6 ms·
I saw this a couple of years ago, its a pretty nice rotary engine. As others have pointed out, rotary engines have their challenges but their advantage in weigh
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I saw this a couple of years ago, its a pretty nice rotary engine. As others have pointed out, rotary engines have their challenges but their advantage in weight and torque still makes them a good choice for aircraft.
The "secret sauce" that the Liquid Piston folks bring to the party is the upgraded rotor shape. It doesn't need apex seals like the old Wankel version did. The news here is that they had reduced their experimental work into an actual functional engine. Unlike the Wankel, their cylinder design would really support a compact multi-rotor engine but presumably you could gang them together on the same crankshaft if you really wanted to.
Other than the UAV and possibly the paramotor market I'm not sure where these guys are going to find customers though.
- sgt101 10y agoI'm going to get laughed at.. but the first thing I thought of was lawn tractor! A lighter tractor would be less of an issue to wrangle about a garden, it would consume less fuel shifting itself about, domestic ones get relatively few engine hour... a smaller engine might allow novel designs that get into tighter corners are simpler and cost less... You need ~10hp for a lawn tractor as is soooooo...
- zodPod 10y agoThe only problem that I could see there is that you actually kind of need weight on a tractor. You take a 500lb tractor and take out the 150lb engine you're getting a lot closer to the weight of the driver and you're upping the possibility of tipping over significantly.
- kbob 10y agoChainsaws and weed-whackers might be good applications.
- nine_k 10y agoImagine powering an exoskeleton with it.
- prodmerc 10y agoIf they can keep the size/weight, go to 5 HP AND make it cheap, this would be perfect for chainsaws, brush cutters/trimmers, blowers, and lots of other portable gas-powered tools... Hell, even small portable generators. The problem I see is that existing engines are already good enough and cheap, so it could be a hard sell for manufacturers.
- Shivetya 10y agoI wonder how loud it is compared to traditional engines
- karmakaze 10y ago"the X2 engine is exceptionally quiet because it burns all of its fuel. In current ICE engines, an alarming amount of fuel goes out the tailpipe. This not only cuts down on fuel efficiency and pollutes the air, it also makes the engine noisy. Since the X2 engine burns its fuel completely, there’s no need for complicated silencing apparatus. (Update: The engine runs quietly due to not needing poppet valves.)"[0] [0] http://www.gizmag.com/liquidpistol-rotary/24623/ http://www.gizmag.com/liquidpistol-rotary/24623/
- DrScump 10y agoIf true, that would also cut emissions significantly compared to a conventional 2-stroke.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe challenge with that comment from 2012, is that the go cart video from 2016 is pretty noisy. Easily 90 to 100db from the sound on the video. https://vimeo.com/170502635 https://vimeo.com/170502635
- userbinator 10y agoIn current ICE engines, an alarming amount of fuel goes out the tailpipe. This not only cuts down on fuel efficiency and pollutes the air, it also makes the engine noisy. The "an alarming amount of fuel goes out the tailpipe" is reminiscent of the wording associated with various fuel-saver scam gadgets. In practice, this is measured in HC emissions, which are usually in the low tens of PPM range on a properly tuned engine. Disregarding mechanical sources, engine noise is largely caused by the high-pressure gases flowing out the exhaust with pulsations on each power stroke. The distinctive beating of a low-cylinder-count engine e.g. a motorcycle is entirely this phenomenon. To attribute the noise of a properly functioning (i.e. not backfiring) engine to "unburned fuel" is completely wrong.
- sporkologist 10y ago> UAV There are a lot of customers there these days.
- stcredzero 10y agoGiven that they are targeting very high efficiency, and they have very low weight, what about something with just a little bit more than the power output to cover highway cruising speeds? With the properties this has, it would make a great range extender.
- MechSkep 10y agoLooks good for robotics applications. The power density is comparable to the low end of brushless motors, and it can use hydro-carbon fuels which are about 25 times more energy dense than current batteries. At 3 hp, it might be a reasonable drop in for the type of weed-whacker two-stroke that drives big dog.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThis is certainly something to consider, and for robots or exoskeletons the power density would make for a pretty compelling solution. I'd be curious to try out its low RPM torque, that was always a challenge on the RX-7, starting in first gear you spun up the engine to 2 - 3K RPM before you let the clutch out.
- ryanmarsh 10y agoHow many watts can you reasonably generate with 3 hp?
- userbinator 10y agoApproximately 2237.
- geon 10y agoI was going to nitpick about efficiency of the generator not being 100 %, but apparently a generator can be 99 % effective.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoYeah, if you start from the break HP of the motor, pretty much all the work can be converted into electricity. If you start from the energy in the fuel, and go all the way to the generator, its like 50%.
- hinkley 10y agoI'm curious. With the air chamber in the cylinder head, why can't they fire 3 charges of fuel per revolution instead of 2? I would think with some appropriate valve configuration they could do that and it would simplify heat and torque problems. Maybe they'd need 2 air chambers for that (but then the counterweight wouldn't be necessary).
- hinkley 10y agoOops! I found a different video that shows three spark plugs. I'm not sure what was going on with the first video I watched.
- whalesalad 10y agoI always thought torque was an incredible weakness of rotary engines.
- ekekekekekekl 10y agoRotary engine advantage in torque? This is nonsense. The Wankel's design limits the eccentricity of the crank shaft which consequently limits torque to relatively low levels compared to a contemporary piston engine of similar fuel consumption. There is no torque advantage to a Wankel, it's at a disadvantage.