logic, the "no expectation of privacy" principle, has long been the standard, and is certainly the logic law enforcement and businesses like Google push hard, I think we really do need to have a public discussion and consideration of how technology enabled Emergent Effects, with emphasis, creates new phenomena that are simply completely beyond the realm of human-oriented common sense that was operated under before. Yes, any single human has always in principle been able to happen to see an individual instance of something in view of public property, or follow somebody around, at any point throughout human history. With the advent of the camera, they could even possibly make a clearer, permanent record of that, but that didn't really change much either. Even simple basic video tape was a true shift. But the ever increasing volume of storage and processing available at ever shrinking cost, combined with similar cost/quality improvements in sensors, objectively changes the situation. Even if it's 100% purely on public property where there is "no expectation of privacy" and involves nothing but video, a ubiquitous surveillance system plugged in to sufficient persistent storage and data processing creates capabilities that are on a different level. It equates to effective location tracking of any individual for a start, but additionally allows inferences to be drawn about everyone they meet with. It becomes possible to start back tracking people's relationship network graphs, and discerning all sorts of higher level private information. The most simple classic example would be knowing John Doe visited a private residence late at night with Jane Doe who is not his wife in a repeated pattern, and boom, blackmail material, but it could easily be used to make high-accuracy judgements on everything from health issues to private interests to overall group memberships. This is a huge amount of potential power, and it's objectively something very very different from having a single warrant for an individual and having some investigators try to follow them around. Resource usage matters: in the end, all security is fundamentally an economic equation. If an adversary, or even an agency that nominally is supposed to be on "our side" can suddenly do a technique 100000x cheaper and more effectively then it cannot necessarily be judged by old standards. Emergent effects or properties that do not exist in a lesser collection of individual parts are a huge deal in all parts of our world, and they're becoming a big deal for information now too. We really should not just allow "well, the police/military intel/investigators/big data corp are only doing what any individual could except a billion times more" to go unchallenged, because that "except a billion times more" is a huge deal. No, an individual human could never do that sort of thing themselves, or even with a huge group. Even the biggest, best funded police states of a half century ago, using far more intrusive techniques, couldn't manage the kind of efficient ubiquitous population categorization, information gathering and tracking now becoming possible "merely" through what's available from the sight of public roads. Don't dismiss what a change omniscience makes. I really hope the courts start to recognize that at some point what government is asking for is not a simple extension of what they've always had, it's something entirely new.
- kristopolous 10y agoI'm curious if these have infrared "night vision" as many CCTVs do. If so, looking for infrared spotlights may be a good idea
- toomanythings2 10y agoI believe England still has the largest number of video surveillance cameras in the world, owned and operated by the government.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Houshalter 10y agoIt's nothing a passerby nailed to a utility pole can't see!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Hondor 10y agoWe can't ban the government from doing what private businesses and people can already do. Otherwise they can simply buy the data off private companies who have cameras on private buildings.
- hobs 10y agoMany times with businesses they just ask nicely, and to maintain good relationships they just hand it over (because they are not the topic of the investigation.) The thing is, they mostly dont keep months of footage, its too expensive to store that much.
- carlmcqueen 10y agoFrom hacker news stories I've now seen that FBI has shell company planes flying over major cities, cameras on the utility poles and wants root un-encrypted access to our phones. Scary.
- Houshalter 10y agoI actually support the surveillance planes. It seems much less invasive than the public surveillance cameras that are becoming ubiquitous. They can't identify faces or cars, just see where people move to after a crime. I'd like some protections on it though. Like deleting the data after 5 days, or requiring a warrant to look at it. No one should look at live. And the cameras shouldn't be better than what google maps or a person in a low flying plane could see. It makes it possible to solve a huge number of crimes much easier. People spend so much energy living in fear of crime. Kids aren't allowed outside anymore, housing is segregated, etc. Irrational or not, anything that decreases people's fear without being too invasive is a huge positive.
- mattnewton 10y ago>> It seems much less invasive than the public surveillance cameras that are becoming ubiquitous. They can't identify faces or cars yet >> Irrational or not, anything that decreases people's fear without being too invasive is a huge positive. I don't think people really live in that much fear, or should. I also don't want their fear to dictate what my definition of invasive is.
- whoopdedo 10y agoViolent crime in the U.S. may be like Lisa Simpson's "bear rock". The if-it-bleeds-it-leads media makes crime appear to be more common than it actually is. The public then ask for law enforcement to protect them from this threat. When they see the low rates of violent crime around them, they assume it's a result of the increased policing.
- Joof 10y agoThe planes aren't bad, but likely set a precedent for drone surveillance.
- ceejay 10y agoSomeone should make an app, crowdsource the effort to locate the cameras.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoI really have no problem with this -- provided the FBI goes in front of a judge with probable cause and gets a warrant. This is secret and that's what really bothers me.
- Roboprog 10y agoYou know we've gone off the rails a bit when the authorities feel they have to automate 24x7 surveillance to watch for things that the neighbors otherwise don't give one rat shit about. (nobody is complaining about anything, but we're still looking for a way to take down "those people", for a given unpopular group of the day) E.g. - the War on Drugs going from somehow (merely) "keeping the peace" to Zero Tolerance and zero sense.
- new_hackers 10y agoWhat do you expect? It's the push from the "never again" crowd. Sandy hook, Boston marathon, San Bernardino, and Orlando to name a few. People are so scared of the big bad terrorist that they are more than happy to be watched 24/7. If you have nothing to hide then what's the problem?
- pella 10y agoopenstreetmap - tag statistics (surveillance:type=camera ) http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/surveillance%3Atype=camera#map http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/surveillance%3Atype=ca...
- Vexs 10y agoIs it just me, or does the TV show "Person of Interest" seem to get one step closer to reality every day, minus the all controlling AIs.
- noir_lord 10y ago> minus the all controlling AIs. Give them time.
- Vexs 10y agoIs it just me, or does the TV show "Person of Interest" seem to get one step closer to reality every day, minus the all controlling AIs.