4 ms·
Regardless of what you think about the events that transpired, this thread is a perfect example of censorship and self-censorship. There's a clear trend here a
by antisthenes 10y ago
Regardless of what you think about the events that transpired, this thread is a perfect example of censorship and self-censorship.
There's a clear trend here among the posts that get downvoted, and while it is within the rules and spirit of the site to do so, it is at the very least ironic that supposed anarchists and libertarians, who so vehemently oppose centrally mandated censorship are perfectly fine when that happens to advance a narrative they agree with, through an echo-chamber which essentially works as the central authority.
That certainly takes away what little credence there was left to their idea about a stateless society and doesn't paint a pretty picture to the magnitude of a delusion required to somehow, in one's mind, to convince themselves that mob justice is better than the rule of law.
How many people are afraid to speak out here, despite disagreement?
- nkurz 10y agoThere's a clear trend here among the posts that get downvoted, and while it is within the rules and spirit of the site to do so, it is at the very least ironic that supposed anarchists and libertarians, who so vehemently oppose centrally mandated censorship are perfectly fine when that happens to advance a narrative they agree with, through an echo-chamber which essentially works as the central authority. Quoting the punchline of a common joke, "No, we can only conclude that there is at least one field, containing at least one sheep, of which at least one side is black." What evidence leads you to conclude that the self-described anarchists and libertarians approve of centrally mandated censorship? Unless you have non-public knowledge of individual HN voting patterns (and are willing to assume that downvotes accurately reflect a desire to censor) it seems like an unwarranted leap to go from a handful of anonymous internet downvotes to decrying the hypocrisy of both movements.
- zorpner 10y agoHow many people are afraid to speak out here, despite disagreement? What, with the horrible consequence of being downvoted looming over them? Probably a lot fewer than are afraid to speak out about charismatic abusers who have threatened to ruin their personal and professional lives if they speak out. This is a pretty classic example of a common phenomenon -- to paraphrase Alana Massey, people often mistake the discomfort of being confronted with their own violence for the suffering they caused by it. Appelbaum's "victimization" isn't remotely close to the suffering of the his victims.
- Nadya 10y ago>What, with the horrible consequence of being downvoted looming over them? Probably a lot fewer than are afraid to speak out about charismatic abusers who have threatened to ruin their personal and professional lives if they speak out. Downvoted? How about losing your job. Speak out and if your account has your Twitter handle, email, employer, etc. that many HN'ers share (or indirectly share by using the same handle on other sites) - risk having an ideological hate mob targeting you and lighting a metaphorical fire under your employer's ass until you get laid off because they disagree with your beliefs? Shit that has been happening in increasing amounts in the past decade. Plenty of people with the "wrong thoughts" self-censor or remain psuedonymous or anonymous to share their "real" thoughts. The defense for attacking these people is almost always "They are a bigot/sexist/racist/transphobe/Islamiphobe/___ist/___phobe", often without actual evidence or relying on a he-said/she-said. Which is just a "morally correct" version of attacking someone for their beliefs and opinions. With very few lines and exceptions - I do not think anyone should lose their jobs for having their own beliefs and opinions. It's a very dangerous line to walk. >Appelbaum's "victimization" isn't remotely close to the suffering of the his victims. Innocent until proven guilty has been tossed to the side I see.