4 ms·
> but the article says the 40 pound engine makes 6.5 horsepower. So? Every production car engine today weighs more than 40 pounds and makes more than 6.5 hors
by kbenson 10y ago
> but the article says the 40 pound engine makes 6.5 horsepower.
So? Every production car engine today weighs more than 40 pounds and makes more than 6.5 horsepower. That doesn't obviate the need to lighter engines, even if they are less powerful.
> Also, one costs $50 and the other probably $50,000.
Doubtful (and where are you getting $50k from?). You can see most of what goes into the engine in the video. Their advances seem to be mostly process and shape changes, not due to some space age material. It may cost $1000 in its current incarnation, but that's what you get when you manually machine all the parts instead of have them mass produced.
- whamlastxmas 10y ago1. My point was that it wasn't a replacement. It's not even capable of getting half the power. Hence my claim that the title was clickbait, it's patently false. That's like saying I invented a replacement motor for the Bugatti Veyron at half the cost, oh by the way it makes 400 horsepower instead of 1000. 2. Again it's my demonstration of clickbait. A 40 pound engine that makes 6.5 horsepower will never be replaced by an engine featured in the article. At least, not in the next several decades. An engine that weighs 40 pounds and makes 6.5 horsepower is called a lawnmower engine. It's cheap to make and maintain and people use it because it's affordable. People aren't going to replace their $50 lawn mower engine with one that's $1000.
- kbenson 10y agoI'm not sure why you think replacing an engine has to entail having the exact same performance as before. > That's like saying I invented a replacement motor for the Bugatti Veyron at half the cost, oh by the way it makes 400 horsepower instead of 1000. You can. What's wrong with that. Maybe there's something else about the engine that makes it noteworthy, such as it being electric? In this case, it's a way to showcase specific aspects of the engine, it's size and weight. > A 40 pound engine that makes 6.5 horsepower will never be replaced by an engine featured in the article. Might it be replaced by two 4 pound engines with a total of 6 horsepower for 8 pounds? Or maybe three for 9 horsepower for 12 pounds? Perhaps the efficiency can scale and they can do a single motor for ~9 horsepower and ~12 pounds? > It's cheap to make and maintain and people use it because it's affordable. It's cheap because it's mass produced. You can't compare how useful this engine is to existing engines without considering the cost when built at the expected scale. > People aren't going to replace their $50 lawn mower engine with one that's $1000. I'll just repeat myself with inflection: "It may cost $1000 in its current incarnation, but that's what you get when you manually machine all the parts instead of have them mass produced."
- toss1 10y agoActually the current "development kit" starts at USD$30,000 http://liquidpiston.com/dev-kit/ http://liquidpiston.com/dev-kit/
- kbenson 10y agoThat seems to include IP licensing as well, since it stipulates any new IP will be jointly owned. It's sort of like licensing a new engine design from a major automaker (e.g. Ford) along with any proprietary technology they implement, with the agreement that any advances you make are jointly shared by you and the licensor. This might be a good deal for an F1 racing team or something, but doesn't really relate in any meaningful way to how much the auto company will charge for their engine to regular consumers.
- microcolonel 10y agoI don't think they mean you get the IP. I think they mean they get the IP you generate while conducting research on the engine; though I seriously doubt much will be created with a clause that says you can't reverse-engineer it!
- kbenson 10y agoThe purchaser agrees that any intellectual property that results of any development on the engine will belong jointly to LiquidPiston. I read that as shared, as you can't jointly own something as one party. There are probably more explicit terms on something you have to sign.
- microcolonel 10y agoI read it to say that they will jointly, with you, own new IP that you generate during research on the engine. That is to say, you own the IP from your own research by default, and the license says they will own it too.
- 10y ago